Bullish (BLSH) Earnings Call Transcript
November 19, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Hello, everyone, and thanks for joining our third-quarter earnings call this morning. Michael Fedele here — I serve as Vice President of Finance. With me today are Tom Farley, our Chief Executive Officer; David Bonanno, our Chief Financial Officer; and Liam Foley, who leads Corporate Development. During this call, we'll make forward-looking statements, among them ones about the performance and business opportunities we anticipate. Such statements shouldn't be taken as guarantees of what lies ahead. Risks and uncertainties affect them, and what actually happens could be materially different. If you'd like more information about those risks, take a look at the earnings press release issued today along with the filings we've made with the SEC, one of which is our perspectives document dated August 12, 2025. We're not committing to any update or revision of forward-looking statements. Also, today's call will touch on non-IFRS financial measures. You can find a reconciliation between those measures and the closest comparable IFRS metrics in our earnings press release and presentation, where you'll also find further details about non-IFRS financial measures and key performance indicators. At this point, I'll hand things over to Tom.
Thanks, Michael. And thanks to everyone for being on the call with us today. I'm Tom Farley, Chairman and CEO of Bullish. We're happy to report that Q3 2025 was another winning quarter for Bullish. Adjusted revenue came in at a record $76.5 million, adjusted EBITDA hit a record $28.6 million, and adjusted net income reached a record $13.8 million. As Dave will get into shortly, and as the guidance we've provided shows, we anticipate additional records across 2025 in its entirety. Over the past six weeks, our momentum has done nothing but build. Our options franchise went fully live on October 31, and the early results are encouraging; we also went live with our U.S. On the exchange side, we've been signing notable clients since we started. During Q4, we added a bunch of new customers for our liquidity services, including some well-known crypto projects. Things are gaining momentum in our index segment, thanks to a wave of U.S.-based ETFs and other listed products launching that track our benchmarks. Our media division has accelerated its growth this quarter, and it's now recognized in our weekly and monthly updates as the number one crypto news outlet worldwide based on viewership. Before I dive further into what's working across our businesses, let me give you some background on how Bullish fits into the wider crypto landscape. Over the past few years, Bullish has intentionally positioned itself where three strong, continuing forces driving crypto ahead intersect. First, there's increasing clarity in regulation, with requirements that expect infrastructure companies and the clients they serve to act responsibly and within the rules. Second, more and more traditional finance players are now interacting with crypto in substantial ways. And third, tokenization keeps spreading across major asset classes, after the U.S. dollar was successfully tokenized via stablecoins. Our confidence that we've chosen the correct course has never been stronger. We are positioned right at the heart of all three of these forces. We take pride in where we stand on the regulatory front, and the continued adoption by institutions that we are assisting in advancing makes us happy. Still, I want to explore that third trend—tokenization—in more detail. When we talk about tokenization, we mean taking conventional financial assets and turning them into crypto assets. From where we sit, over the next ten years this trend will represent the single most transformative value proposition in crypto, and thanks to our liquidity services platform, we are set up to take the lead there. As a matter of fact, our liquidity services business came into existence in 2023 precisely because of the tokenization trend. The U.S. dollar, through stablecoins, became the first significant asset to be tokenized successfully. Once people began putting dollars on-chain, the companies issuing stablecoins turned to firms such as Bullish, seeking assistance with digitizing the U.S. currency. It became clear there was demand in the market for trading listings, depth of liquidity, and exposure, since these freshly created tokens were crossing the divide separating traditional finance from blockchain networks. Throughout the bulk of 2022, 2023, and 2024, we remained focused on building in order to satisfy those requirements, and we labeled this group of offerings liquidity services. Every bit of that took place well before the term tokenization became the trendy phrase on everybody's tongue. Regarding stablecoins in the present day, our work involves authoring smart contracts that make it possible to connect one layer 1 blockchain with a different one. On a worldwide exchange that operates under regulation and compliance, we are providing listings for stablecoins paired with a broad assortment of other assets. On Bullish and across DeFi protocols, we provide liquidity, and we promote these stablecoins via our consensus and CoinDesk properties. To put it plainly, our liquidity services offering has allowed us to create a tokenization platform, and that platform has become the business growing faster than any other we have. What really gets us excited is something else. When it comes to tokenizing assets other than the U.S. dollar, we are only in the first inning; as more assets and more asset classes are listed on-chain in the years to come, these tokenization services may continue to scale in a meaningful way. That spans essentially every major asset class one could think of; the effective tokenization of the dollar — stablecoins — is something we see as a blueprint for tokenizing these new asset classes down the road. Having supported nearly every stablecoin tied to the dollar or the euro, we've come to appreciate how much it matters to build a deep toolkit tailored to tokenizing that kind of asset. Our offerings for stablecoins keep advancing. Take Bullish: we can now mint and burn directly alongside almost all stablecoin issuers, and we also provide sophisticated API orchestration that enables frictionless transfers between fiat and stables, which fuels expansion for our partners. Our view is that each additional asset class is going to require its own set of capabilities, layered on top of what we already provide as the standard three core services that any asset issuer needs for tokenization: listings, liquidity, and visibility. With that need for extra functionality in mind, we've filed an application with the SEC seeking regulatory approval to become a transfer agent, and that will add further support to our strategy around tokenization and liquidity services for U.S. securities. Over the coming months, we're eager to share more about what we have planned, and we're eager to go on this tokenization journey together with you. Now, setting aside the excitement about what our liquidity service platform could mean for future tokenization growth, how is it performing at the moment? Our services continue to be sought after; we're adding new and diversified customers, and our momentum has continued into Q4; in Q3, we added a record number of liquidity services partners, and our active partner count is up 100% sequentially. We're on track for another strong quarter in Q4. We've kept growing what we do with layer one blockchains, working alongside major players like Solana, Ripple, and Tron. Since our last conversation, we've expanded the set of layer one chains we provide liquidity services for, bringing in four new ecosystems: Canton, Cardano, Midnight, and VeChain. On top of that, we're happy to report that things are progressing well in our work with the Solana Foundation. In the first quarter of this engagement, more than 80% of the stablecoins Bullish issued were on Solana, and the overall stablecoin value locked on Solana — that is, the amount of dollars tokenized there — grew by more than 40% during the same quarter. Moving on to talk about our highly successful options trading launch, I want to begin by stepping back and reminding everybody why this opportunity has us so enthusiastic at Bullish. Within crypto, options represent the fastest-expanding asset class. Just last month, they reached over $200 billion in monthly trading volume, which is up over 230% versus the same period a year earlier. On top of that, because options are inherently complex and attract a sophisticated user base, we're well positioned to capture substantial market share within this asset class, and we anticipate it will expand by multiples over the next several years. Turning to how we're doing ourselves: at the very end of October, our exchange became fully operational with all risk caps removed. In only a bit more than a fortnight, we've already seen volume trade north of $1 billion, and currently our open interest stands at approximately $1 billion. Our best session came yesterday, with $240 million traded — roughly 4% market share as we define it. The early momentum we've picked up truly excites me, and I anticipate it becoming a significant driver of our financial performance down the road.
I've participated in numerous launches of derivatives products throughout my career, some extremely successful and others I'd prefer to forget. This particular one shows every sign of becoming a major success. Our previous earnings call took place under 24 hours after we obtained our esteemed BIT License. We noted that getting this license represented the last milestone needed to open U.S. onboarding for prospective Bullish exchange clientele. We also mentioned that U.S.-based customers would require time to go live, because of their institutional character and the normally prolonged onboarding procedure for such customers. That said, we're happy to report that we have already actively onboarded numerous new customers, among them very large retail brokers with millions of customers, such as Webull and Moomoo, institutional brokers like Cantor Fitzgerald, a very large crypto custodian, and other institutional clients. Progress is happening faster than we expected only a couple of months back when we last gathered. Our U.S.-based clientele appreciate our already liquid global order book, which allowed us to launch without any zero-to-one or cold start liquidity problems; we're encouraged by our early progress in the U.S. and look forward to continuing to seize market share in the months ahead. Beyond the U.S., we keep making steady progress growing our exchange. Over the quarter, we've brought on some of the biggest retail brokerages across Europe, the Middle East, and Latin America, and integrated various crypto-focused hedge funds or asset managers that have already begun trading derivatives on our platform. Turning to information services, our CoinDesk business keeps performing well, backed by significant accomplishments in our indices business. We're pleased to report that since our previous earnings call only two months ago, our indices have underpinned an additional five of six total newly launched U.S.-based exchange-traded crypto products, plus four additional global ETPs. During this period, we also secured six new benchmark switches from competitors and have two active ETP filings for the CoinDesk 20 Index. On the CoinDesk Insights or Media side, we keep successfully capturing more market share against competitors with our market-leading and accessible crypto content, and CoinDesk.com remains a highly sought-after destination for advertising. We have also successfully launched CoinDesk Research, a subscription-based vertical dedicated to delivering high-quality research and analysis. CoinDesk Research also acts as a natural extension and upsell to our liquidity services clientele. The thesis that we can land and expand is proving true. There are many examples of existing customers in Q3 and so far in Q4 choosing to take advantage of new Bullish company products and services alongside their existing products and services. Overall, we keep winning, and we keep executing on the vision that Dave and I laid out when we first joined Bullish. We're proud of our success so far, and we believe that we're just getting started. At a macro level, we're only at the beginning, since tokenizing securities along with other real-world assets, plus the transformation of financial market infrastructure, has barely gotten underway. At Bullish, we're likewise only at the beginning today, given our belief that we either hold or are working toward the right combination of licenses, technology, talent, and experience to win in a world moving on-chain at a rapid pace; with focus, discipline, and momentum, we'll keep executing as we set Bullish up for sustained growth in 2026 and beyond. Having said that, I'll hand the call over to our CFO, Dave, my partner, so he can walk through the quarter in greater detail.
Thanks, Tom, and hello everybody on this morning's call. I'll begin by going over what we delivered in Q3, then give you some added background on how the business has been operating, and after that I'll lay out what we're expecting for Q4. Just a quick note — you can find reconciliations for our non-IFRS metrics at the back of the presentation we're using today, and also in the 6K filing that came out earlier this morning. For Q3, total adjusted revenue came in at $76.5 million, which is a 34% increase from the prior quarter and 72% higher than the same period a year ago, and that beat the top end of the range we had guided to. SS&O revenue in Q3, which covers liquidity services along with every CoinDesk-branded product, came to $49.8 million — that's a gain of more than 50% over Q2 and more than 300% over the quarter a year earlier. Looking at the first three quarters of this year, SS&O revenue accounts for 53% of total adjusted revenue on a year-to-date basis, versus 28% for the entirety of 2024. Adjusted operating expenses came in at $47.9 million for Q3, which is a 2% decline from Q2 2025. Adjusted EBITDA for Q3 reached $28.6 million, rising 253% from the previous quarter and 271% compared with a year ago. And finally, adjusted net income for Q3 was $13.8 million. With the business continuing to grow in scale, we're happy with how we've kept costs in check and with our strong incremental margins, and we anticipate that carrying forward. Now shifting to how we're performing at present, trading volume on a Q2-to-date basis through November 17 comes to $126 billion, with an average trading spread of 1.7 basis points. For November so far, our trading spreads are running at an average of 1.8 basis points, which is higher than the 1.6 basis points you'd have seen in the October monthly metrics we published. We're anticipating significantly greater transaction revenue across the whole of Q4 relative to both Q2 and Q3 of 2025, and that's due to more volatility as well as a larger number of active trading customers. Moving on to guidance for Q4, our expectation is SS&O revenue of between $47 million and $53 million, with adjusted operating expenses of between $48 million and $50 million. We continue to feel good about the prospects for our financial performance, and we think Bullish is positioned well to keep delivering growth that is both sustained and profitable over the quarters ahead. Thanks for being with us today, and now I'll hand things back to Tom for his closing remarks.
Much appreciated, and just like we mentioned previously, we're grateful for the ongoing interest in Bullish and for keeping up with the narrative; thanks for spending part of your day with us, and now we'll take your questions.
Morning, and thanks for taking my question. I'd like to zero in on liquidity services. Perhaps to begin, you said the count of stablecoins grew twofold during this quarter. Roughly how many stablecoins do you provide services for? You also said earlier that the backlog of non-stablecoin tokens was beginning to take over that backlog. How do the economics for non-stablecoin tokens stack up against those for stablecoins? I'll fold my follow-up in here as well. Coinbase rolled out something tied to ICOs. How much does that go head-to-head with your business of promoting non-stablecoins? Thank you.
Thanks, Ken. Good to hear from you. I might have been racing through my words as usual. Let me make your question clearer — the liquidity services numbers I gave, broadly speaking, cover every liquidity services client. That means I wasn't claiming stablecoin clients grew twofold. Honestly, if I had to guess without checking, I'd say our stablecoin client count didn't double. What doubled was the total, which counts things like those four Layer 1 blockchains I mentioned, plus stablecoin issuers. To address the main point you're getting at, we keep bringing on more stablecoin clients, which lines up with what we expected going in — and I believe your view isn't far off from that — that the Genius Act will lead to more and more stablecoin issuers entering the market. Our observation is that these newcomers require the same three offerings tied to tokenization or liquidity as everybody else: getting listed, having liquidity, and gaining visibility. And maybe the most encouraging part is that we're demonstrating how well these services fit the market, well past just stablecoin issuers. Throughout this quarter, we observed a fairly even distribution across three main groups: stablecoin providers, Layer 1 networks, and third, issuers of token-based crypto ventures—meaning those that aren't a Layer 1 or a stablecoin—and there's a growing mixture. Let me pause there; I'll have Dave step in to correct me if I misstated any of those numbers, and then we'll get back to you, Ken. Regarding the ICO platform, our primary emphasis has been on the top-tier crypto platforms, which aligns with our core mission of serving institutional clients. Generally speaking, they have little appetite for the long tail of crypto. Their focus tends to be on crypto ventures valued at a billion dollars or more, or at minimum a market cap of $500,000,000 and above. The competitor situation you brought up and the area we're targeting are really just two distinct categories of inquiry; our approach is to stay with what we know best, continue developing liquidity offerings within our primary market, and genuinely take pleasure in the journey as our addressable market keeps growing right before our eyes. Right, Ken, regarding what you asked about the stablecoin liquidity service agreements, we've said previously that we work with essentially all stablecoin issuers except USDT at this point. By my tally, that comes to about 9 or 10 stablecoins altogether, covering both euro-denominated and dollar-denominated partners. As for the chance to generate more revenue from stablecoin partners compared with non-stablecoin ones, broadly speaking, we can take the assets those partners hold in stablecoins and deploy them in other income-producing activities, simply because stablecoins carry wide-ranging usefulness across crypto, DeFi, and beyond. On top of that, we can uncover additional opportunities with the partners that aren't stable. It varies. Every single one of these is somewhat tailor-made, with differing levels of utility and differing contract sizes. We're enthusiastic about the pipeline on both sides, and growth is happening on both sides, though at present the greater emphasis sits on the non-stable portion, since the coming wave of, let's say, Genius compliance stablecoins has genuinely not gone live yet. We anticipate a fresh wave of those starting in late Q4, early Q1, and we anticipate landing some meaningful new wins, which we'll discuss early next year.
Great. Thank you very much.
Thanks, Ken.
Thanks for that. Morning, Tom and David. Nice work on keeping up the execution pace—genuinely impressive. I'd like to dig deeper into what's driving the push toward acquiring transfer agent licensure and related capabilities. Clearly, there are openings tied to certain CoinDesk indices and possibly custom offerings too. I'm just wondering how you view the competitive dynamics, or the setup, for RWAs that might be more commodity-like—individual equities, for instance. What does that competitive picture look like to you? And then, secondly, I was hoping you could share something about how the AMM performed during the sharper volatility we've witnessed over the last few weeks. Spreads clearly appear quite healthy, but I'm wondering whether there are additional operating metrics worth our attention. Thanks.
Absolutely. Great to hear your voice, Pete. Two quite substantial subjects. I'll try to tackle the first one, and Dave will handle the second. In my prepared remarks I touched somewhat on this broader tokenization phenomenon, but given what you asked, I'd like to layer in additional context and shape. Consider stablecoins—at their core they amount to nothing more than the US dollar, so the real question becomes: alright, how do I take that US dollar? I'll use plain language here for those who aren't immersed in crypto around the clock. You've got the US dollar, and then the challenge is how to move that dollar onto a blockchain so it becomes usable for commerce. That process is what tokenizing the US dollar means. As for who engages in this, certain players are deeply crypto native—consider Tether or Circle—while others are less so. Lately you've probably noticed Western Union in the headlines, for instance. Still others sit somewhere between those poles. Think of PayPal or similar companies. Now these players say, "Alright, I'd like to take the dollar and tokenize it." Several of those required tasks they can handle entirely by themselves. Other companies look at the situation and conclude, "Wow, this demands a great deal of specialized knowledge, and going it alone isn't feasible." So you might ask: how does something move from untokenized to tokenized? Picture a range of offerings and services; take, for instance, whether you personally code the smart contract that mints the tokens. Do you personally build the equivalent of an Excel spreadsheet or Oracle database sitting on the blockchain that records which accounts hold how many tokens? Or do you turn to a third-party provider for that? Do you obtain those licenses state by state across the United States, or the federal ones that Genius now mandates? Or do you lease them? All of these, broadly speaking, count as tokenization services. So we reviewed that, and we told ourselves, "We're sticking with what we know best, and we'll provide those offerings where we truly excel." We decided, "Our attention will go to the process of getting the token listed — not merely a standalone listing, but a listing of that token alongside numerous others; not only as a spot trade, but as a perpetual future, a dated future, an options contract — all executed on a compliant, regulated exchange, which grants a degree of respect to the issuers of those assets." Our attention will go to providing liquidity, ensuring that even during distressed moments, bids and offers exist for those freshly tokenized tokens — if you will, using that same term a second time. Last, the visibility. The premier properties in crypto belong to us. Nobody disputes that. For a crypto news site, CoinDesk ranks first worldwide for views. Twice each year, in Asia and the U.S., CoinDesk is where significant institutional people and companies come together, and we can assist these stablecoins and tokens in getting their message out. Right? That has been our strategy. So your question now is, "Hey, tell us about this transfer agent element." We examine the world and we say, "Boy, it seems like the next domino to fall here, or at minimum the next gigantic domino to fall." Other smaller tests will come along the way. Is it the U.S. securities market, whether that means single stocks or fixed income or whatever else? What we have drifted into with stablecoins — our customers have pulled us into it — is that we now offer something more expansive than simply the dead simple listing, liquidity, and visibility. I mentioned the API orchestration. I mentioned the direct mint earn, and I mentioned that we're now writing those smart contracts ourselves to facilitate bridging from Layer 1 to Layer 1. What the transfer agent license enables you to do is engage more actively with asset issuers who are tokenizing US securities, so you can offer more robust listings, liquidity, and visibility, plus some services around the margin, such as writing the actual smart contract for them or tabulating who owns what of what security. That is the license you pursue in the US under the SEC regime that gives you the freedom to offer those additional services to securities issuers, whether in a tokenized or, frankly, a certificated form; that gives you a bit more of the thinking behind that, Pete. Hopefully, that narrative — it was a long one. Hopefully, it was not too boring, but gives you a sense of where we are headed; and Pete.
Now,
Pete,
regarding. Arms dealer.
Go ahead. Go ahead.
No, Sam, you're taking the arms dealer role here. Great.
Yeah. Our goal is simply to be useful during this tokenization wave. In our view, Pete, it's enormous. Let me give one more brief story. Dave will want to hit me; even so, we went out and got this tokenization push underway. Honestly, seriously, feature development began for us in 2022. Then 2023 was when we turned it into a product. Growth really arrived in 2024. The name we gave it was liquidity services, though its substance was tokenization; January of 2025, this year, was when we went in. Pete, going back to that point, that's about the time our discussions with you got started, and tokenization appeared throughout our deck, yet the response was basically a collective shrug. There was really very little enthusiasm from anyone, which just goes to show how dramatically 2025 has changed the picture. Part of it comes down to the regulatory environment. Beyond that, Layer 1 technologies have simply become far more solid. People have come to understand that it's ready for prime time. It's now obvious to everyone that tokenization delivers real advantages, since you can use those tokens as collateral with greater ease and efficiency. Lately, I have frequent conversations with the leaders of the biggest banks globally, and they're preparing for this surge. We noticed it coming. At times we wondered if we were being unrealistic, considering the reactions we received from others at the table, but we've been getting ready on our end, and our goal is simply to contribute to assisting our clients in taking this step. Pete, regarding what you asked about the volatility encounter, you're likely referring mainly to October 10th, the AMM's results and how the exchange did overall, and we feel genuinely proud and happy about what we achieved and how well the technology stood up. Every few quarters or so, something comes along that lets us showcase how AMM liquidity stands apart from what other club order books deliver. When the flash crash hit on October 10th, our order books kept substantially more depth than could be found on other venues — especially offshore ones — where liquidity in major assets such as Solana simply vanished. Our spot prices showed much smaller wicks, and far fewer, while our derivative systems saw considerably fewer liquidations compared with other venues. Overall, we take real pride in how the system weathered that day; trading revenue was strong, and our customers definitely took note. I believe there's currently quite a bit of conversation happening across the broader market regarding how things like derivatives, marketing systems, and order books operate in venues that are, let's say, less regulated, compared with ours.
One additional point on that. I recall back around 2022, I was doing a launch alongside a very senior executive at a trading company in the sector we work in. His advice to me was, "Tom, given that clearing and derivatives have been your entire career, you should take a look at the way perpetual futures markets operate on these other venues. What you find will appall you." So that's precisely what I did. I devoted a weekend to examining it closely, then returned to our team and told them, "There's no way we will ever do that." The way these markets function is wrong. On October 10th, what we observed was fully collateralized accounts having their positions liquidated. These unregulated venues take a heads I win, tails you lose stance. This makes clear to you why genuine institutions will never conduct business in those places. They simply won't. Genuine institutions require certainty that when they're hedged, they remain hedged. Their position can't simply disappear in the middle of the night while it carries gains on a fully collateralized basis.
That's great detail. Thanks to both of you.
Thank you. Morning, everyone. I'd like to dig deeper into SS&O on a wider scale. Clearly there's been considerable momentum and a robust third quarter. But when we look at the guidance for the four-Q period, at the midpoint it's essentially unchanged. Could you address that, and reconcile it with both the longer-term revenue growth opportunity and the current momentum in the business against the near-term revenue picture?
Yes, absolutely. Appreciate it, Dan. Good to hear from you. Let me take the latter portion of what you asked first — our confidence stays high regarding the growth trajectory for subscription services and other revenue going forward. Pipelines are filling up, new projects are in the works; in our view tokenization on a broader scale could be a really significant tailwind for that line item. As for the Q4 guidance specifically, a few different cross-currents are at play. First, as Tom noted, we keep seeing broad-based growth across essentially every line item within SS&O when it comes to customer wins and new contracts. Partially counteracting that growth would be, first, seasonality. No other quarter this year besides the fourth has zero events revenue. Our DC policy event and edge conferences took place during the third quarter. Events generated some revenue in the third quarter, and that won't happen again once we're in the fourth quarter. On top of that, there's a modest effect from significant downward price movement across the broader digital asset space, which impacts the indices business in part, some of our lending business, and to a smaller degree, liquidity services — though broad-based growth mostly cancels that out. A timing factor exists too, since many new contract signings in the fourth quarter are landing mid-to-late in the quarter, unlike the third quarter, when we had tremendous momentum both during the second quarter and into the early part of the third. Blend all of that together, and the guidance in front of you today is what we arrive at — flat to modest growth.
Excellent, that's quite useful. I was hoping you might give us a bit more color on how things are moving after that BIT License was granted. You mentioned a handful of onboardings, but could you build on what you said and discuss the pipeline, plus how you expect that customer base to scale as we head into the fourth quarter — and even more crucially, into next year?
Yes, absolutely, Dan. Like I mentioned, we've had what I'd call a greater number of early wins, and notable ones at that, than we anticipated being able to share with you, considering only 2 months, or 8 weeks, separated our two earnings calls. Some genuinely strong early momentum. Another favorable point, I'd add, is that the pipeline has filled up extremely fast and includes plenty of exciting names you'll recognize, whose titles include things like bank or investments, and who could genuinely move the needle. The flip side, I suppose, is that aside from a group of early adopters who signed agreements quickly, it's tough. It's a grind. Part of this, I think, traces back to FTX, honestly, since we continue to receive questions clearly designed to steer clear of an FTX-like scenario, which means diligence is simply very rigorous. "Hey, let's walk through your SOC reports. Let's walk through your cyber reports. We'd like to see additional working papers beyond just the publicly available audit." Everything looks fine and roughly on schedule, and we've had some favorable upside surprises regarding how many large customers have already signed and joined, along with the pipeline's size. It will require some time.
Understood. Appreciate it.
Thank you for fielding my question. Tom, my sense is that the Clarity Act will make its way to Trump's desk and be signed before this year wraps up. Could you walk us through what impact you anticipate that having on your operations, especially when it comes to liquidity services?
Absolutely. Great to hear from you, Brett. I wish we were doing this call on Monday rather than today. Tomorrow and Friday on the Hill, Brett, I'll be sitting down with 7 or 8 of the 100 U.S. senators, among them a good number of those deeply engaged in what the House referred to as the Clarity Act, or more broadly speaking, a market structure bill. I'll have a much clearer picture then. It was great to hear that your question assumed a bill would pass this year. You're somewhat more optimistic than I am. My optimism that it passes is high, since I'm witnessing bipartisan backing. My belief is it will greatly benefit the crypto sector, mostly thanks to preemption. To put it differently, avoiding the need to approach each of the 50 states for their highly specific — and in certain instances, unique — approvals to conduct crypto business. On its own, I believe that will be a major windfall for infrastructure providers such as Bullish. I also think that delivering legal certainty, similar to what happened with stablecoins, will draw in a large number of institutions along with tokenization participants and asset issuers, for instance. Accomplishing that would be fantastic for growth, and I'd very much like to see it happen. My view is it can only benefit our business. In the next 48 hours, Brett, I'll have far more information. There's plenty still ahead, mind you. My guess is House Ag will release an entirely new draft of its proposed bill. My guess is that will need to be worked out with — excuse me — Senate Ag. To some degree, that will need to be worked out with Senate Banking. In the end, a conference procedure between the Senate and the House will occur to ensure we craft a bill that is sensible for our nation and for this industry. We'll take part very actively in that process, as you can tell from where I'll be spending the next two days.
Great. Regarding the US momentum, it seems the launch came earlier than we anticipated, and adoption moved a lot quicker than we'd expected. Can you identify the reasons it moved so quickly and why it's performed so well, plus what you anticipate, or I suppose for the U.S. business, perhaps the remainder of this year and going into next year?
Yes. I'll probably get PTSD answering this; we made some pivotal choices during the past couple of years. One of those, I'm completely glad we pursued it, and it's ultimately something I can tell you about as an investment thesis, honestly, though it caused us plenty of agony and heartburn. What we did, Brett, was decide, "We're going to obtain the hardest regulatory approvals globally for offering spot crypto trading as an exchange. Every single one. We're going to secure Hong Kong; we're going to approach the frigging Germans, the BaFin, regarded as the strictest, most exhaustive regulator. We're going to approach the New Yorkers. Beyond approaching the New Yorkers, who are famous for being extremely selective about issuing BIT licenses, we're going to hold off on launching in the U.S; furthermore, we're going to approach the Brits, and we're going to obtain benchmark administration license. On top of everything else, our approach to getting licensed won't look like what you see from every other crypto exchange out there. Their ask is basically, "Let me set up an exchange in your jurisdiction and run the whole thing within your country's borders." That's not what we'll do. Instead, we'll go to regulators and say, "We want a single order book that spans the globe, so that a man in Hong Kong making a BIT offer can trade against Gerhard's offer, or someone looking to sell in Munich, or Elaine in New York with her BIT can match up with an offer from someone in France." Getting that approved turned out to be really hard, because just imagine sitting down with a regulator — especially one that's pretty provincial in its outlook — and telling them, "Sure, we'll register under your rules and keep customer funds inside your jurisdiction, but we also need to run one order book for the entire world." That probably cost us an extra two years compared to how long it might have taken, or perhaps should have taken, had we gone the shortcut route that almost every other crypto exchange chose. At last, this works in our favor. Once that BIT license comes through and we can officially start serving customers, what that actually amounts to is simple: people who've been trying to get in with us for a couple of years can finally hear us say, "Alright, you're cleared. Step right in. Your approval's done. The KYC/AML checks are complete; your money will sit with us here in America. We'll bring you on board stateside." The liquidity is sitting right there waiting. You have the ability to conduct transactions the very next day and engage with every one of our clients across the globe; that's the thing that let us sort of launch operations so fast, and it's why this might appear somewhat unlike what you typically see from other companies.
Fantastic. I'm very grateful for that. Thank you, Tom.
Excellent. Thanks a lot. Hello, everyone. I appreciate you fielding my questions, and congratulations on the strong progress you've shown. Perhaps we could explore a different perspective regarding the momentum in the United States. Dave, you mentioned some fairly impressive figures concerning trading volume during Q4 up to this point. Usually, we view a significant portion of the client onboarding activity as feeding into SS&O, but could you discuss how the influx of new customers is driving trading volume growth organically? Might that particular area expand at an even quicker pace compared to SS&O, purely from what's happening in the U.S.?
Sure. I appreciate you asking. We keep setting fresh records for user numbers in every category. That obviously helps. I'm talking about people who trade. It clearly lifts trading activity. Figuring out how much of the credit goes to having more users, versus market swings or the price adjustments we've made ourselves, is never simple. Taken as a whole, though, each unit of volatility is now bringing us bigger trading revenues and heavier trading volumes than it used to. And it's nice that the market has pulled back somewhat. This really highlights how varied our revenue sources are, especially given how remarkably robust transaction revenue has been through the first half of the fourth quarter. Our view remains that during 2026, the U.S. will grow into a significant driver of that revenue. On top of that, we're very happy about rolling out options. We anticipate options will play a big role in driving transaction revenues in the coming year. The momentum on the exchange trading side has us encouraged, much of which comes from cross-sells, our liquidity services, the capability to move in and out of various stablecoins, and our intense concentration on institutions. Everything they require in terms of products and services is generating returns. Yes. Let me contribute one more point on that—regarding options, I don't want to exaggerate its significance, since our market share remains in the single digits, but what we've seen in these early days has been somewhat eye-opening. A few things are becoming clear to us. First, from a product standpoint, it's entirely organic. Naturally, options didn't exist on our platform when we last convened two months ago. When I mention that we hit $240 million yesterday, that's obviously all organic. It's also largely organic when it comes to customers. Those who trade options are a very different group from those who trade linear products—or, say, spot. It's been quite effective at getting new users to join the platform, which is thrilling. And on a wider level, we're seeing that the market genuinely needs an options exchange where people can, within one account, trade spot, perps, data futures, and options on a compliant venue with good liquidity and portfolio margining. It really seems like our timing with this launch was spot on. I couldn't be happier. Stay tuned for what we roll out next.
Yeah. That's fantastic news. Regarding those incremental margins, Dave, you mentioned, obviously, they're high. Is it fair to say they're bigger on the trading side than on the SS&O side, or is that not necessarily true?
Probably. I'd say that's a fair characterization. On the SS&O side, you've got the events business, and that's the only line item of ours with any meaningful variable costs. Overall, probably somewhat more on the trading side. You'll see incremental margins in Q3 were actually over 100%. That happened because there was more advertising spend in Q2 for an event than there was in Q3. When you take a look at our guidance along with roughly where transaction revenues are running right now for Q4, what you can work out is incremental operating margins that aren't quite above 100%, though they're certainly far beyond 80%. We remain eager to show off the operating leverage this business has, to show off what comes from having diversified revenue streams, and to see that start coming through — ideally in an environment with more volatility than what we saw during Q2 and Q3 of this year. Hopefully that carries on into 2026. We're looking forward to reporting additional earnings, stronger margins, and proving out that operating leverage we've been discussing.
All right, that's great. Really great, Keller. Thanks so much, everybody.
Hello, thanks. Good morning to you. And well done on the results as well. This may be a learning moment for me, but I'd like to ask about the monthly figures for the spread side. My assumption would have been that the options segment landed higher than spot. Is the reason that it's still early, or am I just approaching this incorrectly? My second question concerns the negative spread we saw in perpetual futures during October. My guess is that volatility is behind it. Could you give me some detail on what produced that negative spread — one that was a bit bigger in October for perpetual futures? Thank you.
Yeah, absolutely. Regarding options, it's still early, and like we do with every product, we're testing out different pricing approaches. Like I've said in the past, what we're constantly trying to do is figure out how to get the most total adjusted transaction revenue for each unit of volatility. That applies across the board to all our products. These products generally interact with one another. We've noticed gains when we adjust prices on some products, whether through the volume or perhaps the revenue we see from other products. When it comes to options spreads, we're still in the early stages, but we're excited to share updates with you as things progress. It's also the reason we publish those exchange metrics each month, so all of you can follow along with us in what's basically real time. As for the perpetual futures spread in October, yes, volatility was mostly what drove that negative spread. But stepping back, we're still seeing solid progress with perpetual futures; our hope is that as options activity ramps up, it will trickle down into perpetuals too, and we can sort of push that into positive territory going forward. It's going to fluctuate. It'll depend to some degree on volatility, but the progress pleases us, and we're eager to make further progress on perpetual futures.
Excellent. That’s really helpful transparency. Many thanks.
Hello. I’m Guruwan Farinah, and we appreciate you taking our question. Now that options are officially available on the platform, could you help us grasp what capital efficiencies you might be able to deliver via enhanced cross-margining? Also, looking ahead, since tokenized assets could play a role here in enhancing collateral management, are there any particular near-term opportunities you foresee, maybe extending your partnership with Circle past USDC into USYC, or any other tokenized money market offering? If I may fit in one more tied directly to the earlier question, since options revenue is expected to become meaningful in early 2026, when should we expect perps revenue to finally turn positive? Thanks.
Thanks. Wow, that’s quite a lot. Regarding options, one advantage we enjoy, together with that single global order book, is a single matching engine. If you examine other exchanges, regulated and unregulated alike, that provide options, they usually maintain separate matching engines across different jurisdictions. They use a distinct matching engine for options versus perps. In one especially notable instance, they have a separate matching engine for spot, another separate matching engine for perps, and yet another separate matching engine for options. Aggregating trades and positions back into one global account then becomes extremely hard; as for us, our focus has always been on building in a straightforward way. We have one matching engine. We let customers, within one account, submit all their derivatives transactions plus their spot transactions, along with the collateral generated by those spot transactions, into one global order book. What that allows us to do is simply think creatively and apply intelligent, practical margining, collecting from every customer the smallest margin we possibly can, while never going below what’s needed. For instance, suppose a customer has sold Bitcoin calls while holding Bitcoin as collateral; you can take that account and extend reasonable margin. Suppose a customer holds a highly correlated crypto asset and has shorted a different highly correlated crypto asset; you can offer some offset—not a complete offset, but a partial one. This is the kind of thing that, well, it isn’t simple and it doesn’t lend itself to an easy soundbite, yet delivering that portfolio margining is essentially the lifeblood of the options trading community. That’s what they require, and that’s why they’ve come to us. Yesterday I was joking with a colleague, an old colleague of mine, and he mentioned that the previous company where we both worked had just received approval for a new VaR-based margining system that had been under development for 12 years. That should give you a sense of how complicated this can get. What makes this advantageous for us is that our starting point was already highly efficient, and that's the reason we're seeing this success so soon. As we get the opportunity to refine it, the efficiency will keep improving. On your point about tokenization, money markets serving as collateral, and similar matters, our approach remains to track the customers and what they're asking for. Tokenization across many kinds of assets, we believe, is creating fresh possibilities for us, whether in liquidity services, on the exchange through collateral trading pairs, or in other areas. With the market infrastructure bill hopefully getting passed, we expect tokenization to generate a great deal of new opportunity that reaches numerous segments of our business; as for perpetual futures, no specific guidance on transaction revenues is being offered by us. Providing that isn't something we do; that said, we do put out monthly exchange data, so you're able to track things from home in essentially real time. Progress on that line item, as I mentioned before, keeps showing up. In our view, 2026 is going to outperform 2025, and 2025 was considerably stronger than 2024. Keep watching, and keep an eye on the monthly metrics for news about every one of the transaction revenue line items.
Thanks. That's quite useful.
Hi, everyone. Morning. Nice improvement. I've just got a single, brief question regarding spot spreads. I'm aware that during Q2 there was a bit of added pricing leverage. Perhaps we could dig into that a bit further, along with some of the initiatives in that area and what you're observing in the spot market during Q3 and the start of Q4. Thanks.
Yeah. Appreciate it, Joe. The advancement on that front has been, yeah, I believe we mentioned this on the prior call. During the second quarter, we devoted considerable time to refining our overall pricing framework; it was likewise a notably low volatility setting. Together, those factors produced what we believe to be unusually low spreads across that quarter. You've obviously witnessed a fairly robust bounce back from the troughs observed around, let's say, the May and June period. Once more, we keep optimizing for total adjusted transaction revenue per unit of volatility. We're feeling fairly confident about our current position, yet the market, our customer base, and volatility are constantly shifting. We'll keep testing different spread levels. Wider spreads aren't always our objective; our objective is greater adjusted transaction revenue. There could be situations where somewhat narrower spreads generate additional volume, which more than makes up for the reduction in spreads. I'd say our present position serves as a fairly solid starting point going forward. That said, I'll repeat once more, the market situation is highly dynamic, and we'll keep adjusting to optimize for total adjusted transaction revenue.
I should point out that we need to wrap up precisely when the opening bell rings. I realize a few others are waiting in line, and we'll definitely follow up with you once this call ends, plus we'll be sure to bring you in early during the next one; we've got room for one more.
Yeah. Morning to you. Thanks for fielding my question. This will be a fast one from me. So, given that you've now gotten the BIT license in hand and made your way into the U.S., I'm just wondering, what comes after this? Do you still have geographies left where you want to go get a tier one license, or does the plan stay centered on folding the markets you already operate in into the global order book? Thanks.
Yeah. That's a good question. Not really. I'd point out that the U.K. hasn't yet put any legislation in place governing crypto trading, and eventually that will happen. No, we've got the Asia band, the Europe band, and now the U.S. band. There will be additional spot licenses that we intend to acquire, but honestly that isn't significant enough to warrant airtime on this call, aside from the U.K.; this is an ongoing pursuit of licenses. That applies not only to spot, but to derivatives and our index business too. It's like we've got full-time employees whose entire job this is. They'll keep collecting licenses nonstop, and we'll pass those updates along to you. The major ones by geography are already in place. I want to cut in here since I'm aware that Gautam and Owen and Ed, you're all waiting in the queue. My sincere apologies. Had I been less long-winded, we'd have made it through everything if only I could respond to every question the way Dave does. We'll be sure to reach you folks early next time; we'll also follow up within the next 24 to 48 hours and speak with each of you one on one. Last thing, I want to thank everyone once more for staying with the Bullish story, and I look forward to three months from now, when we can share with you all that we've gotten done in the interim. Much appreciated.
Everyone, that brings the Q&A portion of today's call to a close. We appreciate all of you for joining in. At this point, feel free to hang up your phones. Enjoy the rest of your day, folks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Bullish transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.
Get an API key View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Bullish earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server.
Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search,
and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.