Home / Transcripts / Post Holdings, Inc. (POST) · May 8, 2026

Post Holdings, Inc. (POST) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 8, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Food Products earnings 32 min

What were the key takeaways from Post Holdings, Inc.'s May 8, 2026 earnings call?

In the second quarter of fiscal 2026, Post Holdings, Inc. reported strong performance driven by a diversified portfolio, with adjusted EBITDA exceeding expectations. Revenue figures were not explicitly stated, but management maintained previous adjusted EBITDA guidance due to new headwinds from the conflict in the Middle East. The company continues to execute aggressive share repurchases, reducing share count by 15% year-to-date, which may positively influence stock performance moving forward.

What topics did Post Holdings, Inc. cover?

What were Post Holdings, Inc.'s May 8, 2026 results?

Post Holdings demonstrated resilience in its second quarter performance, but challenges in the pet food segment and external cost pressures remain key risks. The aggressive share repurchase strategy and strong cash flow position the company favorably for future growth. Investors should monitor inflation trends and the performance of the pet food category as potential catalysts or risks.

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Daniel O'Rourke executive
#1

Hello, and thanks for being with us for the question and answer portion of Post Holdings' earnings call covering the second quarter of fiscal 2026. With me this morning are Rob Vitale, our Chairman and CEO, Nico Catoggio, our COO, and Matt Mainer, our CFO and Treasurer. This session is being recorded, and an audio replay will be posted on our website, postholdings.com. Throughout today's call, we might deliver forward-looking statements, and those carry risks and uncertainties that investors ought to weigh carefully, since actual results may differ materially from what those statements suggest. Such forward-looking statements reflect circumstances as of today's date. Management assumes no duty to revise them. Our press release, along with written management remarks supporting this call, can be found in the Investors section of our website; on this call we will address certain non-GAAP measures. To see how those non-GAAP measures reconcile to the closest GAAP measure, please consult our press release, which went out yesterday and is available on our website. We hope you've had the opportunity to go through our management remarks. The main takeaways are that our diversified portfolio turned in strong performance during Q2 and generated Adjusted EBITDA that exceeded expectations. In light of fresh headwinds stemming from the conflict in the Middle East, we kept our prior Adjusted EBITDA guidance unchanged; we stayed aggressive with share repurchases, and on a fiscal year to date basis we've cut our share count by 15%. Our solid cash flow, liquidity and credit metrics keep giving us considerable flexibility for opportunistic capital allocations. With that, I'll hand things over briefly to Matt.

Matt Mainer executive
#2

Hello, and thank you, Daniel. Beyond how the business has performed, I'm certain everyone here caught yesterday's news regarding who will take over as our CEO. To begin, everyone on our team wishes Nico well — this is thoroughly earned. Your leadership at PCB has been outstanding, and we have every belief that this will carry over as you step into the top role at Post. As for Rob, all of us have gained from the finest guidance, and we genuinely value the direction you've provided throughout these last 12 years. Though Rob commands great respect from so many listening in on this call, that admiration runs even deeper among those of us inside this company. With that said, I'll hand things to the operator so we can begin Q&A.

Andrew Lazar analyst
#3

Great, thank you very much. Rob, congratulations on an outstanding tenure as CEO, and I'm happy you'll remain as Chairman. I'll just say that I believe plenty of other packaged food companies could gain enormously by borrowing from how you run operations and allocate capital. Nico, congratulations on your appointment as COO.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#4

Thanks.

Andrew Lazar analyst
#5

To begin with, yes, absolutely. Maybe just one question about pricing, for the industry and for Post. I understand there's still a fair amount of uncertainty, but if the industry were to encounter another wave of bigger inflation, do you believe pricing might be among the tools applied this time, given that consumers have already been resisting the price points as they stand now, and a few are in fact cutting prices with, you know, results that haven't been great so far? I'm just wondering what your perspective is on that, and how does Post kind of approach it?

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#6

Thank you, Andrew. What I'd say is that it hinges on where inflation lands. Should it be in the low single digit, then I believe we'll see more CPGs attempting to soak that up inside their P&L, and that might come through perhaps reducing promotional intensity. Should it be beyond that, then we'll likely see pricing that is more targeted.

Andrew Lazar analyst
#7

Perhaps we could focus on pet food for a moment. I'm attempting to gauge what we ought to expect moving forward within the pet segment. Because my understanding is that this quarter—the one we're currently in—is when the restage genuinely begins taking hold across the marketplace. How do you approach revitalizing a brand within a subcategory of dry dog food that is, you know, somewhat challenged at present compared with certain other areas of pet?

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#8

Yeah. Regarding pet, I tend to break it down into roughly three major buckets. The first is somewhat beyond our influence; namely, the category has moved more slowly than we had projected, particularly dry dog food. Dry dog food makes up 60% of our portfolio. As we noted in our remarks, that declined 4% in pounds. That accounts for roughly 20% of the gap between us and the category. The remainder can be split evenly across two buckets. The first is what we discussed regarding 9Lives. 9Lives. We increased prices on a third of the brand—the portion that is more functional. When those price increases went through, elasticities came in higher than we had expected. We lost distribution in a couple of retailers; to our minds, that part is pretty clear-cut. If you recall, less than a year ago, we were discussing Gravy Train in much the same way. We raised prices. Keep in mind these brands carry lower margins, which is precisely why we take these actions; our focus is on profit. We recall Gravy Train: we raised prices, elasticities behaved the same way; we resolved it near-term through rollbacks, and now we've resolved it through price pack architecture; that brand, at one of our largest retailers, is now growing 40% in pounds. We view this as the identical playbook, correct? We tested the price point. Elasticity came in somewhat higher; we can address it near-term with rollbacks. Over the longer term—call it 2 quarters out—we ought to resolve it through price pack architecture. It's pretty clear-cut. The third bucket is Nutrish; we're in the early phases of the relaunch, which will likely require all of Q3 to truly reach the market fully. It's underway, it's flowing in, and it's still taking somewhat longer—especially in the food channel—to be fully reflected on shelf. That one, if you recall, we addressed it; it's a complete relaunch featuring new positioning, new packaging and new price points. What gives us encouragement is that where it has been fully relaunched—at one of our largest retailers—we're already observing sequential improvement week after week. During the last week of April, we already saw the brand flat versus last year in a category that, again, is declining; that's a positive sign, though it remains early and we likely need a couple more months. Come Q4, we should really begin seeing the category at least showing flat to slight growth compared with a year ago. That's the way our thinking goes on that matter.

Andrew Lazar analyst
#9

Excellent, and I really appreciate the detail. Congrats once more.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#10

Thank you very much.

Matt Smith analyst
#11

Hello, and good morning. During this quarter, you delivered yet another robust EBITDA and cash flow result, and when reiterating guidance, you mentioned being cautious regarding fresh cost pressure along with uncertainty. Which particular parts of the business are showing these elevated costs? Is a more hesitant consumer having an effect, or does the uncertainty center more on the cost side?

Matt Mainer executive
#12

Yes, Matt, what we're seeing firsthand is the cost effect, primarily tied to fuel charges and surcharges. Some coverage, or hedges, are in place for us, yet this represents exposure past those coverages, and simply because of the sharp rise in diesel that moves through the entire company, particularly in North America. That's truly the main driver.

Matt Smith analyst
#13

Thank you, Matt. I just have one more question. Your cash flow results have been robust, which enabled the buybacks announced today while keeping leverage unchanged. You highlighted the solid liquidity that Post has been maintaining. What's your read on the M&A landscape? Are more assets becoming available? Do you feel that sellers' expectations are sensible? Has deal flow been affected by instability and turmoil in the Middle East? Thanks.

Matt Mainer executive
#14

Yeah, I'd say it's still largely a continuation of what we've been seeing. You know, there are definitely certain assets, certain private investments that have yet to be brought to market, and I believe that reflects where public multiples stand and, you know, where a clearing price could land. There remain potential deals that are waiting on the sidelines. Beyond that, you know, you keep hearing some of our bigger competitors discuss possibly spinning off parts of their portfolios; we've already witnessed that occur in a couple of instances over the past year. I'd view those as bigger, more transformative deals. Again, we review everything, but it's something we'd assess. I think it's somewhat of a barbell shape. There are the smaller tuck-ins, which are on offer and, for us, come with more synergies and are clearly simpler to absorb. I think what really sets the backdrop for us is where our stock is trading and the multiple that's implied. Again, we set that out in the prepared remarks, and that genuinely serves as our yardstick, our point of comparison. It remains a demanding hurdle. We keep evaluating everything that's available.

Matt Smith analyst
#15

Thanks for that, Matt. I'll make sure to share it.

David Palmer analyst
#16

I appreciate it, and well done on everything you've accomplished in your career up to now, Rob, along with all the value you've created.

Rob Vitale executive
#17

I'm grateful.

David Palmer analyst
#18

back to you, Nico. Yeah.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#19

Thank you.

David Palmer analyst
#20

Thanks. My first question concerns food service profitability. Obviously, there was a period when a great deal of business shifted toward value eggs with better margins, because egg prices had risen, and now those prices have fallen, and this has been quite a strong stretch for profitability. I'd like to know how you view the path of profitability ahead. Perhaps it climbs from here toward something like a mid-cycle level as some of your accounts perform better of late; put another way, I'm trying to determine whether $125 million a quarter will truly be the appropriate run rate as we enter fiscal 2027, or whether you believe there's upside beyond that. I have a follow-up.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#21

We continue to view that as the run rate, though once more, during the quarter there were numerous puts and takes, including lapping HPAI, constraints on supply, pricing, and costs exceeding pricing a year ago. Even so, our supply and demand stay balanced, so although we don't give guidance by segment, we expect to return to our run rate.

David Palmer analyst
#22

Understood. And along the lines of what was asked earlier about pet, I'm just trying to gauge, regarding cereal, how confident you are in achieving what I believe is your target of a decline in the low single digits, so that it genuinely carries its own weight. Cereal has been tough.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#23

Yeah.

David Palmer analyst
#24

How confident are you in reaching that, and what does the outlook look like there? Thanks.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#25

I'll begin with the category. As we mentioned in our remarks, the category has performed better than it did 12 months ago. During the quarter, the category declined 3% in pounds, and looking at April, it's down 2.5%. Things are getting better. It's still not quite at pre-pandemic levels, but it's moving in that direction. That covers the category. As for our portfolio, you're seeing part of it. We're very happy with where we stand. Q2 was another period in which we continued working through the transition assortment, particularly in the food channel, so we could be better positioned or achieve a higher return on promotional spend. Our promotional spend came down slightly compared to the prior year, and even so, we were the only large player that held flat dollar market share versus a year ago. We feel really good about our portfolio, and we feel good about the category's improvement.

David Palmer analyst
#26

Thanks.

Tom Palmer analyst
#27

Morning, everyone. I want to add my congrats to the two of you, and I’m grateful for all your support, Rob, while I’ve been getting up to speed on Post.

Rob Vitale executive
#28

Thanks.

Tom Palmer analyst
#29

I wanted to build on what David asked regarding the food service segment, particularly around some of the egg-related trends. Clearly, during the quarter, declining egg prices appear to be providing a boost to earnings, especially judging from certain disclosures regarding input costs. I was hoping to ask about the possibility of either reducing your prices, as you see it, or if you're noticing any potential movement among customers—since whole eggs are so inexpensive—toward the more labor-intensive approach of beginning with whole eggs rather than purchasing prepared egg products. I just want to confirm that neither of those is something we ought to be watching for. Thank you.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#30

Certainly; regarding the switching question, that's clearly a risk we assess. To be honest, because of the value proposition and what we've observed, particularly among larger operators, once they adopt our value-added products, they can remove that labor from their operations and they recognize the advantages of consistency, food safety, and other aspects of the product, it's very sticky. I would say the, you know, perhaps the exposure lies with some of the smaller independent operators, who represent a significantly smaller portion of our business, where they possess somewhat greater flexibility in the back of the house to make that change. Again, I believe overall, most of the portfolio regards that shift as quite sticky.

Tom Palmer analyst
#31

All right. Appreciate the update. I had a question about Weetabix — specifically your remarks regarding the license, and how reported sales there may have looked somewhat softer than the underlying consumption patterns across the wider business. How significant is the licensing effect we ought to factor in? And how much of 2Q actually captures the full scale we should expect in the coming quarters? Thank you.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#32

Absolutely. As for what drove that, it ties back to the Oreo O's licensing arrangement we hold, and my understanding is there's one more quarter until we completely anniversary its removal. Regarding how we see things from a volume perspective across the rest of the year, we'd anticipate stronger year-over-year results once we lap that in the back half. As a point of reference, the category has returned to being more flat, which is where cereal in the U.K. has historically sat, or at least what we've observed. Speaking of Weetabix, the yellow box item especially carries quite a bit of strong momentum and keeps overperforming. Once we lap Oreo O's and it drops off as we move into Q3, we'd expect you to begin seeing improved results across our portfolio as a whole because of that.

Tom Palmer analyst
#33

All right. Appreciate it.

Scott Marks analyst
#34

Hello, and good morning. We really appreciate you fielding our questions, and once more, congratulations go out to Nico and Rob.

Rob Vitale executive
#35

Thanks.

Scott Marks analyst
#36

I wanted to follow up on Weetabix after Thomas' question, focusing more on the profitability angle. Clearly, the margins for that business remain well under where they used to be. I'm just hoping you could help us get a clearer picture of the route back to that 30% mark and how we ought to view the opportunities inside that business.

Matt Mainer executive
#37

Scott, first off, I'd like to remind everyone that UFit keeps expanding at a solid pace within the portfolio. It operates as a co-managed business, yet since it's co-managed, its sales growth comes with lower margins. Realistically, that has capped our ability to hit 30%, which is actually fine because our profit dollars are still rising. Regarding the step-by-step gains from our current position, we managed to carry out some network optimization at the close of March and shut down a facility on the private label side, thanks to our Deeside acquisition 2 years back. That fit into the overall strategy. We got it done, and it should drive improved profitability in the latter half. You should anticipate that when examining EBITDA margins, the sequential gains will be clear in Q3 and Q4 compared with the first half.

Scott Marks analyst
#38

All right. Thanks for that perspective. Maybe turning now to refrigerated retail — clearly the volume numbers were really strong this quarter. You mentioned some Easter timing helped things out. Could you give us a sense of how big that benefit actually was, and how we ought to frame the run rate for that segment heading into the back half? Thanks.

Matt Mainer executive
#39

Absolutely. We recorded a fairly meaningful increase in dinner sides, or sides for the business, coming in at 12% growth. Easter was far and away the largest factor, and if you look back over time, whenever Easter lands, it delivers a substantial bump. Given that Easter occurred in Q3 last year but landed in Q2 this year, I'd characterize that as accounting for most of the year-over-year change. The second thing driving it was definitely the new private label items we launched at the start of the fiscal year. Those keep performing well. You could make the case that they got a bit of a tailwind from Easter too — those really are the two factors. Clearly, once Easter drops out, what remains is the ongoing, you know, lapping of the private label rollout until we reach the end of the year.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#40

Scott, I'd also mention that our rounded portfolio did see a bit of volume growth underneath. Naturally, it's just — I mean, assuming you had a pair of As, you'd describe it as roughly a third, split among underlying volume growth, private label, and Easter.

Scott Marks analyst
#41

All right. That's appreciated. Thank you. I'll relay that.

Marc Torrente analyst
#42

Hello, good morning, and thanks for taking the questions. Rob and Nico, my congratulations too. So, first, regarding the added expense effect coming from energy that you anticipate, has it begun showing up in the P&L yet? Is it more of a gradual build through the second half? At what point would you choose to act on pricing if it becomes necessary, and how fast might that deliver an offset?

Matt Mainer executive
#43

Sure; we're definitely observing those impacts now that we've reached the close of Q2 and moved into the start of Q3. Fairly steady, I'd say, subject to how much hedging we had in place for the rest of the year. You can probably view it as a fairly typical run rate, if the war continues through the end of the fiscal year, since that's what our base assumption contains. Pricing. Once more, that varies by business, but largely, at present, we're assuming we'll take that through the P&L. Should this go past this fiscal year, we'd likely then start thinking about pricing. Again, it truly hinges on where inflation lands. What I mean is, at the moment we're seeing it in fuel and somewhat in packaging. If those things in fact worsen, we'll need to consider pricing, and it's likely to land in the new fiscal year. But again, far too soon to tell.

Marc Torrente analyst
#44

Got it, thanks. Perhaps you could give us an update on how 8th Avenue has been doing since the business was folded in. Since this was the first quarter where we only had the ongoing business, what did it contribute during the quarter? And how are things going with integration and capturing synergies? Thanks.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#45

Performance of the underlying business matches the deal model. We're happy with that; a few takes and a handful of categories came in a touch better, others a touch worse, but overall, it aligns with the deal model. We feel quite good. Integration is going very well indeed. Synergies are running somewhat ahead of plan. As we expected, we ought to reach run rate near the close of this fiscal year. We feel quite good about the two combined, correct? The team remains focused, there are no distractions, the business keeps performing, and chances are we are over-delivering when it comes to synergies.

Marc Torrente analyst
#46

Thank you.

John Baumgartner analyst
#47

Good morning, and thanks for taking my question. Perhaps, first of all, to Rob Vitale: it's truly been an enjoyable journey over these last 10 years, and just, you know, I want to express a lot of gratitude for everything you've shared and every conversation we've had through the years. It was honestly, you know, a tremendous opportunity to learn. Thank you, and wishing you nothing but the best going forward.

Rob Vitale executive
#48

Thank you.

John Baumgartner analyst
#49

Nico, congratulations on this opportunity too. I appreciate it from both of you very much.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#50

Thank you very much.

John Baumgartner analyst
#51

So when it comes to ready-to-drink protein shakes, this is a space you know inside and out. You put up the capital for the manufacturing facility. What I want to know is, first, how do you see the durability of growth in this category, and how do you view your own role as a manufacturer, especially with so many new brands entering the space — what's your read on the competitive landscape from a manufacturer's standpoint? And second, given how public equities in RTD are rated at a B, and possibly private assets too, how would you approach getting back into RTD as a brand owner once more? I'd assume it's accretive to growth, accretive to free cash. You'd capture synergies by bringing volume back in with a vertical operator. Where do you see your position in that category today and looking ahead?

Rob Vitale executive
#52

Yeah, I mean, I think we need to be cautious about which questions we respond to from the vantage point of BellRing. Answering as a manufacturer seems perfectly fine to me, but not as a brand owner. I'll let you address the—

Matt Mainer executive
#53

Yes. Once more, regarding the shake segment, I believe we keep observing chances to expand alongside BellRing, as we are one of their main suppliers. We have improved our internal situation when it comes to sheer volume within the shake area. I believe our confidence in that business is rising. We have discussed certain elevated expenses that we are attempting to manage, specifically those running above what we expected related to the production process as well as some of the costs we are taking on. When it comes to volume, we are witnessing stronger results, and there is definitely appetite for the volume we are moving through on BellRing's end.

John Baumgartner analyst
#54

Appreciate that. For my follow-up: in certain parts of the industry, we're noticing food service brands achieving quite strong market share gains in retail grocery and successfully crossing over into that channel — soup, french fries, mashed potatoes. Bob Evans is already in your portfolio. Given how challenging volume growth is for many traditional retail brands, how are you thinking about using those manufacturing assets to perhaps take Bob Evans into new categories, or to license additional food service brands so they can enter more categories within your meals focus? Have you at all considered this as a potential growth avenue by leveraging your assets?

Rob Vitale executive
#55

You put it well; much of what the Bob Evans business amounts to is exactly that, correct? It does put a lot of the Michael Foods assets to work. In terms of moving into other categories, I believe the Bob Evans team, as with all our teams, evaluates that constantly, and it hinges on what they regard as their capacity to win in the category and the trends present there. In fact, I'd point out that the Bob Evans team — the Bob Evans business is basically that operation which utilizes the Michael Foods assets.

John Baumgartner analyst
#56

Great. Thanks for your time this morning.

Carla Casella analyst
#57

Hi, and thanks for taking the question. You spoke a little about private brand today, and it brings up the question of how much of your business is private brand at present, and where do you rank highest as a percentage of the segment? Is there additional opportunity there? I suppose the follow-up to that, and margin opportunity as well.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#58

Post Consumer Brands is where we actually have the largest private label brand and the highest in terms of percentage of the total business, and roughly 20% of the business is private label. If I understood, your question is like, what is our position? Our cereal, granola, and peanut butter businesses are in a really solid spot. On the pet side, our private label presence is on the smaller side, and what we do there skews toward the premium end of private label. As far as where we can grow, we're seeing openings across every one of those categories. Broadly speaking, whenever we're competing in a category, we're constantly asking how the branded side and the private label side can work together to our advantage, correct?

Carla Casella analyst
#59

All right. It seems your growth is tilted more toward the refrigerated side, so I wanted to ask whether any private label exists alongside Weetabix over in Europe?

Rob Vitale executive
#60

Yes, Weetabix does include private label, and that's been true for a number of years at this point. Our expansion is quicker in refrigerated mainly because we essentially chose to get back into the private label business within that category. It's starting from basically zero. We view that as a chance, a continuing chance. Right now it's focused on a smaller set of retailers, though it's also a possibility in that space.

Carla Casella analyst
#61

All right. So is the potential in that area comparable to what you have going on with consumer brands? For instance, do you expect those categories to reach a 20% private brand share?

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#62

That's hard to answer. I'd say Weetabix probably is. Actually, it's above that, yes.

Rob Vitale executive
#63

The figure exceeds 20%.

Nicolas Catoggio executive
#64

Looking at Weetabix by category, store brands hold a far bigger position in the U.K. compared with the U.S., which is clearly a notably smaller market. Regarding branded against private label, our share matches what the category shows.

Matt Mainer executive
#65

When it comes to private label over in that market, our share sits above 40%. I'd say we're roughly in line there, and I'm not sure there's much room to gain. Having those alternative price points is something we feel really good about, the same way we do at Post Consumer Brands. Our view is that this creates a competitive edge for us and opens doors with retailers, both when it comes to the branded side and, you know, through that private label footprint.

Carla Casella analyst
#66

All right. May I pose a single brief question regarding finances? You've accomplished quite a bit when it comes to repurchasing shares. You've also completed several refinancings as of late. What amount of cash ought we to factor in as necessary to remain on the books simply to operate the company?

Matt Mainer executive
#67

Certainly. Our typical way of looking at it is roughly $150 million in cash held on the balance sheet to support working capital needs. Given our Weetabix office along with international operations, that figure is approximately the proper amount of cash required for day-to-day business.

Carla Casella analyst
#68

Okay, great. Thank you so much.

Matt Mainer executive
#69

Thank you.

Carla Casella analyst
#70

Thanks.

Operator operator
#71

Thanks; that wraps up the Q&A portion for today, and it also brings Post Holdings' Q2 2026 earnings conference call and webcast to a close. At this point, please drop off the line, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Post Holdings, Inc. transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Post Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.