Cannae Holdings, Inc. (CNNE) Earnings Call Transcript
May 11, 2026
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Thanks, operator, and good afternoon everyone. We appreciate you being with us for Cannae Holdings' first quarter 2026 earnings call. Joining us today are Ryan Caswell, our Chief Executive Officer, and Bryan Coy, our Chief Financial Officer. Before we get started, I want to remind everyone listening that forward-looking statements and references to non-GAAP financial measures may be part of this call. Any statements that aren't historical facts — including those regarding Cannae's expectations, hopes, intentions, or strategies about the future — count as forward-looking statements. Such statements rest on management's beliefs, along with assumptions management has made and information that's currently available to management. Since these statements are built on expectations about future financial and operating results rather than established facts, actual results could differ materially from what's projected. The company has no obligation to update any forward-looking statements, whether because of new information, future events, or anything else. Risks and uncertainties that forward-looking statements are exposed to include, without limitation, the risks and other factors laid out in our quarterly Shareholder Letter, which came out this afternoon, and in our other SEC filings. References to non-GAAP financial measures will also appear in today's remarks. You can find additional information, including a reconciliation between the non-GAAP financial information and the GAAP financial information, in our Shareholder Letter; these statements carry risks and uncertainties described in our Shareholder Letter and SEC filings, and we have no obligation to update forward-looking statements; with that, I'll hand the call over to Ryan.
Thanks, Jamie. Good afternoon, everyone. There are four main areas I’d like to discuss on today’s call: the way we put our capital to work during the quarter, the situation at Black Knight Football, which is our biggest sports holding, where things stand with the restaurant segment and the sale of further non-core assets, and how the holding company is being run. Let’s begin with capital allocation. During Q1, we gave back roughly $51 million to shareholders via share repurchases plus our standard dividend, and that dividend presently delivers a 4.2% yield. So far this year, that $51 million accounts for roughly 86% of everything we’ve deployed. The other 14% went into investments we already hold. Twelve months ago, the comparable return to shareholders was roughly 70%. Our decision to lean toward buybacks during the quarter was intentional, since we believed the best return available to us was our own stock; we’ll keep reviewing how we deploy capital to figure out what does the most for shareholder value, whether that’s returning capital or putting it into new investments. On repurchases in particular, since the start of the year we’ve bought back 3.4 million shares, equal to roughly 7.3% of shares outstanding, for $43 million. During the quarter, our board increased the buyback authorization to 14.9 million shares, giving us room to keep making opportunistic repurchases; now turning to Black Knight Football, the biggest single position in our portfolio and, in my opinion, the holding with the most upside. AFC Bournemouth is currently sixth in the Premier League. Should the club stay there, that would be its best-ever finish across its 127 year history, and it would send the club into European competition for the first time. Qualifying for Europe isn’t merely a sporting achievement. It significantly alters the club’s commercial side, its brand, and its economics. Those results on the pitch stand out even more given that across the past 18 months, we’ve sold star players to Manchester City, Real Madrid, Paris Saint-Germain, and Liverpool, bringing in about $360 million in transfer fees altogether. We’ve managed that while improving our results, not declining. That shows the platform behind our investing and operating approach is delivering. Here’s one concrete illustration, because I believe it sums up the whole multi-club investment case. There’s a player called Eli Junior Kroupi, age 19, who progressed through the academy at FC Lorient, one of the clubs we own. In January of last year, AFC Bournemouth, another club in our group, bought him from Lorient and left him there for the rest of the season so he could develop and assist with their promotion back to Ligue 1. This season, he made the move to Bournemouth. He leads Bournemouth in scoring, and he has netted more goals in one Premier League campaign than any teenager ever has in the league’s history; that is the multi-club platform demonstrated in a single deal. We grew an asset at one club and shifted that asset to another club at the right moment for both the team and the player. Ultimately, from a financial standpoint and an athletic one, the two teams come out ahead, plus the athlete gains and advances his professional path. That shows what the multi-club model is worth and will generate returns on what we've invested at Black Knight Football. The money side matches the sports side, with revenue and EBITDA rising by double digits to reach $136 million, thanks to substantial player transfers and the better revenues mentioned earlier. Bryan is going to cover these figures more thoroughly when he speaks; during the prior quarter we placed a thorough summary of Black Knight Football on Cannae's website. I'd urge each person listening to set aside some time for it, since it reflects the effort we've put in. Moving on to the restaurants. The strategic review of the restaurant group we told you about earlier is still underway. What I'm able to share today is that the board hasn't shifted its stance. This asset isn't core to us, and we aim to turn it into cash, get the most proceeds possible, and put that money back to work either in opportunities with better returns, which would boost our NAV, or in our own shares. We're putting in serious effort to reach that goal and anticipate offering a fuller update when we next speak. On a wider note, the board keeps examining our whole portfolio each quarter to find the best moment to divest non-core assets. Restaurants aren't the sole item under review. You ought to anticipate ongoing changes in our portfolio, which I'll explain when the timing is right. My final subject is the holding company. We remain focused on bringing down our corporate holding company expenses. I'll have Bryan say more about this during his remarks, though for Q1 our corporate holding company costs fell by roughly 45% versus a year ago, showing the discipline the board and management have brought to cutting corporate holding company costs. Regarding governance, the board is still assessing additional governance improvements. During the first quarter, we changed up our committee membership to bring in the four new directors voted in last year, adding fresh viewpoints to committee discussions. To wrap up, we're carrying out our strategy. We're seeking ways to push the portfolio further toward sports and entertainment-related assets as we convert our non-core assets into cash; we're taking opportunities to return significant capital to shareholders at prices we consider far beneath intrinsic value. We're strengthening the companies in our portfolio and offering greater transparency on each one. We're lowering holding company costs. We'll continue these efforts until the discount shuts and NAV rises. Having said that, I'll hand the call to Bryan.
Thank you, Ryan. Good afternoon, everyone. I'll go over what we saw in the first quarter, and then I'll wrap up with a quick comment regarding our balance sheet and liquidity. For Q1, total operating revenues came in at $96 million, which is a 7% decrease versus the same period a year ago. That entire drop was attributable to the restaurant group, reflecting the shuttering of eight O'Charley's sites since March of last year along with weaker traffic at both brands. Over at Ninety Nine, larger average guest checks almost fully made up for the traffic shortfall. At O'Charley's, menu pricing clawed back about half of the decline in traffic. Brasada Ranch's revenue was roughly unchanged from one quarter to the next. In the first quarter of 2026, total operating expenses reached $118 million, versus $125 million in last year's first quarter. That reflects unchanged operating expenses for the restaurant group plus lower holding company expenses. The cost of restaurant revenues fell by a bit more than $7 million given the lower top-line volume I mentioned earlier; that reduction was countered by roughly $8 million of non-cash impairments on restaurant right of use and assets and fixed assets. As part of our push for greater transparency, we included additional disclosure regarding corporate holding company expenses in the MD&A section of the 10-Q we filed today. In the meantime, I'll note that holding company expenses came to $8.9 million in the first quarter of 2026, versus $16.1 million during the same quarter a year ago, a reduction of $7.2 million, or 45%, year-over-year; that reflects a $3.6 million decline in corporate personnel costs stemming from lower bonus and stock compensation following the management transition, along with no management or termination fees, compared with $3.6 million in the first quarter of last year; we anticipate this run rate will persist through the rest of the year. Now looking at our equity method investments, which include Black Knight Football. As Ryan mentioned earlier, total revenue at Black Knight Football rose 19% to $274 million for the 12 months ended December 31st, 2025. That revenue increase was driven by on-field performance through higher commercial revenue at Bournemouth and by bringing Moreirense in for the half year. EBITDA climbed from $12 million in calendar year 2024 to $136 million in 2025, fueled by player trading profits rising nearly four-fold, from $30 million in 2024 to $113 million in 2025. Adjusted EBITDA, which strips out player trading profits, went from — $5 million in 2024 to + $21 million in 2025 on better operating leverage net of higher player wages. On the other EMIs, a significant factor behind the year-over-year variance is a valuation gain on our CSI holding that had benefited the prior year period. Moving to the balance sheet. At the corporate level, Cannae held $123 million of cash at quarter end. Following continued buyback activity since the quarter closed, we sit at approximately $90 million today. We filed our corporate tax return and refund claim in March. Later in this year, we anticipate getting roughly $45 million in cash refunds plus around $10 million more in tax assets, following the reclassification of part of that refund into carryforwards. In Q1, we ended Cannae's margin loan, cutting commitment and custody fees by about $350,000 each year. Once that was terminated, the sole corporate-level debt remaining consists of $48 million in 5% fixed-rate interest-only term debt, which won't come due for more than four years. With that said, operator, please open the line for questions.
Hi there, good afternoon, and I appreciate you taking my question. I just have one regarding how the portfolio is allocated. Given the shift over the longer term toward putting money into sports and media, how ought we to think about certain investments made previously — JANA Partners and Watkins, for instance, and I suppose most of the remaining ones, apart from BKFC — is the intention to ultimately monetize essentially every one of those? Thank you.
Yeah. Appreciate that, Ken. Our focus is moving toward properties tied to sports and entertainment, though having said that, every investment we currently hold appeals to us, and we see appealing qualities there. Each quarter, my practice is to go through the whole portfolio alongside the board, and together we decide if selling off any holdings would be wise. Once it's suitable, we'll of course make public whatever determinations the board reaches, much as we did in the case of the restaurant group.
Understood; regarding giving money back to shareholders, is there any fresh assessment, and I realize you've looked at this before when it comes to sending capital back either via repurchases or by keeping on with repurchases, or have you also considered dividends or special dividends? Thanks.
Yes. Right now, when it comes to repurchases, our commitment to buying back stock is unchanged, and you can see that in what we've purchased so far in 2024. Special dividends or anything along those lines haven't been something we've examined. The regular dividend, of course, continues. More generally, I'd say we review how we deploy capital and our liquidity continuously, weighing what delivers the greatest value for shareholders — whether that's returning capital or putting money into new investments; that's the approach we'll keep using moving forward.
Understood. One additional question from my side. Once more, as you look across the whole portfolio, are you continuing to hold ongoing conversations and keep a pipeline of possible deals or fresh investments? I'd just like a bit more detail on that. Thank you.
Yes, we are. I believe what we're doing is drawing on the network we already have, because of how well some of our sports assets have performed, and we're attempting to share a little more detail on this in our — or we will share it in an updated investor deck coming out later today. We're evaluating various deals. With every new investment we consider, we try to figure out whether putting money into a new business delivers greater value for our shareholders than carrying on with the share buyback. During the last quarter, we directed the funds toward share buyback. We're seeing plenty of deals. We'll run that analysis as we move forward.
Great. Very helpful. That's all I had.
Thanks again.
Hey, Ryan. Thanks a lot. Sort of following up on that buyback topic — how are you approaching the sizing of buybacks, since the stock is really quite cheap right now? What's your thinking on actually just going ahead and doing additional buybacks? When you consider the other ways you could use cash and put money to work, how demanding is the threshold for fresh investments? Is there, like, a pretty slim likelihood that you'll make additional investments, or is there still a pretty strong likelihood that you will? If that's the case, could you perhaps share an example of what you're looking for, maybe which part of your verticals you're in? Thanks.
Thank you. I'll attempt to address those individually. To start, regarding buybacks and attempting to determine their size, we consider liquidity, and liquidity across the coming, well, 6 to 12 months when it comes to how we approach buybacks, and that liquidity review also takes in the timing of certain of these other non-core asset sales. I'd rather not give a particular size framework. You clearly can look back at what we did during the 1st quarter and historically. For every buyback and every, we examine liquidity and the capital allocation framework I brought up earlier; when it comes to new investments, management and the board are concentrated on attempting to maximize shareholder value via the growth of NAV over time. We have discussed how we are shifting the portfolio toward sports and entertainment assets. To accomplish that, we do have to make new investments. We're being thoughtful and mindful regarding those when it comes to, once again, considering size and liquidity, and valuation and future performance. We believe that shifting the portfolio toward the sports-related assets will generate the most shareholder value over time.
All right, thank you. One more question on that. What's the status of the options we're weighing for the restaurants? You spent a lot of time on how they've been performing, so where do things stand on those strategic alternatives? Thanks.
Like I said during my prepared remarks, that process around strategic alternatives continues. Our aim is to get the most value and the largest proceeds possible out of every asset. By the time we reach next quarter, we expect to be able to share something more complete. These assets are not core to us — that's the board's strong position — and our efforts are focused on turning them into cash.
All right, thank you.
Thank you.
Hi there, good afternoon. First question from me concerns the repurchase plan. During 2024, Cannae acquired quite a large block of outstanding shares via a tender offer. What I'd like to know is whether, considering the number of shares that remain authorized under the existing repurchase program and possibly the cash coming in from the restaurant business, the company might explore running a structured process similar to what was done in 2024?
Yeah. Appreciate it, Oscar. At this moment our attention is on buying in the open market. A tender was something we carried out previously, so it remains an option we could look at should we fail to obtain the volume or pricing we were after. The shares were purchased by us at a premium, and the stock subsequently traded down; over the near term, open market purchases are what we're concentrating on as our method of repurchasing.
That's useful. For my next question, what could you share regarding Alight and how you're currently viewing that particular investment?
Our outlook on Alight is positive, and we feel the same about the new chief executive. For details on how the company is doing, I'd point you toward what he has said at greater length. We have held a stake in this company for some time now, and we back both him and the organization. Like I mentioned before, every quarter we go over each of our holdings together with our board so we can decide when the right moment is.
All right. For my final question, regarding that $55 million tax refund—or the $45 million you brought up before—how do you plan to split those funds between repurchasing shares and possible added investments in certain core assets? And what ultimately will be the deciding factor there?
When it comes to putting that money to work, our approach will mirror how we treat any liquidity sitting on our balance sheet—namely, figuring out what represents the best value for our shareholders at that moment. During the most recent quarter, roughly 86% of our excess capital, or of our capital, went toward buybacks and dividends. Decisions will be made individually as situations arise, depending on where we stand with investments or what price our stock is fetching.
That's quite useful, thanks.
I'd like to express appreciation to everyone for your backing as we keep carrying out our strategic priorities. We're eager to share news about how we're advancing when the next quarter comes. Thanks so much.
Appreciate it, sirs. So once more, everyone, that brings to a close the Cannae Holdings, Inc. First Quarter 2026 Earnings Conference Call. Many thanks to each of you for being with us today; we hope the rest of your afternoon is excellent. Farewell.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Cannae Holdings, Inc. transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.
Get an API key View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Cannae Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server.
Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search,
and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.