Home / Transcripts / Australian Ethical Investment Limited (AEF) · August 29, 2024

Australian Ethical Investment Limited (AEF) Earnings Call Transcript

August 29, 2024

Australian Securities Exchange AU Financials Capital Markets earnings 36 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator operator
#1

Thanks for holding, and welcome to the Australian Ethical FY 2024 Full Year Results Briefing. Everyone is currently in listen-only mode. A presentation will come first, and after that we'll hold a question and answer session. Should you wish to ask something, please join the webcast, type your question into the Ask a Question box, and hit Submit. At this point I'll pass the conference to Melanie Hill, Head of Investor Relations. Over to you.

Melanie Hill executive
#2

Thanks, and good morning to all of you for being here. I’m Melanie Hill, and I serve as Head of Investor Relations at Australian Ethical. First, I want to acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land where we operate — the Gadigal people, one of the 29 tribes of the Eora Nation — and to recognize their enduring bond with the land, the waters, and their culture. Our respects go to their elders, both past and present. Just a note that this presentation is being recorded, and that recording will be posted on the Australian Ethical website. The slides we’re using today can also be found on our website. We’ll leave time for Q and A at the end. Throughout the presentation, you’re welcome to submit questions at any point through the webcast by using the Ask a Question box. Members of the media may also be joining us this morning. With me today are John McMurdo, our Group CEO and Managing Director of Australian Ethical, and Mark Simons, our CFO. John will walk us through the highlights, Mark will take us through the financials, and after that John will give a business update.

John McMurdo executive
#3

Thanks, Mel, and good morning, everyone. Before Mark and I get into the highlights, of which there are many, I wanted to remind you of some important context for understanding our results today, particularly for newer shareholders. Australian Ethical isn't a typical listed financial services firm. Beyond the value we generate for shareholders, we provide customer returns via ethical investing, aiming to positively shape outcomes for people, planet, and animals. That dual purpose sits in our constitution and runs through the fabric of our organization. It's the reason people decide to invest with us and the reason people want to work for us, because of our genuine authenticity. We believe the push for, and the demand for responsible investing is now permanent and only likely to grow over time as both the existential threat to the planet and the urgency of humans to address these problems grows. We've also been deliberately scaling the business up over the last four to five years to capture that growing addressable market for our shareholders and broader stakeholder group. We have been growing with a clear, consistent, and disciplined strategy. We are now an acknowledged global role model for responsible and principled investing, and have positioned the business to remain at that forefront, poised to take advantage of further opportunity for our stakeholders.

John McMurdo executive
#4

Our advocacy efforts mean we speak with a shared voice on behalf of a better world, and naturally, we have been developing our capabilities and putting money into a range of growth avenues so the business can scale further and our portfolios can make a greater impact as customer demand rises. We carried out that plan with confidence that, as we turn Australian Ethical into the larger and more influential business we are now becoming, shareholders would see the results of it. I am happy to report that our disciplined execution produced a milestone year in FY 2024. Across roughly the last 12 months, I have tried to be clear that following our recent organic growth and the successful integration of Christian Super, we would bring in higher revenues, better profit, and stronger ongoing operating leverage. So it is a pleasure this morning to report substantial further gains across every FY 2024 metric compared with FY 2023. Revenue growth of 24% year-on-year let us reach the significant milestone of AUD 100 million in revenue for the year. That result was helped by further positive net flows, which rose 30% versus the prior corresponding period, along with positive investment performance.

John McMurdo executive
#5

For FY 2024, underlying profit rose a significant 57% compared with FY 2023, which delivered on the scale benefits we were seeking to achieve. Full-year statutory NPAT increased 80% to AUD 11.8 million. The one letdown for me in a strong set of results is that we've recorded a further and final fair value write-down of AUD 2.16 million on our investment in Sentient Impact Group. This business has not delivered on its growth ambitions and has begun an orderly disposal of its assets. That write-down of our minority stake, which was taken in 2021, is of course non-recurring and non-cash, but it has reduced our second half statutory NPAT to AUD 5.6 million. Without that, our full-year result would have been even higher than the 80% NPAT growth we are announcing for the full year this morning. In terms of underlying momentum, though, it has continued throughout the year, with second half underlying profit up a further 18% on the first half at AUD 10 million. Our scale growth, as I said, has always been with a structural improvement in operating leverage in mind. So it is very pleasing to see a step change in our underlying cost to income ratio at 74% for FY 2024, compared with 79% in FY 2023.

John McMurdo executive
#6

That momentum, together with the structural improvement in how we realize profit, has given the board confidence to confirm a record high full-year dividend of AUD 0.09 per share, which includes a second half dividend of AUD 0.06 per share. Four years ago, when we set out on our growth strategy, we were clear that although investment in the business might weigh on short-term profit growth, our funds under management and revenue capture, if we succeeded, would deliver stronger profit growth over the medium to longer term, and a business better able to capture further upside beyond that. Sitting here today, the Australian Ethical team is delivering on that promise. Some capture has been strong. Revenue growth has been very pleasing, even after we sharpened our pricing across the four-year period to intentionally build a better moat for customer retention. That now allows us to present five-year underlying profit growth running at a 23% compound, and to report a five-year total shareholder return, or TSR, of greater than 160%. One notable aspect of that more diversified, more capable business is our growing M&A muscle, which has clearly added another dimension of capability and potential for further acceleration of AE.

John McMurdo executive
#7

Most of our growth has come organically and will keep doing so, but the Christian Super opportunity we secured, the clean integration of that business, and bringing the asset management in-house—where the value extraction is now very evident—has been a major success story for us, with quality execution, of course, being the key. Our M&A strategy is focused. It's for scale—tucking in valued, aligned businesses and distribution that feed our economic engine of investment management, Christian Super being a clear example of that—and it's for capability, capability that expands the strength and value capturability of that economic engine. As we've shared with the market, we have leveraged that M&A capability to secure, we believe, a compelling further opportunity with the acquisition of Altius Asset Management. Scheduled to complete at the end of next month, this gives us the ability to add valuable and strengthened asset class capability, retain further manufacturing margin as we continue to grow organically and acquisitively, and it is immediately EPS accretive. For me, even more important than the results we have now delivered, the unquestionably stronger, more diversified, more capable business we now have positions us strongly for further growth.

John McMurdo executive
#8

So to give you a bit more insight into that momentum and where we stand, we've now delivered over 40 consecutive quarters of positive net flows across a range of economic and political cycles, inflationary periods, and global pandemics — while plenty of other fund managers have had their struggles at times. We've deliberately built one of the country's most trusted superannuation brands. Our customer retention is among the highest, and we have strong customer experience and satisfaction. Our asset class and product offering is broader, backed by consistent awards for investment excellence and for the quality of our people — and it's a great place to work. At this point we're picking up multiple awards across pretty much every part of our business — for investments and superannuation excellence, for responsible investment leadership for growth, and for customer experience and service. Not long ago we were given the highest B Corp rating ever awarded in Australia and New Zealand, for any business in any sector, reflecting the quality of our business and our ability to recognise and deliver for multiple stakeholders — the highest score ever. So there's recognition of our growth, recognition of our customer delivery, recognition of the quality of a company that's been built and oriented sustainably, and recognition for our investment and ethical craft not just locally, but on the international stage.

John McMurdo executive
#9

There's a rich heritage here, and it runs through every part of what we do. Our investment portfolio keeps producing good results, limiting investments in businesses that do harm to the world, helping to bring about lower emissions, more renewable energy solutions, and making a positive contribution to the UN's Sustainable Development Goals. That heritage and trusted voice help us deliver on our purpose in boardrooms with CEOs at AGMs, via the media, through sponsoring research, and through submission to industry bodies and governments. And we do that not only with businesses and assets we direct capital to, but also in sectors where we don't. These are often multi-year engagements and very often behind the scenes, as well as sometimes very clearly and intentionally in the public domain. Our customers value this immensely. And to cap that off, we put our mouth where our money is and our money where our mouth is, via the Australian Ethical Foundation, to fund and advocate for a better world. It's all delivered by the most amazing team I've had the privilege to lead in more than 30 years of financial services leadership. I contend you could not find a more authentic, motivated, and action-oriented responsible investor anywhere, and I do believe that's why we are seen as an employer of choice, and rated and regarded by Morningstar and others as one of a very small number of true global leaders in our domain.

John McMurdo executive
#10

Mark, could you walk us through the financial highlights and results, please?

Mark Simons executive
#11

Thanks, John. I'm in agreement — FY 2024 delivered robust outcomes as our strategy gets executed. Among the numerous financial highlights: we crossed the AUD 10 billion mark in FUM and the AUD 100 million mark in revenue, achieved record profit, a record dividend, the largest donation ever made to our foundation, and improved operating leverage. I'll start with an overview of the annual financial results. As John noted, underlying profit came in at AUD 18.5 million, a 57% rise for the year. That gain stems from the successful integration of Christian Super and disciplined investment in the business, which produced better operating leverage — a core focus for us. Statutory net profit of AUD 11.8 million was 80% higher than the prior year. Our underlying profit leaves out non-business as usual costs. In the year, those costs comprised the transformational super administration transition project, due diligence and transaction costs related to the Altius acquisition, plus preliminary due diligence costs incurred on the M&A pipeline aligned to our strategy, and, as John noted, a final fair value write-down on our investment in Sentient Impact Group of AUD 2.16 million. The underlying cost income ratio for FY 2024 stood at 74%, an improvement of 5% points versus 79% in the prior year.

Mark Simons executive
#12

FUM has kept rising compared with a year earlier, hitting a record AUD 10.4 billion at year-end — yet another major milestone across our 38-year history. That works out to three times the growth if we look back five years, to the AUD 3.4 billion in FUM we posted in June 2019. FUM is expanding at a five-year compound rate of 25%. Average FUM is the main revenue driver and it rose 25% over the year. We're happy to report the May acquisition of the Altius Asset Management business, which brings us roughly AUD 2 billion of FUM in fixed income and is EPS accretive. The deal remains on track to complete by the end of September. Even though investment managers faced a challenging year, our organic growth carried on, with AUD 607 million in net flows for FY 2024. Those net flows came mainly from our super net flows, which in tough market conditions tend to hold up better than managed funds. That shows the advantage of our diversified business. In FY 2024, we posted record super guarantee contributions and year-end voluntary contributions — a benefit of our growing customer base. As ever, we stay focused on engaging and retaining customers, and we have one of the lowest net outflow rates in the super fund industry.

Mark Simons executive
#13

How we charge fees is central to how we grow — it keeps our products competitive for today’s customers and those who come later, while still delivering profitable growth for shareholders. When the SFT happened in FY 2023, we brought in substantial fee cuts for our super members. In FY 2024, there have been no additional reductions. Within managed funds, our aim was to lift returns on the High Conviction Fund, so we trimmed its fee by 11 basis points, bringing it to 0.69%. Fee margin overall has held fairly steady, and at 30 June 2024 the revenue margin stood at 1.02%. Each year we measure our fees against what competitors charge, and as we grow in scale, we’ll keep balancing profitable growth against giving customers a more competitive offering. Once the acquisition of the Altius Asset Management business is complete, we anticipate our overall fee margin will naturally fall to a pro forma margin of roughly 0.9%. It’s terrific that we’ve now crossed the 100 million revenue milestone. Revenue rose 24% for the year, and second half revenue came in 7% above the first half. The revenue increase came from a full year of Christian Super, the SFT, continued positive net flows, steady customer growth, and investment performance.

Mark Simons executive
#14

Over the past five years, revenue has compounded at a 20% CAGR, driven by growth in FUM and partly offset by deliberate fee reductions. As the financial year closed, our revenue run rate stood at AUD 106 million, calculated from closing FUM and the present revenue margin. To put ourselves in the strongest position for the growth opportunities ahead, continuing to develop a scalable, institutional-grade business platform has been essential. During the past year, we enhanced capabilities supporting our investment-led product offering, moved forward with our super administration transition to grow, invested in our technology strategy so the business can be data-driven and digitalized, and pursued operational efficiency via automation and innovation. We readied the business for the November transition to State Street, our new custodian and investment administrator, and we are midway through upgrading to new front and middle office investment systems. Operating expenses rose 16% to AUD 74.4 million, covering both fixed and variable costs. Spending on new capability, together with the run rate from FY 2023 hires — including the Christian Super staff brought on in November — plus salary increases, produced a 24% rise in employment costs. Our FTE grew from 118 to 125 at year-end.

Mark Simons executive
#15

The bulk of our new joiners came into the investment and ethics functions as well as data and technology. We strengthened risk and governance too. The run rate from these additions will carry into FY 2025. During FY 2025, six new Altius team members will join us, and we'll add FTE to keep building out the platform in a disciplined way. Expenses unrelated to the above, variable by nature, rose 26%, mainly because average customer numbers and FUM were higher following the SFT, plus an increase in regulatory levies. Savings from crossing various scale thresholds partly offset that. IT costs climbed 21%, reflecting the build of our core, stronger technology platform, with new front, middle, and back-office licenses aligned to team growth and strategy, along with spending to improve cybersecurity defenses. Marketing costs moved the other way, falling 22%, largely from rationalizing the employment platform's distribution channel. Ongoing brand investment stays a key part of building awareness and growth. That said, the timing of brand campaigns meant brand spend in FY 2024 was lower than the prior year. We still hold a stronger balance sheet, with excellent cash conversion, no debt, and surplus regulatory capital.

Mark Simons executive
#16

Right now, we hold a regulatory capital surplus of AUD 13.8 million, which we're keeping to fund the acquisition of the Altius Asset Management business, to cover rises in regulatory capital requirements, and for possible inorganic opportunities. These charts illustrate the pleasing growth in key shareholder metrics over time, with underlying profit rising at a strong 23% CAGR since 2019. Net profit after tax has grown at a lower CAGR of 13%, as you'd expect, given the investment in the business and our deliberate choice to invest in strengthening the business platform. Our total shareholder return over five years is over 160%. Confidence in our business and momentum has led the board to declare a final dividend of AUD 0.06, bringing the full year dividend to AUD 0.09, up 29% on last year and a record dividend. I'll now hand over to John for a business update.

John McMurdo executive
#17

Thanks, Mark. On the business update, the first thing to keep in mind is that we remain highly deliberate about how we build this business. We're set up around two big structural themes and tailwinds: a growing addressable market for responsible investing, both at home and around the world, and mandated systems growth in Australian superannuation. And while growth in responsible investing won't necessarily follow a straight line — with greenwashing and other dynamics undoubtedly bringing periods of pause followed by surge — we're still convinced we're only at the early stages of a mega trend toward this kind of investing, as the world confronts the existential threats facing humanity and as consumer behavior and preference keeps favoring, and even expecting, this investing approach. We're making very meaningful progress across every element of our strategic execution. We have an expanded investment and ethics capability and team, which positions the business in new asset classes, products, and opportunities, further diversifying and strengthening our business. Adding Altius next month will augment this further. Our advocacy is, most importantly, making a positive difference in the world, but it also builds our brand and reputation. The experience we deliver for clients keeps getting stronger from an already strong base, as shown by the growing numbers of awards we receive.

John McMurdo executive
#18

And obviously, we've expanded funds under management from roughly AUD 4 billion just four years back to AUD 10.4 billion as of today, and AUD 12.4 billion pro forma once Altius is included, following completion next month — so we're already a bigger, stronger business with more impact. Still, despite all the success we've plainly had over those last four years, we believe there's considerably more ahead. The size we've reached now lets us keep investing in the quality of the business and produce greater profitability along with operating leverage. Our approach to the business model and how we've positioned the brand has been intentional. A retail brand that's strong, differentiated, and trusted. An economic capture model centred on high quality, high margin, differentiated, and largely active investment management, with all the natural operating leverage potential that an investment management operation at scale brings. But it's enhanced and positively compounded by a multi-channel distribution strategy centred on the sticky, high margin retail channels, with particular strength and focus in the retail or B2C superannuation market, where systems growth is high. When I put together the macro structural thematics of system and addressable market growth, our 38-year history and record of investing ethically, the trust in our brand, and our deliberate business model, and layer on top of that periodic, disciplined, and accretive M&A, we genuinely see substantial opportunity ahead to keep compounding this business and deliver attractive outcomes for shareholders and stakeholders.

John McMurdo executive
#19

What gives me added confidence is our ability to accomplish that through excellent people capability along with a strong ungeared balance sheet. The medium-term opportunity ahead strikes us as exciting. That covers further optimizing the position we already hold, our capabilities, and valuable channels, yet we also perceive new revenue opportunities via asset class and product expansion in areas such as private markets and international equities. It is exciting in the here and now as well, since a great deal of the behind-the-scenes groundwork we have undertaken in FY 2024 lands in FY 2025. That covers our administration platform consolidation, custody scale benefits available to us, transition of our custody, the acquisitive growth with Altius, and all of these will begin to deliver run rate benefits in terms of either revenue uplift or unit cost reductions during FY 2025. We hold very strong confidence in continuing our upward profit growth trajectory. Thanks for joining us this morning. We appreciate your interest in and support of Australian Ethical. Mark and I are also joined this morning by John Woods, our Deputy Chief Investment Officer, and Alison George, our Head of Impact and Ethics. And all of us do look forward, now, to answering any questions that you might have.

Melanie Hill executive
#20

Thanks, John. Just a reminder that if you'd like to pose a question through the webcast, go ahead and enter it in the Ask a Question box. John, a question has already come in for you. Over the past four years, you've obviously seen robust growth. How does the board view the way the strategy is progressing?

John McMurdo executive
#21

Thanks, Mel, and I appreciate the question. So, when it comes to how confident we are in the strategy, we feel we're headed in the right direction, and we've established the appropriate business model and differentiation strategy to keep succeeding. I covered some of that during the presentation. Maybe if I frame it another way for you, and draw a parallel between what we've built and the listed funds management sector at large. In other places, I observe institutional mandate-driven FUM carrying typically thinner margins, far more vulnerable, in my view, to economic cycles, performance cycles, and a shrinking pool of available clients as super funds gradually internalize investment management. And a number of them tend to be reliant on the so-called rock star type of portfolio managers, who take, you know, a substantial draw on that value chain. But what we've built and keep refining through our strategy is something rather different, which is a strong, differentiated, trusted retail brand. An economic capture model centered on high quality, and importantly, high margin, and differentiated, largely active management, with all of the natural operating leverage potential that comes from investment management at scale. But as I've mentioned, enhanced and positively compounded, we believe, via a multi-channel distribution strategy, which is aimed at the high margin and sticky retail channels, with a particular strength and focus in that high systems growth superannuation market.

John McMurdo executive
#22

So this is a very different model with a deliberate strategy bias, and, you know, we're already seeing it deliver strong relative outcomes, and both the board and the management team remain very confident about our prospects going forward.

Melanie Hill executive
#23

Thanks, John — and nice work on that solid earnings growth. Do you think something in the neighborhood of your recent 20+% cumulative average earnings growth rate is something you can keep up?

John McMurdo executive
#24

Sure, that's a fair question as well, and obviously I won't be offering guidance this morning. Having said that, my own short answer would be yes. We now have 40-something consecutive quarters of positive flows behind us, and that makes it clear our brand is strong and that we've built a well-developed B2C direct acquisition marketing engine. We're operating in the part of the market — the retail super sector — where mandated systems growth is strong and margins are attractive. We also have other growth channels that are now valuable, including advised distribution and our employment platforms, plus real potential to push further into the employer market and into what we describe as values-aligned organizations, all at retail margins or at least mezzanine margins. And then, with prospects for more product and asset class diversification — whether that's private markets, as I mentioned, or international equities or thematic products — we're very positive about new revenue streams emerging as we go forward. On top of that, there are unit cost improvements available in the near term through our middle and back office transformation agenda and the natural scale in our investment management engine. So as you can see, it isn't hard to anticipate both further top-line growth and improving unit costs, and therefore the jaws of operating leverage widening further over the next medium-term period.

John McMurdo executive
#25

So although 2024 has clearly been a landmark year for us, we think we're in a strong position for growth — and for further profit growth — in FY 2025, and well past that too.

Melanie Hill executive
#26

Thanks, John. Mark, we’ve got a question that came in for you. Both of you mentioned the unit cost savings we expect as a result of our transformation program — specifically, the AUD 4 million in annual savings. I was wondering, Mark, if you could give us a little more detail on that and on how it’s going to play out next year.

Mark Simons executive
#27

Yes. Appreciate the question. Like I mentioned, we've been putting money into a business platform that's both scalable and efficient, and part of that involved actually negotiating attractive rate cards with our main service providers. And in terms of what you're asking about, there's a mention of the super admin transition we've referenced that's happening in order to grow. We have in fact secured a more attractive rate card. It's more fund-based, and it will actually deliver a unit cost saving relative to the current incumbent. And as John just said, our back and middle office transition involves scalable solutions with the service providers where we're obtaining an attractive rate card. So that unit cost saving begins from the period in which we finish those transitions, both of which will land in FY 2025. Thank you.

Melanie Hill executive
#28

Thanks, Mark. Another question has come in, and the person congratulates us on the strong results. When you talk about growth in private market opportunities, what exactly do you mean? Does that refer to private credit, or to social infrastructure? I'll pass this over to John Woods to answer.

John Woods executive
#29

Appreciate the question. Private markets is, by nature, an extremely wide asset class. We brought on a new head of private markets recently, Adam, to push this strategy further. Late last year we also introduced our first product in this area, the Infrastructure Debt Fund, and we see several ways to grow it further both here at home and abroad.

Melanie Hill executive
#30

Thanks, John. John McMurdo, I’m curious whether you could give us some detail on how investment performance has been lately and whether you expect that to have an effect on flows.

John McMurdo executive
#31

Sure, I appreciate the question. Look, we're keenly aware — pretty much inherently, given how our business is structured and how we operate — that we pay very little attention to benchmarks. So you'll get stretches, whether that's one month or a quarter, when we either beat various benchmarks by a wide margin or sometimes lag behind them, and we're used to that kind of pattern. But without question, our philosophy when it comes to investing has been thoroughly tested and thoroughly validated. When I look at how we've performed over the long run, whether in our diversified funds or our single sector funds, those results are exceptionally strong on any relative measure. And I actually haven't shared this with my own team yet, but here's a spoiler for everyone: our Australian Shares Fund hits the 30 year milestone next month since it was launched. The performance of that fund has been roughly 9.7% compounded across 30 years, versus a relative benchmark of 7.5%. That figure is net of all fees, so essentially 2.2% of alpha compounded over 30 years, and we have tremendous confidence in our team's capabilities and process.

Melanie Hill executive
#32

Thanks, John. Mark, I’ve got a question for you about the Sentient investment. Could you expand a bit more on the writedowns and confirm whether it is now valued at zero?

Mark Simons executive
#33

Thanks for asking that. As John said, we made the Sentient investment back in 2021, and the clear rationale at the time was that it would extend our impact capability. That investment has not worked out as planned and has been a disappointment. We put AUD 5.2 million into it, and it has been written down by AUD 4.8, recovering point AUD 4 million, and that investment has now been written down to zero.

Melanie Hill executive
#34

Thanks, Mark. Since no further questions have come in, we'll bring things to a close here, and I want to express our appreciation to all of you for being with us today as we announced Australian Ethical's FY 2024 results. Thank you.

Operator operator
#35

That brings today's conference to a close. We appreciate your participation. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Australian Ethical Investment Limited transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Australian Ethical Investment Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.