Commerzbank AG (CBK) Earnings Call Transcript
November 6, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Good day, everyone, and thank you for joining Commerzbank AG's conference call on our 2025 third-quarter results. I'd like to point out that this call is being broadcast and captured via audio webcast, and afterward it will be posted online for replay. Right now, everyone attending is in listen-only mode. Once Bettina Orlopp and Carsten Schmitt have finished their presentation, we'll open the line for your questions. I'll now hand things over to our CEO, Bettina Orlopp.
Good morning, everyone, and welcome to our earnings call. Commerzbank's growth story is still going, and we've posted the strongest nine-month operating result in the bank's history. That momentum also shapes our outlook. With net interest income expectations raised, we're very confident about hitting our targets in 2025. I'll take you through the financial overview after 9 months of this year and the main strategic topics, and then Carsten will guide you through the third quarter's financial performance. Let me begin with how we see the last 12 months. It's been a special journey we set out on. Built on an exceptionally good team spirit, we generated very strong momentum for Commerzbank. We crafted our momentum strategy with ambitious targets for 2028. A 50% cost-to-income ratio, 15% return on tangible equity, and 100% payout each year. Throughout this process, the extremely high commitment of everyone involved mattered as much as the bare numbers and targets. That has translated into a strong focus on delivery. The success is impressive. 13% loan growth in Corporate Clients, 8% growth in fee income, and an 11% increase in total revenues are proof of the strength of our team yellow.
That said, this is achievable only thanks to a strong, robust business model that serves our clients' needs. We bolstered our client franchise further, and I must say we take pride in the deep client relationships—deep relationships—that rest on the many awards we have earned. Our share price has also been propelled by the very good performance and positive outlook, nearly doubling over the last 12 months. Given our team spirit, our well-established client relationships, and with a bit of help from macro developments, I believe there is considerable additional potential to be unlocked. Our emphasis on shareholder value will gain further strength from the employee share program, launched in October, whose goal is to turn every employee into a shareholder of Commerzbank. Now let's take a closer look at this year's nine-month financial performance. Record operating result after 9 months came about through material growth in fee income and roughly EUR 500 million higher revenues at mBank, including fewer burdens from provisions of FX loans. Alongside high cost discipline, that growth shows up in the cost-to-income ratio of 56%, which is precisely where we wanted to be on the path toward raising efficiency going forward.
When it comes to return on tangible equity, we hit 10% over 9 months once restructuring charges are excluded. That double-digit return level now serves as our new baseline for growth starting in 2026, and it shows how much stronger Commerzbank has become. Our high revenue growth of 11% rests on substantially higher fee income. Just as important is how well we managed net interest income in a setting where rates are significantly lower than a year ago. NII fell by only 1%, and that gives us plenty of confidence for the quarters ahead. At the divisional level, the somewhat weaker net fair value result in Corporate Clients was largely offset by strong fee income and PSBC, and the group as a whole gained from the strong trajectory at mBank. The first 9 months have been very successful financially. That also holds for how we are implementing our strategy. Let me point to five areas where we have made significant progress. First, customer focus. Since last month, the new client coverage model in PSBC Germany is live. Key elements are personal one-on-one relationships for affluent clients and more time for high-quality advice in wealth management. Second, growth. Thanks to our deep client relationships in Corporate Clients, we are the leading go-to bank.
That has produced meaningful loan growth that is capital accretive — 13% over the last 12 months. Carsten will go into more detail on that. It's important to note this growth stems from strong relationships with our clients, not from any concessions on pricing. Third, AI. We've already reported on use cases like fraud detection and AI-assisted documentation for advisory calls with Corporate Clients. Among the newest applications is enhancing our KYC processes with AI. Fourth, costs. Implementation of the restructuring program is completely on track. The most recent milestones were wrapping up all negotiations with the workers' representatives and offering part-time early retirements to a selective group of people. An acceptance rate of almost 50% is very high. Fifth, capital. In Q3, we successfully completed our first SRT of the year. The EUR 3 billion notional and EUR 1.6 billion RWA relief came at low cost — in the area of 1% of RWA. That is very capital-efficient, and in placing the first loss, we also achieved some risk mitigation. We plan further SRTs in the weeks to come. All these achievements, together with the financial performance, contribute to the regulators' confidence in Commerzbank.
You can see this in the stronger SREP outcome we achieved, which brought a 10 basis points reduction in pillar two requirements. As we look toward the coming years, our standard planning refresh has validated the approach we're taking. We've pinpointed several areas of particular strategic significance and given them attention. First, we remain committed to our growth trajectory and are keeping a close watch on the German stimulus package. That package represents a substantial extra catalyst for our financial results. Second, AI stands among the biggest forces for transforming this bank and for securing rising efficiency levels. Everything we've witnessed up to now is merely the start, and we intend to keep investing heavily in AI. Take, for instance, the assistance we give our people in the advisory center. Live transcription of calls, suggested client solutions, and help with outbound calls will all help lift efficiency and client satisfaction. Third, we aim to optimize how we deploy capital above 13.5%. Beyond returning capital through dividends and share buybacks, that covers exploring additional organic growth opportunities plus inorganic routes like bolt-on acquisitions. In a screening that continues on an ongoing basis, every option has to satisfy our investment criteria when it comes to business fit and value accretion. Now, returning to macro and the German stimulus.
The German investment package for defense and infrastructure, along with legislative changes like taxation reliefs and depreciation rules, is going to provide significant support for our growth ambitions. Within our GDP forecast of 1.2% for 2026, we expect a considerable fiscal stimulus of 0.8% of GDP. The recently weaker German economic data don't contradict the expectation that a more expansionary fiscal policy will boost the economy. The budget for 2025 and the law on the extra budgetary fund only came into force at the beginning of October. So the positive impact will only be visible in future economic data. Furthermore, the federal government has shifted a considerable amount of investment spending from the core budget to the extra budgetary fund in the budget for 2026. This increases the federal government's financial leeway, and it can quickly increase other expenditures. This will help the economy in 2026 and 2027, even if the extra spending is partially directed at consumption instead of investments. The halving of the ECB deposit rates to 2.0% also points to higher economic growth. The positive view into 2026, however, still needs to translate into higher economic activity of corporates and especially the German Mittelstand. In this regard, the highest business expectations since 2022, according to the IFO survey, are positive.
While sentiment has picked up, the Mittelstand is still wary about putting money into Germany. Bureaucracy, energy prices, and a shortage of skilled workers continue to weigh on the business prospects of many corporates. Reforms driven by the government to address these issues matter if the huge potential of the stimulus package is to be unlocked. Now, let's turn to our own capital return program. We are very much on track and are planning a steady increase in capital return. Our currently active EUR 1 billion buyback program for 2025 is progressing well, and we have applied for a second tranche of up to EUR 600 million. As soon as we have a clear view on the full year results, we will decide how much we will propose as dividend for 2025 and what the exact size of the second share buyback will be. Both steadily increasing dividends and the flexible use of buybacks will remain integral parts of the capital return program. Returning 100% of net profit after 81 translates into attractive capital return yields of 8%, increasing to 11% over the next years. This is a key element of our strategy and our equity story. Let me now conclude with our outlook for 2025.
Given how well we’ve done through 9 months, we’re lifting our net interest income guidance to a range of EUR 8 billion to EUR 8.2 billion. On top of that, we now expect the risk result to come in under EUR 850 million. Our cost-to-income ratio target stays at 57%, and we’re holding to a net result goal of EUR 2.5 billion—or EUR 2.9 billion once restructuring charges are excluded. We see that as the floor for what we expect across the full year. Our expectation for the CET1 ratio remains at least 14.5% by the end of this year. As for 2026, our view is very positive as well. A strong NII trajectory plus the macro tailwind coming from German stimulus give significant backing to our momentum strategy. When we present full year results next February, we’ll lay out the complete picture of our 2026 outlook. At this point, I’ll pass things to Carsten to cover the financial performance of the third quarter. Carsten, over to you.
Thank you, Bettina, and good morning to all of you. I'm glad to walk you through the quarter's results. Let me begin with a quick summary. Thanks to robust top-line growth, the operating result has risen 18% versus Q3 of last year. The net result came in lower, though this stems solely from a one-off tax effect tied to DTAs, which was driven by the cut in the German corporate tax rate starting in 2028. As a result, net royalty stood at 7.8% for the quarter. Across the full financial year, we remain on course to hit our royalty target in spite of that tax effect, helped by the solid underlying performance of the business. At 14.7%, the CET1 ratio sits 18 basis points above the Q2 level and is entirely consistent with our goal of at least 14.5% by year-end. Now I'll take you through the details, beginning with revenues. During the quarter, revenues grew 7% versus the same period a year earlier. Net interest income continues to hold up strongly, matching the Q3 level of last year even with ECB rates considerably lower. In net commission income, momentum has been sustained, with growth in line with our roughly 7% year-on-year target. Although offsetting effects mostly cancel each other out, the net fair value result is slightly negative, reflecting a minus EUR 34 million valuation impact from our stake in eToro.
The remaining non-interest line, once you strip out FX loan provisions, is driven mostly by a favorable hedging outcome. Let me walk you through it in greater depth. Every customer segment expanded its business compared with a year earlier, and mBank got an extra lift from a one-time item in the cards business. In what is typically a quieter summer quarter, Corporate Clients still delivered solid revenues. Trade finance brought in higher revenues even though exports remain weak, and capital markets enjoyed a very robust syndication business. Lending produced the largest gain, as fee income tied to loan origination rose substantially, matching the growth in volumes. Green energy stood out in particular. Among private and small business customers in Germany, fees from the securities business keep climbing, driven by both securities volumes and transactions versus last year. On the payments side, the higher account fees launched at the end of Q2 are beginning to make a contribution. Our first round of customer outreach is complete, with a good acceptance rate, and it has also led customers to raise their volumes. Asset management gained from elevated transaction fees at Commerz Real as well as growth in wealth management products. Thanks to our ongoing initiatives, momentum has been sustained and we remain on track to hit our growth target for the year. Now let's turn to interest income.
Once more, rates created some headwinds for us. During Q3, ECB rates averaged 25 basis points, while Polish rates stood 50 basis points below their Q2 level. Even so, net interest income sits at almost the same level as in Q3 of last year. That is a clear sign of how resilient our business model is. At Corporate Clients, net interest income has risen relative to both Q2 and Q3 of last year. The key drivers were cheaper funding for trading positions plus stronger income from lending. Still, within the net fair value of trading book positions, those cheaper funding costs tied to lower ECB rates are partly offset. At PSBC Germany, net interest income is higher year-on-year and matches the Q2 level. Increased contributions from the replication portfolios and mortgages offset the impact of lower ECB rates along with our investment in promotional offers for new deposits. At mBank, the decline in NII stems chiefly from the reduction in policy rates. A higher net fair value from derivatives has offset that effect. Within others in consolidation, NII is lower as well, largely because of rate cuts. Once again, the net fair value result from derivatives provides a positive offset.
Turning to volumes, it was a really solid quarter for us. The loan business with Corporate Clients has kept expanding across every customer group. Loan volume is now 13% higher year-on-year. Deposit volumes have held steady. At PSBC Germany, sight deposit volumes remained stable, and call money rose by nearly EUR 8 billion thanks to the promotional offers in July. That strong inflow means the average deposit beta is expected to tick up to 42%. In mortgages, new contract volume climbed again, which points to demand recovering now that house prices have stabilized and interest rates have leveled off. The outstanding volume is a bit lower, reflecting seasonally higher early repayments. On the next slide, I'll walk you through more detail on loan growth in Corporate Clients. As I said, Corporate Clients are well ahead of the 8% annual growth target, and they got there on the strength of our diversified franchise. That franchise reaches customers around the world who have a connection to Germany. It also covers the foreign activities of German companies. As expected, given the sluggish German economy, growth with corporates in Germany has been only moderate. By contrast, demand from the public sector has picked up over the last quarters.
Green infrastructure has also been a growth area for us, in Germany and beyond. Our portfolio has expanded at a steady pace over recent years. We anticipate that will keep going even with shifts in the political landscape, because the projects we're engaged in remain economically appealing. Demand from outside Germany has also stayed robust. Roughly 80% of the growth was split evenly between Europe and the U.S., with Asia accounting for the remainder. The new business is diversified across sectors, and the biggest demand came from energy, chemicals, and consumption. Lastly, consistent with our momentum strategy, we deepened ties with institutionals — particularly financial institutions and emerging markets — in loan and trade finance products. We generated all of this business at appealing risk-adjusted margins, since we stay focused on RWA efficiency in our client relationships. As we look toward 2026, we expect German demand to strengthen, as additional spending by the German government ought to begin stimulating the economy. The substantial growth we've recorded in renewable energy and in financing for the electricity grid, along with guarantees for defense projects, are first harboring us. We're therefore confident we'll sustain our profitable growth trajectory.
That takes me to the following slide, which covers the NII outlook. Given how well we did on loan growth and deposit management over recent quarters, we are once more lifting our NII guidance for the year, up from EUR 8 billion to roughly EUR 8.2 billion. In our view, the low point for interest income was reached during the second half of this year. Looking at Q4, we don't foresee any major shifts in the key drivers, so net interest income ought to land at the same level as Q3. We expect contributions from the replication portfolio to keep rising, though this should be partly offset by a somewhat higher deposit beta and continued growth in volumes. mBank's contribution will be a bit weaker, reflecting the rate path we expect in Poland. 2025 demonstrates that our business model remains resilient, even through a rate cut cycle, with ECB rates averaging roughly 1.5% below their 2024 level. Although lower rates brought NII down in 2025, we simultaneously saw a positive impact of about EUR 300 million in net fair value. As for 2026, we assume ECB rates will stay where they are now. Consequently, we don't expect the contribution from positions sensitive to ECB interest rates to move much, whether in interest income or in the fair value result.
Given an anticipated EUR 2 billion in NII for the fourth quarter, our starting baseline for 2026 is therefore EUR 8 billion in NII. Beginning from that point, the primary forces shaping net interest income during 2026 will be growing contributions from the replication portfolios along with continued expansion, partly countered by headwinds stemming from beta and rate cuts in Poland. Taken together, these forces ought to add roughly EUR 400 million, producing expected net interest income of approximately EUR 8.4 billion. That gives us a solid foundation for hitting our profitability target for 2026 and the years that follow. Turning now to costs on slide 19. We have kept managing operating expenses in line with our 57% cost-to-income ratio target for 2025. Excluding mBank, personnel expenses have been the primary cost driver. Planned increases account for half of the rise, while the other half comes from valuation effects tied to a higher share price on equity-based compensation. In addition, during H1 we recorded impaired intangibles of EUR 65 million related to Aquila Capital, which shows up in the cost line. As planned, mBank has seen a larger cost increase driven by significant investments in business growth. On top of that, compulsory contributions came in higher. For Q4, we anticipate costs above those in Q3, since some seasonal effects will be present, mBank will keep growing, and personnel costs will rise as we keep ramping up shoring and sourcing centers to move additional tasks that are currently performed in Germany.
Once we had booked the momentum restructuring expenses in Germany during the first half of 2025, the bulk of the provisions for staff reductions at our international locations was booked in Q3. For Q4, we anticipate an additional booking of less than EUR 20 million. The risk result is what the next slide addresses. At EUR 215 million, the risk result came in. That is entirely consistent with what we expected. The portfolio remains resilient. Although we anticipate a somewhat higher risk result in the longer fourth quarter, given the good performance so far, we are very confident that we will finish below EUR 850 million. Since this has been a topic recently, we have added a slide on our NBFI portfolio in the appendix. This portfolio largely reflects our well-established institutional business in Corporate Clients, with which we are very comfortable. Our exposure to private credit is not noteworthy. We have no direct exposure to U.S. private credit markets. That concludes the view on the key line items. The main drivers of the excellent operating results have already been covered by me, and I will therefore focus on the tax rate. At 36%, the tax rate was well outside our normal range of 25%-30%.
The main reason for this is a modification in German tax legislation. Starting in 2028, the corporate tax rate is set to drop in 1% increments from 15%-10% by 2032. Although that's a positive development over the long term, it lowers the present value of future tax credits. As a result, we needed to account for this in the DTAs we carry, and it's a one-off event. Should the proposed tax hikes in Poland be enacted, we would see the reverse impact in Q4 through a write-up of Polish DTAs. On the whole, we anticipate the 2025 tax rate will land rather in the upper half of the 25%-30% range we expect. The following slides address the operating segment results, beginning with Corporate Clients. As noted earlier, Corporate Clients delivered a good quarter, lifting the operating result by 15% year-on-year. Revenues gained from strong loan growth and the solid capital markets business. That shows up most clearly in International Corporates, where revenues were 14% higher and loan growth was the strongest. In Mittelstand and Institutionals, performance was also good. Even so, the impact of lower rates on deposits could not be entirely offset. Lastly, the risk result stayed well contained, which supported the operating result.
PSBC Germany's operating result has improved as well, both compared with a year earlier and versus the prior quarter. As I said, the key revenue drivers were the securities business, the new account fees, plus some contribution from loans and deposits. Among private customers, the investment and promotional offers delivered the expected effect in Q3 and should begin to pay off in 2026. Asset management kept revenues at the Q2 level through the rather slower summer months. mBank has sustained profitability almost at the record level seen in Q2. As expected, provisions for FX loans came in lower than in the previous quarter, and we expect Q4 to be the last quarter with sizable provisions. In September, mBank published its new strategy running until 2030. mBank is targeting continued growth, with the ambition of reaching a 10% market share in Poland. With this growth and a target cost-income ratio below 35% before banking tax, mBank will contribute materially to the group's financials. For 2026, mBank aims to begin paying a dividend. That will ultimately benefit Commerzbank shareholders, as it supports our capacity to distribute capital. Others in consolidation posted an operating loss of EUR 53 million in the quarter, nearly at the same level as Q3 last year.
So far this year, the operating result sits at plus EUR 56 million, which matches what we expected — a full-year result that's more or less neutral. Revenues came in a bit above Q3 of last year, as lower NII was offset by the fair value result. Versus Q2, we've seen some extra valuation effects. The most notable one is our stake in eToro. During Q2, we recorded a gain of EUR 63 million after the IPO, but in Q3 we had to record a valuation loss of EUR 34 million, since the share price dropped over that quarter. There will be some impact in Q4 as well, and it hinges on how the share price performs. Moving to the next slide, I'll go through RWA and capital development. At quarter-end, the CET1 ratio was 14.7%, which is 18 basis points above Q2. Two main factors drove this. Risk-weighted assets came down, because RWA from loan growth was more than offset by an SRT issuance and model effects. We intend to issue additional SRTs in Q4, which optimizes the return from the loan book of Corporate Clients. Meanwhile, capital went up, since deductions from prudential valuation were smaller thanks to reduced market volatility after the spike earlier this spring.
Consistent with our 100% distribution target, the quarterly profit has been left out of the CET1 ratio calculation. Altogether, we've already allocated EUR 2.1 billion toward shareholder distributions during the first 9 months of the year. The MDA rose to 10.4% from 10.2% in Q2. That reflects a countercyclical buffer being introduced in Poland. We expect a comparable effect in Q3 next year, when the Polish countercyclical buffer goes up again. Last, the SREP letter has arrived from the ECB. Our 2026 capital requirements came down by 10 basis points. To us, that acknowledges our solid business model and the resilience we've built up in recent years. Since only a portion of regulatory capital requirements has to be held as CET1, the MDA will drop by roughly 6 basis points starting in January. Turning to the outlook for 2025. As noted earlier, we've raised our NII outlook to EUR 8.2 billion from EUR 8 billion, and the risk result outlook to below EUR 850 million from around EUR 850 million. Every other target is confirmed. We still anticipate net commission income growth of around 7% versus last year, a cost-income ratio of 57%, a net result of around EUR 2.5 billion, and a CET1 ratio of at least 14.5%.
Our outlook for 2026 is going to come together with the full-year results in February. Compared with the original plan we published in February, we see clear upside on NII, and we expect an improving macro environment to provide support. Thank you very much for your attention. Bettina and I are now looking forward to taking your questions.
Folks, if you'd like to pose a question at this time, kindly press nine and then the star key on your phone's keypad. Should you want to withdraw your question, just press three and then the star key. Go ahead and press nine and star now to signal that you have a question. At this moment, the first question is from Benjamin Goy at Deutsche Bank. Please proceed.
Yes, hello and good morning. I have two questions, please, regarding net interest incomes. First, thank you for slide 17, which contained the breakdown on Corporate Client growth, but perhaps you could elaborate a bit more on your growth expectations for corporates in Germany and on when this is going to inflect, whether that is early 2026 or a bit later. And then secondly, you also mention that your 2026 NII is likely impacted by higher deposit beta, which I think you consistently assumed conservatively. I am just wondering what increase you have expected and how much the comdirect campaign in July actually increased the deposit beta last quarter. Thank you.
Thanks, Benjamin. So, what's the outlook like for corporates in Germany? You're seeing it. Growth is already happening in Germany when it comes to public institutions. Partly green infrastructure as well. The majority we expect for 2026. One factor will clearly be the German government's stimulus package. Given the improving business sentiment that we see, there should also be more activity, specifically for Mittelstand clients in Germany. There's apparently also the MED for Germany initiative, which means significant investments in Germany in the coming years. On NII 2026, I'll hand over to Carsten.
Okay, thank you, Benjamin. I'll begin with the growth in deposit volume we witnessed during the third quarter, since you asked about that. During July, through the offers we had available via comdirect, we lifted our deposit volume by roughly EUR 8 billion. That produced a rise in the beta. On the personal customer side, we had anticipated this, which explains why you also observe the beta rising to 42% in Q3. We have now stated that we anticipate a modest uptick going into Q4, and that uptick does not originate in the personal customer business — it comes instead from the Corporate Client side. Because rates are generally lower at present, passing rate cuts through completely into the client business gets harder, and so you get a structural rise in the beta from that side. For the full year, we continue to expect an average beta near the 40% mark that we guided to at the start of the year, possibly a touch above it. Regarding 2026, since you asked about how things develop toward the EUR 8.4 billion NII for 2026, our expectation is that the present rate environment will in fact bring the same pressure on the Corporate Client beta.
Regarding personal customers, as we said, we anticipate that figure will decrease once more during Q4, and after that we'll manage it quarter by quarter through next year.
I appreciate that.
Our following question is from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. Please proceed.
Morning, and thanks for taking my questions. Just a couple, please. On cost savings, could you give us an update on how the various initiatives you launched with your CMD earlier this year are progressing, and how confident you are of delivering, particularly the trajectory on that? Second one on capital. If I understand correctly, by year-end we'll have a clearer view of the mix between cash and buyback. You say paying 100%. Is it possible that you pay more than 100% if you are above 14.5% CET1? Because we know there will be roughly EUR 1.6 billion of buyback, and then the cash components, given where you trade, could that be higher and lead you to more than 100% this year? I think what we need to look at now is the 14.5% CET1. Thank you.
Tarik, thanks for your questions. Regarding cost savings, we're making really solid progress. First, on the restructuring program itself and the headcount reductions, we've wrapped up all the negotiations we needed with the Workers' Council. All structural changes have already been announced, and we're now in the middle of implementing them. We also began with one instrument — it's a kind of part-time retirement program, and its advantage is that people remain on for the next 1 to 3 years, so you can genuinely manage the transition, and after that they move into their passive retirement phase. Acceptance was very high, beyond what we had expected, with 50% of the people we approached. All the other social instruments are available now as well. So we're tracking very much in line with the plan. On the measures we need around efficiency, streamlining, and AI, we're likewise showing precisely the progress we anticipated. AI use cases are being delivered day by day, you could really say. There's a great deal of speed there. The shoring activities are continuing too. We've already brought on a number of people in Sofia, in KL, for the various teams.
Everything is moving forward and on schedule. On the capital side, honestly, what I mean is that we're paying out above 100%, since we enjoy the advantage of being able to strip restructuring costs out of our payout ratio. If you look at the actual net result once restructuring cost is included, then this year our payout will exceed 100%. We'll stay at 100% of net income after81 but before restructuring cost, since that is precisely the basis we also agreed with the regulator for our share buyback requests. The final decision on the precise split between dividend and share buybacks will come when the results are in. What's clear is that we also want to present a highly attractive dividend. So far we've had EUR 0.30, EUR 0.65, and evidently we intend a further increase too, given that the share price has improved nicely during recent months. It will be highly attractive, and the mix will be highly attractive as well. As I mentioned, the EUR 1 billion share buyback program is running right now. We have just filed for the next one. On the remainder, we'll give an update in February.
I appreciate that.
Our following question is from Jeremy Sigee at BNP Paribas Exane. Your line is now open.
Great, thanks so much. Good morning. I have two questions, and both concern capital. First, is there anything particular in Q4 that would take the 14.7% down to 14.5%? Does that "greater than 14.5%" actually mean it could remain at 14.7%? Is there anything specific you expect in Q4? My second question relates to slide 6, where you discussed future strategy elements. Regarding topics of special strategic importance for the quarters ahead, you mentioned optimizing deployment of capital above the 13.5% target. Do you have any new ideas in mind, or any new areas of focus, or are you simply reflecting something that is already a core plank of your strategy?
Thank you, Jeremy. On the capital side, we're always aware that a 0.1% move either way can simply be a reflection of currency fluctuations, FX shifts, and that sort of thing. Broadly speaking, we anticipate additional growth arriving in Q4, and that is going to have an effect. More SRTs are also on the way, but that covers the full picture on that front. As for deploying capital going forward, we're constantly considering investments. The entire conversation surrounding AI — particularly agentic AI — is speeding up, so we are certainly also looking at putting more money into it in order to speed up certain things. After that, we explore — as we have mentioned previously — various M&A opportunities, to ensure we can reinforce our business model. The challenge is that any such opportunity must satisfy extremely tight criteria, since we have very explicit targets set for 2028. It has to be value accretive and must support both our growth ambitions and our profitability ambitions in the years ahead.
That's really useful. Thanks.
Our following question is from Kian Abouhossein at JPMorgan. Go ahead, please.
Appreciate the opportunity to ask. My first question concerns loan growth within Corporate Clients, and you provided some quite useful information on slide 17 about that. Could you discuss the asset spread margin situation across the various areas? What is it that you're doing in a different way from peers that is producing this very strong growth rate we are witnessing? My second question relates to PSBC deposits, where we've also observed very strong growth. Should we expect growth to be more flattish going forward? How ought we to think about deposit growth at PSBC? In that connection, you noted that the structural hedge, which was flat, could grow from EUR 147 billion. I'm wondering how we should think about deposit growth and, in conversion, the structural hedge. Is there any guidance you can provide us?
I'll begin with PSBC's deposit growth. I mean, growth in deposits has received a great deal of support from the attacker products, which we saw in July. We've now discontinued those. Overall, if you look at our plans — and that hasn't changed — we're planning for average deposit growth of roughly 2%. That comes largely from what our clients are doing, but we also definitely want to grow alongside our client base. For the rest, I'll hand things over to Carsten.
And perhaps I can also address the part of your question about where we stand with the structural hedge. Our replication portfolio position has not changed from Q2 to Q3. As the slides show, that portfolio currently holds EUR 147 billion. With the deposit structure having shifted as it has, or given the portfolio's size, we will naturally examine whether to grow it. That decision will be made in Q4, and we'll give you an update afterward. I'd also point out that altogether we hold more than EUR 200 billion in deposits that we can model, and we always keep some distance from what is actually in the model. There is scope to examine that, and we'll do so in Q4. On your first question, about loan growth in Corporate Clients and how margins are developing, I'd like to split that into two directions. First of all, you've seen that loan growth was healthy, particularly internationally. We're expanding the portfolio there, as mentioned, at good margins. The business is contributing, so we are in fact seeing a healthy increase. Quite frankly, Kian, from where we sit, it's mainly coming from the deep relationships we have with our customers and the international presence we offer through our outlets internationally.
So that essentially lets us support them whenever financing needs arise. Taking a closer look at the domestic side and the growth, particularly regarding the public sector and the municipalities: we read this as the first pickup from the infrastructure packages the government has also announced. This is a fantastic business when it comes to the risk position of the book. Naturally, it also comes with slightly lower margins. I'd also note that in this space, municipalities aren't necessarily just the municipalities — there are also municipality corporates, such as suppliers and so on. From a margin standpoint, those typically move a bit more into the middle-stand territory. As a result, growth in the book comes at good margins and is rather accretive to the RWA efficiency of the book.
Much appreciated.
Borja Ramirez from Citi has the next question. Please go ahead.
Hello, and good morning. Thanks so much for taking my questions. I have two, both about NII. First, on 2026: could you share the deposit beta you're assuming? I ask because there seems to be some commentary about corporate deposit beta going up, perhaps due to lower margins. And on the retail deposit beta, I think that may be improving as your attacker products get repriced at lower rates. That's my first question. My second one would be whether you could kindly give a bit more color on the moving parts within 2026 NII—for instance, I believe you have EUR 300 million of benefit from the replication portfolio in 2026. For NII, I have slightly higher, EUR 400 million, because of the steeper yield curve and also because you increased the portfolio. If you could kindly add more details, please. Thank you.
Borja, many thanks for those questions. I'll begin with the first one, which concerns the deposit beta. Once more, I'd like to kick off with 2025. As you've observed, we started from a fairly low level, and it rose steadily across the year, in line with what we had anticipated. Q3 now arrives somewhat higher, largely owing to the attacker products we rolled out during July. As we said, we actually anticipate the private customer beta will decline once more in Q4. The primary factor behind the modestly elevated beta we foresee at year-end stems from the corporate client business. Taken together, the beta, as noted earlier, will actually stay at a level of 40%, perhaps 40.5% for the year, just as we expected. Moving into 2026, from an expectations standpoint the beta will probably be shaped by the corporate client side, where we essentially see a beta landscape that is unchanged relative to Q4. You touched briefly on the effect our attacker products had on the personal customer side. I'd like to emphasize that the deposits we actually brought in at the start of July are term deposits. Although that always produces a short-term effect on the beta, the longer-term advantage of actually holding these deposits in the bank will actually contribute in 2026.
On the second question, about that EUR 400 million rise in NII for 2026: for 2026 we expect the ECB rate environment to be pretty much unchanged — at least, we see it as flattish. The real driver will be the replication portfolio. Given the investments and the position we hold there, we do see the stabilization effect. As you've also seen over the last quarters, we've kept raising the average return from that portfolio, and that will be the main driver. Of course, we'll see growth effects, plus a slight negative from mBank given the Polish rate environment — as expected, a slightly higher beta next year. Those are the main drivers behind the EUR 400 million, so we'll see a positive development from EUR 8 billion–EUR 8.2 billion, sorry, to EUR 8.4 billion next year.
All right. I believe Tobias Lukesch from Kepler Cheuvreux has the next question. Your line is open.
Yes, good morning, and thank you. I’d also like to briefly revisit NII and the 2026 outlook. You gave guidance of EUR 8.4 billion. I was just wondering what the expectation is for net fair value. Under your previous strategy at the CMD, you had EUR 0.5 billion, but you also had EUR 0.4 billion for 2025, which is now still confirmed at EUR 0.3 billion. I was just wondering whether this still holds up and what your overall view is on this combined revenue contribution. Second, basically on the cost side, if I understand your guidance correctly now for 2025, we have this EUR 200 million more in NII at the same time as a EUR 70 million tax effect leaves us with EUR 140 million, which is more or less eaten up by higher costs. On the share price, I mean, one could hope for it, but it is rather unrealistic to see the same compensation potentially for next year. I was just wondering what you see in terms of this kind of cost development, how it will come back, and how you will steer that basically into the future. Thank you.
Thank you very much for that, Tobias. To begin with your question on NII for 2026, and specifically what you asked about net fair value: for 2025, this year, we have a net fair value contribution tied — as we always describe it — to NII to the tune of EUR 300 million. That represents a change versus last year. The reason we called this out explicitly when entering the year and providing NII guidance was that, in an environment of declining rates, we wanted to make clear that it isn't only NII but also, in part, a contribution from derivatives that supports us on the NII side. Now, as we move into 2026, we are guiding NII at EUR 8.4 billion, but we assume a flat rate environment and therefore also no meaningful movements in the net fair value result arising from the NII position. So EUR 8.4 billion, and flat at present — meaning no additional contribution from net fair value for 2026. On your second question, about the cost side, I think you covered that quite well. There are certain effects you listed, which we also referred to in the speeches concerning our 2025 development.
If we turn to the operational side — the cost level and the development we're observing in the bank — what we see is a very disciplined approach to managing costs at the moment. As we look ahead to 2026, we're basically very confident that we're operating at the level we guided at the capital markets day. As you know, we steer toward the cost-income ratio. The target we set for next year is 56%. At this point, we are clearly holding to that 56%.
Thanks. If I could revisit this net fair value point, I have to admit I'm somewhat confused, because at the CMD you set a 2026 target of EUR 8 billion NAI plus EUR 0.5 billion net fair value, which adds up to EUR 8.5 billion. From what I'm hearing, your guidance now is for a combined figure of just EUR 8.4 billion for next year. And then on 2025 as well, I can't reconcile this net fair value result of EUR 0.3 billion that's unchanged. As I recall, we sit at minus EUR 60 million, unless I'm mistaken. That would imply roughly EUR 350 million coming through in Q4. How should that be interpreted and made to fit? Thank you.
Yes. I believe that is a very reasonable question. First, Tobias, regarding 2026, to be completely clear, we expect EUR 8.4 billion in NII and our net fair value expectation remains unchanged at EUR 0.5 billion. That holds. I was only referring to the net fair value we expect on the NII side. For 2026, there is no change to the net fair value guidance, to be completely clear here. Turning back to 2025, the net fair value is essentially composed of several positions. One position is the net fair value that we have from interest rate-related positions. That is the EUR 300 million we mentioned. These are included as one portion of the net fair value, and they hold. We see them in the books at the moment, and given the current rate environment, we do not expect them to change toward the end. Also included in net fair value are the positions from our capital markets business. That is contributing to it. The third position contributing to net fair value is general valuation effects. Those have to be viewed in combination with the other income. If you combine those positions, so the net fair value that we have as a run rate at the moment, the other income, and if you exclude from that the FX mortgage provisions, which we hold for mBank, then you actually end up with a value around the EUR 250 million mark for 2025.
So because of that, we’re sticking with that guidance.
I appreciate it.
Riccardo Rovere from Mediobanca has the next question. Go ahead. Thanks.
Thanks a lot for taking my questions. Back to NII, if I may. Looking at the loan book, it stood at EUR 263 billion at the close of the 9 months. That's the average, and it's 2.5% above the average recorded since the beginning of the year. During 2025 to 2026, you'll get support from the fiscal boost in Germany, 1.2% of GDP. That's real. Then you add 2 percentage points from inflation. The loan book will keep expanding. Whether 3.5%, or something along those lines, is reasonable, I can't say. You have Poland, expected to grow by more than that, whereas your NII is meant to increase 2%. So implicitly you're building in a fairly decent margin compression, I would guess. Rates should stay stable, at least in Europe. Europe accounts for 70%-75% of your business, and Poland makes up the remaining 25%-30%. Since in 2025 your NII guidance moved from EUR 7.8 billion, to EUR 8 billion, then to EUR 8.2 billion, I'm simply wondering whether the approach you took in the 9 months 2025, when you set EUR 8.4 billion, involves some caution, some prudence, as you've consistently shown throughout 2025.
That's my first question. My second one concerns the coal money, the coal deposits at PSBC. As I understand it, the promotional offer came in July, if I've got that right. So the effect on NII ought to be more or less entirely visible in these particular numbers. Beyond that, why are you still running this promotional offer — what are you gathering, what are you doing with it? My other question is about medium to long-term funding. Since the beginning of the year, that amount has risen dramatically. Unless I'm mistaken, it's roughly EUR 20 billion or so, EUR 18.5 billion in debt securities. It moved from EUR 45 billion, something in that region, to EUR 53 billion and then past EUR 70 billion. Why has it increased so much? What spread do you get? Because my impression is that you then put it into debt securities on the asset side. I was curious to learn what kind of debt securities that sum of money goes into. That's just to get an idea. Thank you.
Yes. Riccardo, thanks for those questions. On the first one specifically, as you're aware, that's the term we prefer — floor. Right, we're consistently cautious, and you know that about us. Looking ahead to next year, which factors are driving things? To start with, we're planning on an additional 8% growth in loans for Corporate Clients — that's certain. And everything we're currently seeing around the stimulus package will support that too. I believe we've demonstrated quite well that we can organize this, given the 13% we've delivered year to date. That said, there are two things to bear in mind. The first is clearly Poland, which will also show decent growth on the lending side, though we anticipate interest rate levels there coming down further, and that will have a negative effect. Regarding what Carsten mentioned earlier about the deposit beta, you should essentially treat the fourth quarter as something that will also shape the full year 2026. That implies a somewhat higher deposit beta at each end than what we've observed this year. At least, that's our assumption. It's also the assumption we built into our plans back at the capital markets day.
If you check those documents, we consistently mentioned 41% for this year. At this point, 40% is the most likely figure, and that would rise to 44% through 2028. It's simply a reflection. It's below what we expected, but there's still a bit of improvement in the deposit side. On the. Yes, you could say the EUR 8.4 billion is plainly a floor number once again, nothing more. Regarding call money, we had that in July. We actually halted the program after 3 weeks since inflows were so large. The bulk of that money runs through January and February. Right now, we only have our standard offers in the market, nothing special. On funding, I'll pass it to Carsten.
When it comes to funding, Ricardo, our plan had been built around debt instruments — roughly EUR 10 billion, a bit more, for the full year. Right now we're at about EUR 11 billion of funding. As for how that's spread across instruments, we actually saw a wide variety in the market this year, with something like 81 to 82 issuances and so on. In essence, we had the whole spread available and took advantage of market conditions to carry out our usual refunding work. The funding plan is really quite consistent with what we laid out. We did extend it somewhat in Q4, effectively to capitalize on the market as it stands. Looking back a little at the first half of the year, we're aware that markets aren't always available at the moment you'd like them to be. We essentially focused on steadying the funding position, but it's largely consistent with the plan — perhaps slightly above it. And with today's market conditions and the spreads we're seeing, which are attractive for the reissuances, you should expect that we enhanced our overall funding cost position in the book over the course of this year.
Since we're keeping the margins on the asset side steady, this is going to feed into our business plan.
Thank you. Appreciate it. That was quite clear. Perhaps just one brief follow-up. Regarding the loan growth at PSBC Germany, the book is holding pretty steady at EUR 125 billion. Do you think the ECB's easing will make itself felt at some point in 2026?
Are you referring to the private client side?
That's right. Exactly so, on the German retail side.
I mean, what we're seeing right now is already a lot more activity again. Mortgage activity has gone up. Essentially, it's back to where we were before COVID. There's simply a timing lag in there, because people begin a mortgage, but then it takes some time until they actually draw the money, since most of the time it's just paid out in construction. Yes, we expect loan growth next year on the PSBC side as well.
Yeah. Thanks. Thanks a lot. Appreciate it.
Our following question is from Anke Reingen at RBC. Please proceed.
Yes. Good morning, and thanks for taking my questions. There are two areas, please. The first is just following up on the really strong corporate loan goals in Q3. Some of that appears to be somewhat more short-term in nature, as in working capital and trade finance. Since Q4 is normally seasonally a bit weaker, I just wanted confirmation that you don't expect any real reversal in Q4 from these levels. Then secondly, you spoke at the beginning about your wealth management initiatives. I'm sorry, I can't really fully recall, but what you mentioned, is this incremental to your plan? Maybe can you just sort of give us an indication of how much it currently contributes to your revenues and what you sort of like size as an opportunity? Thank you.
To start, no reversal in loan growth is anticipated for the fourth quarter. Next, regarding wealth management — I mean, that's a central piece of our momentum strategy. It's completely built into the plans. I mean, among the factors that ought to drive our net commission income, the 8% or 7% — the 8% we've recorded year to date, but also the 7% we anticipate over the years ahead. What we've now done is essentially deepen client coverage. So more relationship managers are covering these client groups. We have wealth management centers. We also have new locations. A number of new locations were opened by us in Germany this year. And those are going to be a meaningful driver behind net commission income growth. We don't really state what that is in percentage terms.
Alright, thanks.
Mate Nemes from UBS has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Yes. Good morning, and thanks for taking my questions. I have two, please. The first is a follow-up regarding deposits—more precisely, those strong call money inflows. Could you discuss the retention rates you have seen on such attacker products after the high-interest period comes to an end over the past 1 to 2 years? I would love to hear what your experience has been on that front, and how sticky those new funds are. My second question concerns the risk result, or risk costs, and in particular your guidance. During the first 9 months, you recorded EUR 515 million in risk results. Clearly, you revised your guidance down for the full year to below EUR 850 million. I am just wondering what keeps you from being more specific about the full-year risk results. There seems to be an awful lot of room between the current result and the upper end of the guidance. Would you expect anything sort of inorganic in the fourth quarter, any model changes? Why not, let's say, a somewhat more precise lower guidance? Thank you.
Yes, regarding the call money and the influence, and now you're asking about our expectations. I mean, we can only talk about what has happened so far. The programs, since the attacker products we set out in July are running, as I mentioned, through January and February. Only in the new year will we see how sticky it is. You really need to distinguish between the two client groups, Commerzbank clients and Comdirect clients. For Commerzbank clients, whatever we get there is actually stickier than on the Comdirect side. On the Comdirect side, we also have more of these — I call them interest rate hoppers. Even so, the stickiness has pleasantly surprised us, how many clients still keep their money with us as well. That is also because most of the time we pair that with real client onboarding. We have a very attractive brokerage offering on the Comdirect side, and that is clearly something we also combine with new clients. Overall, so far, we have been rather pleasantly surprised by how much core money remains with us after the attacker products. The risk result — I mean, completely clear. We see it is the same. However, it's a long quarter, and that is why, as always, we remain a little bit cautious.
Nothing specific is on our radar. We aren't anticipating anything particular, though this quarter is a long one that extends through February. We're simply leaving room. No particular model changes are scheduled or anything of that kind. I mean, model updates happen constantly, but there's nothing particular in this case. That's the reason we're also quite confident. I mean, we would not have revised it to under EUR 850 million unless we believed it would land below the EUR 850 million we initially set out. How much altogether. We genuinely will find out in February, once the quarter wraps up.
Understood. Thanks.
That seems to bring us to the close of today's call. Many thanks for all your questions. We look forward to continuing our conversations with you, and we wish you a wonderful, sunny day ahead. Thank you. The recording is now stopped.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Commerzbank AG transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.
Get an API key View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Commerzbank AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server.
Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search,
and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.