Home / Transcripts / Commerzbank AG (CBK) · November 5, 2026

Commerzbank AG (CBK) Earnings Call Transcript

November 5, 2026

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Financials Banks earnings 65 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator operator
#1

Good day, and thank you for joining the Commerzbank AG conference call on our Q3 2026 results. I'd like to point out that this call is both being broadcast and captured via audio webcast, and a replay will be posted on the Internet afterward. <<operator_script>> Once Bettina Orlopp and Carsten Schmitt have finished their presentation, we'll open the floor for your questions. At this point, I'll hand things over to our CEO, Betina Orlopp.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#2

Good morning, everyone, and welcome as we present the results for the third quarter. Carsten and I will take you through a set of very strong figures, including a record profit for 9 months. Those numbers confirm that we are delivering on the momentum promises we made and that we remain on our path of predictable, profitable growth. What we achieved stems directly from the trust our clients place in us and from the outstanding dedication of our people. In a period of strategic change and a complex market environment, we do not take that for granted. These partnerships mean a great deal to us, and they form the bedrock of our success. Before we dive in, let me briefly comment on the economic landscape. While uncertainty persists, our own economic research experts take a cautiously optimistic view. For the full year 2026, they expect the German economy to grow by 1.2%. This is reflected in a significant rise in sentiment indicators, with the Ifo Business Climate Index rising for the sixth time in a row. This sentiment of resilience was also central to the government's recent invest in Germany Summit, which aims at promoting Germany as a destination for investment, a goal we actively support as Commerzbank. So the macroeconomic environment in Germany provides potential tailwinds for banks and Commerzbank in specific.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#3

This backs the targets we haven't changed for revenues, profitability and efficiency across 2026 through 2030. For 2026, though, we have adjusted the revenue composition. A somewhat lower growth in net interest income will be offset by a higher projection of revenues from net fair value and others. Beyond that, we're very much aware that the ongoing situation with UniCredit creates questions for our clients. We're addressing their concerns proactively through clear communication. So we welcome UniCredit's press release last Friday, which highlighted their commitment to support the German Mittelstand and the 2 banks' international presence. Let's turn to our performance, which clearly shows the financial momentum we have built. We're well on track to deliver a record result for the full year 2026. In the first 9 months, revenues grew by a strong 8% year-on-year to EUR 9.7 billion. We showed strong operating performance as our operating result increased by 17% to a new high of EUR 4 billion. Ultimately, this operational strength translates into a record net result of EUR 2.7 billion for the 9 months period. Our firm cost discipline remains a key pillar of this success, with our cost/income ratio improving significantly to 50% when excluding compulsory contributions.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#4

We posted a net return on tangible equity of 12.4%, which is an excellent figure and clear evidence that our business model is capital-efficient and profitable. All of this has been accomplished while we kept a strong CET1 ratio of 14.2%. Our strategy is built to generate sustainable value for all stakeholders, and the progress is evident everywhere. For customers, we are providing tangible improvements and innovations. Corporate client satisfaction has risen to a record 80 points on our client satisfaction index. That shows how deeply we are committed to service and partnership, and it confirms we are the leading bank for the German Mittelstand. In retail, we are actively getting ready for the upcoming state subsidized pension reform. Our 2 brands will each offer tailored solutions. Commerzbank will provide an advice model built on actively managed funds from Allianz Global Investors, and comdirect will offer flexible digital ETF solutions for self-directed investors. We regard this as an important entry point into securities investment for many clients, lowering the barrier for them to build up the portfolio with further products in the ETF and fund space. And throughout the bank, we are using artificial intelligence to improve the client experience and to boost our efficiency.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#5

In customer service, every one of our teams is now backed by AI-powered assistants, and we're pursuing automation for things such as complaint management, where we estimate an automation potential of roughly 60%. When it comes to our employees, we're handling our transformation in a socially responsible manner. More than 1,100 colleagues have opted in so far to our new early retirement program, which has been very well received. That comes on top of 1,800 contracts already signed, which are predominantly -- which are especially early retirement programs as well. Meanwhile, our appeal as an employer has never been stronger. This year brought a record high of around 12,000 applications for our trainee and student programs, a very good sign of trust from the next generation of bankers. And most importantly, it is the strong commitment and performance motivation of our team that makes the record results we are presenting today possible in the first place. That is also documented in a very high satisfaction score from our latest employee engagement survey, which just finished this week, and that despite all the noise we had in the past quarters. Finally, for our shareholders, we are delivering the best financial performance in our history.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#6

Strong growth in our core business is what drives this — corporate loan growth came in at 14% and fees were up 8% year-on-year. On the back of that performance, we're confirming the guidance we've given for net profit and the cost/income ratio across 2026 through 2030. That strong showing feeds straight into our capital return policy, and that policy stays a central pillar of the equity story we tell. Our current share buyback is well underway, and altogether that means EUR 7 billion has already gone back to our shareholders since 2022. And we remain committed to distributing earnings in full to our shareholders. We expect another EUR 2 billion for distribution this year, which reflects our 100% capital return until we have reached our target CET1 ratio of 13.5%. In short, we stick to our targets and deliver. This management and communication style has shaped our journey over the past years. We began Strategy 2024 with ambitious goals for restructuring, cost reduction and rightsizing, and we delivered. We returned to a positive net result in 2021, executed our first-ever buyback in 2022 and rejoined the DACH's index in 2023. We delivered on our strategy 1 year ahead of schedule and kickstarted our momentum strategy in early 2025 to grow and transform our business and deliver double-digit returns.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#7

Earlier this year, in May, we unveiled a faster pace of momentum and set out our perspective looking out to 2030. That strategy draws on strengths we have already demonstrated, allowing us to generate growth that is quicker and more profitable. Artificial intelligence serves as a crucial driver here, speeding up how our business transforms and assisting us in hitting the ambitious goals we have set: a net RoTE of 21% and a cost/income ratio of 41% by 2030. Alongside the potential for returning capital, which mirrors distributing all of our earnings, this forms the road map we will follow going forward. Naturally, UniCredit is a major part of the path we are taking. Once the regulatory authorities give their approval, a new chapter begins for us. This slide lays out the journey that lies ahead, divided into clear phases. At present we are moving from Phase 0 — the status quo, in which we function entirely on our own — into Phase 1, in which Commerzbank becomes a consolidated part of the UniCredit Group yet remains listed, with 51% minority shareholders. This is a structured process, and the preparations required for an upstream consolidation are already under way. Looking further out, Phase 2 sets out the potential for deeper integration within the market, which might unlock the full synergy potential. Let's concentrate on the immediate step in front of us, Phase 1.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#8

We're confident this initial integration phase presents meaningful, concrete value upside. Constructive talks are now underway with UniCredit, and we're eager to work together to lay out and verify the value-creation assumptions in detail. Where costs are concerned, we identify synergy opportunities in areas such as combined purchasing, harmonizing our technology stacks, and exchanging expertise — in cybersecurity or AI development, for example. On the revenue front, a strategic CEE partnership plus tighter collaboration around product platforms and shared financing for bigger transactions can strengthen what we offer clients. Our stated aim is to capture that value for our stakeholders while limiting revenue dis-synergies as far as possible throughout the process. As we begin this new chapter, we do so from a position of strength. Commerzbank contributes substantial strategic and financial value. We will stay committed to meeting UniCredit's needs as controlling shareholder and the needs of every minority shareholder. That is our obligation as Commerzbank's Managing Board. A strong client franchise is our bedrock — both as a leading bank for the German Mittelstand and a top provider for private and small business through our 2 powerful brands, Commerzbank and comdirect. We are firmly rooted in the German economy, holding an approximate 30% market share in foreign trade finance, drawing on the huge deposit base in Germany, and supporting our country's development and its large investment programs.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#9

We turn in strong financial results, with a steady history of top-line expansion, expense control, an appealing capital return framework, and profitability that keeps getting better. That foundation is what we'll build on as part of UniCredit Group, acting in the best interest of all our stakeholders. That brings me to the main points I want to leave with you today. First, we posted our strongest 9 months ever, and we reaffirm our key targets from 2026 through 2030. This bank keeps its promises. Second, our attention stays squarely on our client business, which drives sustainable success. And third, we are entirely committed to maximizing value for all our stakeholders, and we feel confident about the extra potential that can be unlocked within UniCredit Group. Our shareholders stand to gain from our proven delivery and the further strategic opportunities that lie ahead. With that, I'll pass things to Carsten for the financial deep dive on the third quarter.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#10

Thank you, Bettina, and I'd also like to extend a warm welcome. Since Bettina has already laid out how well we did over the strong 9 months, I'll now walk you through the third quarter's financials. It was a very good quarter indeed. We delivered across all key metrics, which shows our resilience even as Q3 brought tougher deposit competition in Germany. Revenues kept rising year-on-year, while we held costs ex mBank stable, and that gave us positive operating leverage. The risk result came in fully in line with expectations. With EUR 1.3 billion in operating profit, we landed significantly above Q3 last year and even got close to the record Q2 results — remarkable, since Q3 is normally the slower summer quarter. The CET1 ratio stands at 14.2%. That's well above our target, though 20 basis points below Q2, mainly because of market moves in FX, rates and credit spreads that affected OCI. Now let's go through the figures in detail. Q3 revenues are up 9% versus Q3 last year. That's an extremely strong development, and the market's high expectations reflect it. But we have to note the intensified deposit competition.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#11

So because we’re actively managing both deposit volumes and margins, we’ve revised our NII guidance down by roughly EUR 100 million, to EUR 8.5 billion for the full year. The key point is that we are entirely keeping our total revenue outlook of EUR 13.2 billion, since we anticipate greater contributions from net fair value and other income. Part of this reflects a shift between NII and net fair value. On the individual line items, net interest income rose 3.5% year-on-year, supported by the private and small business customer segment in Germany, where NII was 12% higher. NII from mBank and Others & Consolidation came in somewhat lower, mirroring interest rate movements. Higher net fair value largely offset that. Net commission income is once more very strong at EUR 1.1 billion, 9% above last year’s third quarter and comfortably ahead of our targeted annual growth rate of 7%. That confirms the quality of our revenue growth, especially driven by the securities business in Germany. The net fair value result is stronger than last year and more than offsets the effects in NII. Other income is negative in the quarter. Contributions from dividend income, hedge accounting and realizations were offset by one-offs in O&C and provisions related to customer protection at mBank.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#12

By contrast, the second quarter had gotten a lift from one-off items. Across the whole year, we lifted our guidance to roughly EUR 400 million for net fair value plus other income taken together. Our fee income is the subject of the following 2 slides, and I'll go directly to Slide 15. The biggest force behind the strong NCI increase we posted has been PSBC Germany, which delivered impressive growth of 14%, fueled by the securities business and by higher fees in the payments business. Asset Management likewise did well, with the primary catalyst being the portfolios we run on a discretionary basis for our customers. Over in Corporate Clients, the growth has come largely from trade finance-related guarantees and from payment transactions. Let's now turn to interest income on Slide 16 and 17. Net interest income has risen 3% compared with Q2. The forces behind this are growing contributions from the loan and deposit business across all our customer segments. At Corporate Clients and at mBank, volume growth has been the key factor, whereas at PSBC Germany, the replication portfolio has been the key factor. Although solid, the total increase lands a bit under what we had originally expected. At Corporate Clients, NII rose only modestly, reflecting higher funding costs in the Capital Markets business.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#13

That said, a robust net fair value contribution from the positions we funded more than made up for these. At PSBC Germany, deposit competition heating up in the third quarter has been the central issue. A number of competitors have been paying extraordinarily high rates on fresh money. Our choice was to refrain from matching those teaser rates, and as a result roughly EUR 3 billion of highly rate-sensitive call money flowed out, while the deposit beta held steady and actually fell to about 40%. During Q4, we began rolling out more appealing offers on new call deposits, though we are keeping them under the rates the most aggressive competitors offer so that margins stay reasonable. In the fourth quarter, we consequently anticipate volumes will rise once more. The market shifts constantly, and over the medium term we will keep adjusting what our offerings can do. We are still applying AI to fine-tune offers and to determine the optimal price for each customer group. Before turning to our NII outlook for the rest of the year, let me address the lending business of Corporate Clients. Over the past 12 months, Corporate Clients delivered loan growth of EUR 15 billion, equivalent to 14%. Once more, this demonstrates the value of our setup, which serves clients around the world and not just in Germany.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#14

What we're seeing continues the trend from the last few quarters. Client loan growth is still mostly international, and it's nicely diversified both by geography and by customer group. In Germany there's activity, with selective investments, and that's not just in defense and infrastructure. Once repayments are factored in, this works out to steady net growth of roughly 2% to 3%. Outside Germany, growth is still strong, especially with corporates connected to our DACH franchise. As an industry-wide trend, loan margins have come under some pressure, and that has nudged the portfolio's average margin down by a few basis points. Turning now to our NII outlook for 2026. Because of the headwinds from deposit competition and loan margins, we've revised our NII outlook from around EUR 8.6 billion to around EUR 8.5 billion. That implies we expect net interest income to rise by around EUR 300 million, or approximately 3.5%, for the year. So we're on track for record NII in 2026, and the longer-term outlook is still positive. The key driver here is the replication portfolio, which I'll go through on the next slide. On Slide 20, you'll find an updated simulation of what the replication portfolio is expected to contribute over the coming years.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#15

To run that calculation, we hold the portfolio's structure and volume fixed and use the prevailing forward rates. We don't anticipate the portfolio staying unchanged across such an extended stretch, since we continuously seek to optimize it, yet this simulation provides a solid baseline. Measured against the Q2 simulation at current forward rates, the portfolio will generate an extra EUR 200 million to EUR 400 million of interest income each year over the coming years. We anticipate that this added revenue from the replication portfolio will more than offset any potential headwinds arising from tougher deposit competition and loan margins. Turning now to costs on Slide 21. Group costs for the year to date sit at nearly the same level as a year ago. As planned, costs are climbing, including investments at mBank, whereas costs across the remainder of the group are held flat. We delivered this even while putting more into IT and AI and absorbing salary increases through active cost management. We additionally gained from lower valuation effects on equity-based compensation and from making no contribution to the German deposit guarantee scheme. All told, we stay fully committed to our cost/income ratio target. The risk result was EUR 210 million. That is entirely consistent with our expectations and outlook.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#16

Nothing materially new came up during the quarter. Our portfolio stays very resilient, with a nonperforming exposure ratio of just 1.2%. Given economic and geopolitical uncertainty, and reflecting how disciplined we are about risk, we are prudently keeping our full year guidance for a risk result of around EUR 850 million. That wraps up the view on the key line items. Slide 23 lays out the drivers behind the EUR 859 million net profit. The tax rate came in at 28% for the quarter. For the full year, we still expect the tax rate to be close to 30%, mainly because of the higher corporate tax rate in Poland. Since I've already covered the main developments, I'll comment only briefly on how the segments performed. Corporate Clients raised its Q3 operating results year-on-year, helped by 5% higher revenues. Mittelstand posted 4% revenue growth, mainly from the deposit business and transaction banking. International Corporates was broadly flat, as better lending and transaction banking revenues could not fully offset lower contributions from capital markets. Institutionals had a very strong quarter, with revenues up 18% and increases from all product areas, in particular from secured financing and the FX business. PSBC Germany delivered its best ever quarter. This year, every quarter has been significantly above the corresponding quarter of the previous year, as fee income is growing strongly and NII is benefiting from the replication portfolio.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#17

You can see this clearly among private customers, since that’s where the bulk of the benefits from the replication portfolio lands. Alongside a solid fee business, that helped revenues rise 17% year-on-year. Revenues from small business customers are 5% higher, whereas revenues at the asset management subsidiaries came in a bit lower. A large share of the business rests on real assets. Throughout the industry, these are being hurt by higher interest rates, and that will put pressure on revenues in the coming quarters as well. Turning to mbank, mBank once again turned in a very strong quarter. Loan and deposit growth continues at a rapid clip, and fee income keeps climbing. Although mBank booked provisions tied to customer protection, which modestly affected revenue growth this quarter, the burden from FX loans is no longer material. Given mBank’s well-established business model, ongoing innovation, and the Polish economy being one of the strongest in Europe, we expect this favorable trend to carry on. Others & Consolidation has made a neutral contribution thus far this year. That matches what we expect for the year, with some quarter-to-quarter swings arising from valuation effects and one-off items within other income. I’ll now turn to capital on Slide 28. Several changes occurred during the quarter that brought the CET1 ratio down from 14.4% in Q2 to 14.2% in Q3, which works out to 370 basis points above the MDA.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#18

The main reason for the decline in RWA — which will matter again in coming quarters — is that we’ve started applying the foundation and internal ratings-based approach to certain portfolios. After getting ECB approval, we freed up some RWA that had been prebooked in Q3, roughly equal to 1/4 of the anticipated mid- to high single-digit euro decrease. The rest will come through gradually by the end of Q2 2027. On top of that, new SRT issued by mBank lowered RWA in Q3. As for the CET1 ratio, that was more than offset by a drop in CET1 capital. The cause was market movements in FX, interest rates and credit spreads, all of which affect OCI. These valuation effects should mostly reverse over time. Higher regulatory deductions also had an impact, e.g. for intangibles. Consistent with our capital return policy and our commitment to a 100% payout ratio, we have set aside the entire net result after AT1 coupon payments — EUR 2.5 billion year-to-date — for distribution. That equals almost 140 basis points of the CET1 ratio. Turning to our capital requirements: the MDA rose by 19 basis points this quarter because of a higher countercyclical buffer in Poland. Next year a reduction in capital requirements will offset this, though only marginally, since SREP requirements were cut by 5 basis points, producing an effect of about 3 basis points on the MDA.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#19

Ahead of the outlook, let me give a quick status report and summary of where things stand in our work to consolidate Commerzbank into UniCredit Group. We anticipate that every remaining regulatory approval will come through either during Q4 of this year or in Q1 2027. At that point, UniCredit will have to fully consolidate Commerzbank in its P&L and balance sheet. Minority interest, though, gets deducted from the after-tax result. Working groups have been set up to get us ready for this. That work continues, and together we are making consistent headway on the many complicated matters that have to be dealt with. Our preliminary analysis points to a difference in how net interest income is presented as between UniCredit and Commerzbank. At the level of UniCredit Group, we would accordingly anticipate a shift between net interest income and fair value results. On top of that, the purchase price allocation that is required will create differences between Commerzbank Group's figures and the matching figures in UniCredit's consolidated financial statements. That matters both at initial consolidation and in later periods. Turning now to the outlook. We remain firmly on track for <<inaudible>> and reaffirm our key targets while making adjustments to a few line items. As ever, the outlook depends on further geopolitical developments and events in Russia.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#20

Our revenue guidance stays at EUR 13.2 billion, and that rests on our adjusted outlook of EUR 8.5 billion for net interest income plus EUR 0.4 billion for net fair value and other income. For the risk result, the outlook remains the same, at roughly EUR 850 million. We're reaffirming a cost outlook of approximately EUR 7 billion. As a result, the outlook is unchanged for the cost/income ratio at around 53%, for the net result at a minimum of EUR 3.4 billion, and for a CET1 ratio above 14%. We're likewise holding to our target of a 100% payout ratio, made up of share buybacks and the dividend, and we expect a RoTE of about 12%. That brings me to the end of the presentation. Thanks for listening, and Bettina and I are now glad to take your questions.

Operator operator
#21

<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Benjamin Goy at Deutsche Bank.

Benjamin Goy analyst
#22

I have two questions, if I may. First, regarding net interest income: even allowing for some generous rounding, my math says you need at least EUR 100 million to hit your Q4 net interest income guidance. Could you perhaps shed a bit more light and confidence on the components that get you there? And on that same topic, do you anticipate any shift in deposit strategy, given that the market is expanding overall but appears to consist largely of rate-sensitive deposits? So should we expect more bundled products? Are you leaning more toward corporate clients, that sort of thing? Then secondly, about the constructive talks with UniCredit that you mentioned, I'm just curious whether there's anything new to report on what you'd call Phase 2 — that is, the go-to-market approach for the corporate business, especially the international network, and any other possible stumbling blocks.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#23

Benjamin, I’ll handle the first question about NII. And if I heard you right, what you wanted specifically was how Q3 and Q4 develop over the remainder of the year. If we look at the run rate in Q3, and take into account what the market is showing us, including deposit competition as we move into Q4, we basically expect a higher run rate, coming mainly from a sort of increase in the contribution of the replication portfolio — call that roughly EUR 70 billion. A similar amount comes roughly from the rate-sensitive positions. We still expect a bit of an uptick from the volume we’re seeing and also from mBank, while at the same time we see a slight decrease in Q4 from the beta. Taken together, that should actually get us to roughly EUR 200 million to EUR 300 million of increased run rate, and therefore bring us to EUR 8.5 billion for the full year. So those are the moves we see in the portfolio. As for the deposit strategy we have, as was briefly mentioned in the speech already, we have deliberately actually observed the market and assessed where to enter it. We are very much economically driven in what we do and want to balance the volume and the margins we’re seeing.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#24

During Q4, we began with extra promotional offers at levels we consider reasonable. And we always aim to offer bundled products and at minimum secure the whole client relationship, so that we move past deposits alone. So expect us to stay active there, again, always on economically sensible terms as we see them, and we anticipate volumes rising once more toward the close of the fourth quarter.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#25

Yes. And maybe to add to that, we shouldn't overlook that we're also actively working to turn some deposits into securities, since we believe that matters too — and hopefully you'll see more of that starting early next year, when the new pension reform takes effect. That's something we constantly bear in mind as well, because there's a strategy behind it. On UniCredit, I mean, right now we're entirely concentrated on 2 things. First is really ensuring we're fully prepared for the upstream consolidation. That's number one. And number two is sharing as much information as possible regarding our business model and how strong that business model is. We're still doing this in a situation where we have to be careful about what we can share and what we can't, since not all approvals are in place yet. Then we're very focused on this Phase 1, where we remain a publicly listed company operating independently, with HBV and UniCredit essentially competing with each other. So Phase 2 isn't something in focus at the moment, because it's also unclear when it will happen.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#26

The main emphasis, then, is really on Phase 1. Yet, as we likewise demonstrated during the presentation, we believe significant value creation already exists within this phase on the cost side — where we can certainly align on procurement, and also with regard to the international network as well as product platforms. And through the <<inaudible>>, you can hopefully gain advantages too when it comes to product offerings from the joint group. That should be the focus — while not forgetting key matters such as cybersecurity and AI, where you can clearly learn from one another and take full advantage of the complete group.

Operator operator
#27

And our following question is from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous.

Stefan-Michael Stalmann analyst
#28

I've got two, if I may. First, on NII. From how you've laid out what's happened recently, you've shed EUR 3 billion of rate-sensitive deposits that weren't especially profitable. That alone probably doesn't account for a double-digit hit to NII. So cutting the NII figure by EUR 100 million seems to point to volume and margin effects showing up in your core business. Could you give us a little more detail on that? Second question, on Stage 3 coverage. Looking at it year-on-year, Stage 3 loans are up more than EUR 1 billion while Stage 3 provisions have stayed flat. I understand that quarter-to-quarter, various things can move the ratio around. But how do we get comfortable that, structurally and over the longer term, this lower coverage ratio is genuinely fine?

Carsten Schmitt executive
#29

Stefan, I'll begin with NII. So once more, regarding the trend we observed this quarter, we saw roughly EUR 3 billion in deposit outflows — again, since we purposely decided to watch the market and, once more, take part in that business, which in economic terms we regard as valuable. As for how NII moved during the quarter, we don't see any effect on the overall deposit base we hold. Quite the opposite, in fact: we keep exercising our pricing capability and expect that to add positively as well in the fourth quarter. What we do observe is that, on the loan side of the book, there is, as noted, a modest dip in margin within the single basis point range. That by itself also weighed on the third quarter. So, taking in the movements from the <<inaudible>> along with funding effects, there was a slight erosion relative to the ambitious targets we had set for the year. We actually don't see any effect on the business as such — again, since we intend to keep pace and catch up on volumes once more. Then, on the Stage 3 question, regarding the shift in volume and the coverage ratio, we had a full write-off of highly covered exposures in Stage 3, and that leads to a lower coverage ratio.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#30

What happened is basically that those engagements shifted out of Stage 3, and Stage 3 carried a bigger contribution to overall coverage. That's idiosyncratic to these particular exposures. So from this, we don't see any structural effect in the portfolio.

Stefan-Michael Stalmann analyst
#31

Would you attribute the year-over-year drop in the coverage ratio mainly to those write-offs of the highly covered loans, or was that just a Q3 phenomenon?

Carsten Schmitt executive
#32

The bulk of what we observed came during Q3, though it's plainly tied to those specific exposures.

Operator operator
#33

And the next question comes from Máté Nemes at UBS.

Máté Némes analyst
#34

Yes, I’ve got 3 of those, please. The first would concern NII and, more precisely, the replication portfolio. Carsten, I believe you said that over the next couple of years we probably shouldn’t count on the size staying unchanged. Could you give a little more detail on what you expect to drive the volume of those? Is it just the size, or volume, of nonmaturing deposits in your franchise? Or do you also expect some behavioral shifts to influence how the volume develops there? That’s the first one. The second concerns the EUR 850 million risk result expectation. That implies almost EUR 300 million of net new provisions in Q4. I was just wondering whether that is simply caution. And could you give any further detail on asset quality trends, particularly, I suppose, in corporate clients? Also, would you expect any additional provision top-ups, for example, for macro risks? And the last question is about RWA reductions. Could you update us on the benefits expected from these over the coming quarters? What is the sequencing here?

Carsten Schmitt executive
#35

Thank you very much. I’ll take the NII question and the one about RWA. Bettina will probably chime in on the risk results. Regarding the size of the replication portfolio, what I meant in the speech was to emphasize that the replication portfolio as it currently stands is also what appears in our presentation on Page 20, an unchanged portfolio assumption at current forward rates. My remark about a changing portfolio was more — let’s call it — from a prudent standpoint, saying that naturally we will always adjust the portfolio, as you have seen, for instance, at the beginning of this year, whether through contributions, that is, size increases if we truly believe that is viable given how our deposits are structured and behave, or possible reductions down the road. Right now, we regard the portfolio as stable. If we did see changes to the portfolio, that is always a function of volume first and foremost. As you may remember from earlier quarters, we always maintain a decent buffer between the volumes actually invested in the portfolio and those we are able to model. Those remain very comfortable. And so, movements, as you saw in the third quarter, do not automatically imply that we will end up rebalancing the portfolio.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#36

On the behavioral side, we aren't really observing shifts within the individual deposit classes, though of course we keep watching that closely, and it always depends somewhat on how we go after those different deposit classes with the offers we make. So on the whole, expect the replication portfolio to stay stable and to contribute to our NII as described. And perhaps I'll address the RWA question first. Regarding RWA reduction, during the third quarter we got permission from the ECB to bring in our foundational internal ratings-based approach on certain portfolios. As we said, the impact we'll see lands in the middle to high single-digit billion area in RWA. A smaller portion of that showed up as prebooked RWA in Q3, but the bulk of the effect you'll see between Q4 this year into Q2. Expect that to develop in a relatively linear way, with relief across these 3 quarters up to that full amount.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#37

On the risk results side, well, you're totally correct. That is a careful posture, and we adopted it very deliberately, since we know full well that Q4 runs long. By now we've had an extended stretch with no expansion in Germany. So some effects are always present, and we simply remain prudent about it. That said, I'd put it this way: we'd prefer to anchor on the EUR 850 million at the bottom of the range rather than the top. And beyond that, if I consider all the signals <<inaudible>> positive. Look at the Ifo 1 — the Ifo index, which has now risen 6 times in succession. Look at the upgraded GDP growth forecasts for this year, at 1.2%, with some even expecting 1.3%, 1.4%. And then only this morning, we got the newest order figures for German industry, which had been a concern for a good while, because the trend was quite flat. Yet for the first time, it has picked up markedly, which is welcome news as well. So overall, I'd describe us as conservative, yet we're quite at ease with that.

Operator operator
#38

And our following question is from Borja Ramirez with Citi Group.

Borja Ramirez Segura analyst
#39

I have 2 questions, please. The first one concerns deposit volumes — I'd like to see whether you could give us some color on how much in deposits you may have gathered quarter to date. My second question is about NII, perhaps looking out to 2027 and past that. I noticed the guidance for income from the replication portfolio has been raised by EUR 200 million on the basis of the curve as it stands, now at EUR 700 million. And on top of that, we have the ECB — the rate hikes expected from the ECB. So pulling all of this together, and given that your guidance already baked in conservative assumptions on deposit beta, I'd like to ask whether there might be upside to the EUR 9.3 billion consensus NII for 2027 on the current curve.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#40

Borja, first off, regarding deposit volumes so far in Q4, as I said before, our goal is to get deposit volumes rising again. We already launched product — active products in the market in October. So we're on an upward trend, and we'll report on that, Borja, I think, once the quarter wraps up, but a clear increase is expected. Then on your second question about NII for 2027, I think there are various ways to look at it. We'll finish this year with a record NII of EUR 8.5 billion. And as you correctly note, next year brings a strong contribution from the replication portfolio. At present we see that at roughly EUR 700 million. Parts of the increase you're seeing, given current forward rates, will help us offset some of the pressure we're seeing from deposit competition. So that ties somewhat to your beta assumption. We're very low or relatively low, let's say, in the current market environment this quarter at 40%. But as you're also aware, we expect the beta to rise steadily over the coming years.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#41

That will definitely be a bit of a drag on development. As for the ECB rate increases on the way, on balance they help us. The bank is, as you know, positively positioned to interest rates in that respect. Still, we also anticipate higher funding costs accompanying them. So on the whole, Borja, if I may put it that way, since we'll discuss our 2027 guidance in February alongside full year results, I'd say I'm not uncomfortable with the guidance currently out there for NII -- sorry, to be 100% clear, the consensus.

Operator operator
#42

And our next question comes from Riccardo Rovere at Mediobanca.

Riccardo Rovere analyst
#43

Two things, if I can. First, on the guidance — you cut the NII outlook by about EUR 100 million, yet at the same time you raised the indication for fair value items by roughly EUR 100 million, which might seem a bit counterintuitive given what's going on in the fixed income market. So my question is whether those 2 things are sort of intertwined, interconnected perhaps for accounting reasons rather than anything else, or whether they're entirely separate — just to give us a sense. And then on the slide where Phase 2 is shown, you used the word — if I'm not mistaken, Bettina, you used the word potential. Do you see that as the most likely outcome in due course, or is it merely one of the possible options? Just to get a sense of your thinking there, if you can.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#44

Riccardo, I'll begin with NII and net fair value, and with your question about whether those two are interconnected. Of course, there are always elements that are interconnected to some degree — the interest rate moves we are seeing are partly offset by movement in net fair value. So some interconnectedness does exist. But I wouldn't build a fully connected picture into the Q3 or full-year guidance we're now providing for the NII movement relative to the fair value movement. What we generally observe in fair value, and did observe in the third quarter, was a healthy underlying business in the capital markets. As mentioned, our Corporate Clients business actually contributed somewhat more than the usual run rate we would expect, and that is generally what provides for the underlying beat in this — or baseline, I should say, in this line item. So we saw a somewhat stronger contribution there. Hence it is not entirely counter linked to the NII. When we look at the movement on a year-over-year basis, there is, of course, a stronger relation, especially when we look at the mBank movement — we saw lower NII coming from mBank given the drastically lower rates in Poland, which is counterbalanced in the net fair value.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#45

So these things are connected. But on the EUR 100 million we talked about across both line items this quarter — that isn't 100% tied together. It stems from a wider set of developments. And I'd say the main thing is we saw solid performance in the underlying Corporate Clients business.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#46

And Ricardo, on the different phases: our emphasis in the mid term is plainly on Phase 1, since that's what we're moving into right now, and timing-wise it's unclear when Phase 2 might show up. But it's also quite evident — we're all aware of this — that there's a distinction depending on whether you're a publicly listed, independent company with 51% minority shareholders, which German company law also bears on, or whether full integration is the goal, which is achievable only through some form of merger and would let you essentially line up, say, the German retail network and such things. So the extent of synergy potential you can capture varies across these phases. Still, for the time being, concentrating on Phase 1 strikes me as smart.

Operator operator
#47

And our following question is from Tobias Lukesch at Kepler Cheuvreux.

Tobias Lukesch analyst
#48

Just a quick one again — Carsten and Stefan went into detail on that, and you also mentioned the EUR 100 million just now. The deposit movement puzzles me too. What I mean is, the EUR 3 billion you lost came mostly from PSBC and term deposits. And clearly, we've seen a decline across the year, essentially stemming from the push in Q3 and Q4 of last year, when initiatives brought in roughly EUR 8 billion of deposits at PSBC. So I'm wondering what the actual assumption was for deposit growth over the course of the year. In other words, what natural rate did you expect? And obviously, you look somewhat flattish, or declining, as those strong offerings flowed out during the past year. And second, maybe on cost again — I mean, regarding cost development and restructuring costs, is there anything tangible you foresee changing over Q4, Q1, perhaps Q2 of next year, now that there's a more collaborative approach with UniCredit?

Carsten Schmitt executive
#49

Thanks, Tobias. So to address your question about deposits first, you're absolutely right. Last year, when we were examining deposit development, we had an attacker out last year, at the end of Q2, beginning of Q3, which led us to gather roughly EUR 8 billion, as you mentioned. Those funds went out ending in the first quarter, and then continuing from there, what we observed in the market, particularly in Q2, was market entrants by participants who really came out with exceptionally high offers at that point in time, also significantly above ECB deposit rates. So it was a market that we deliberately did not want to sort of engage in at that point in time. Over the year, we were originally anticipating deposit volume growth of around 1% to 2%. That is in line with the strategy goals that we put out last year. We are clearly now, as you said, flattish and have declined again in Q3. That we will stop in Q4, hence, going out now with offers that we see as economically viable. The benefit that we actually saw by not participating clearly was a slight uptick coming from lower beta, but that is something, as we've also guided towards the next years, we see inclining given the deposit competition.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#50

For us, then, the question is more about timing — when to move on this — and then actively striking a balance between the volumes and the margins we have. So it's pretty much all going according to plan, in line with what we've observed in the market so far.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#51

On the cost side, look, we firmly believe in the cost/income ratio targets we've set, and we're going to deliver on them. If you look at what's in our strategy up to now, we had momentum with a reduction of 3,900 FTE, and the full restructuring costs needed for that were already booked last year, in 2025. We've now announced a further 3,000 FTEs. For that one, you'll likely see the first booking in the first -- in the fourth quarter, and that's at least also reflected in our guidance. The remainder we expect in 2026. And you can also see that we're making progress -- 2027, sorry, in 2027, the rest in <<inaudible>>. And you can see progress because we already have a lot of signatures on momentum and a lot of sign-ins on the Momentum 2030 programs. So we're quite optimistic that this head count reduction can be achieved in a very socially responsible way. As to whether there will be even more restructuring given the value creation potential also laid out in our presentation, that is something we first need to detail out further.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#52

You should see some benefit from it, though it shouldn’t be too large and needs to be easy to digest. So from where I sit, we’ve set out very clear targets for 2027 through 2030. And I believe those targets can only get better. To me, they really represent the bottom end of the targets and nothing else.

Tobias Lukesch analyst
#53

One final question, if I may. Regarding shareholder returns, you said you obviously aim to maximize value for all stakeholders. So recent talks have been far more aligned with UniCredit when it comes to achieving synergies jointly. I think the key question on shareholder returns is this: that 100% payout promise you restated — how are the discussions with UniCredit going? Clearly, some investors worry the payout could be cut. But since there may only be some extra restructuring costs, and as we learned with Q2 there's definitely substantial capital relief, one could argue these offset each other. In that case, the return expectations we held 3, 4 months ago wouldn't be hurt in such a scenario. Is that a fair way to think about it? Yes.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#54

At least that's how we look at it, because if you focus just on 2026 for a moment, we're targeting net income of EUR 3.4 billion, and we've just confirmed that with a CET1 ratio that will be far above 14%. So we're still very comfortable and also above our target ratio, and that's where we stick with our capital return policy, which states that we have a 100% return as long as we haven't achieved the targeted CET1 ratio. And unless I'm totally mistaken, UniCredit has a very similar capital return policy. So, I mean, we're very committed. And if I also look at the way forward, the amount of net income we'll deliver over the next years, which we haven't included at any point in time in our CET1 projections, gives you a lot of positive momentum when it comes to our equity story and the capital return.

Operator operator
#55

Our following question is from Anke Reingen at RBC.

Anke Reingen analyst
#56

Let me start with the replication portfolio benefit and the unchanged NII guidance. Are you essentially seeing more headwinds, or at this point are you basically not changing your net interest income guidance given that, I assume, NII will shift under the new reporting anyway? And in that connection, you mentioned headwinds from loan margins — could you elaborate a bit more? Is there anything unexpected, and in which pockets of the book? Then second, coming back to the earlier question, can you offer investors a bit more assurance regarding the minority shareholders in Commerzbank, and a bit more on how the booking of restructuring charges will be adjusted in your payout ratio? And I mean, I guess if there's an acquisition of HGB, how should minority shareholders think about how they're being treated in the overall process?

Carsten Schmitt executive
#57

Alright, thanks so much. I'll start with the first question, which is about the benefits of the replication portfolio. The overview we put in the pack has been updated to reflect current forward rates, and those rates have moved up significantly in certain parts of the curve since our last call. So the higher contribution you're seeing from the replication portfolio in the coming years is essentially a repricing at today's forwards. That should help us offset the headwinds, which come mainly from competition on deposits, and we also expect a somewhat higher beta as we head into next year, and to a lesser extent from the loan margin impact I mentioned earlier. That one is comparatively minor — let's say a single-digit basis point effect on the book — and it's fairly broad-based, and at this point it also stems from the fact that there's still plenty of supply, so to speak, in the loan market. So you do see some competition there as well, but at a completely different level from what we're seeing on deposits. So the majority comes from deposits, and we believe the portfolio is offsetting that.

Carsten Schmitt executive
#58

So you'd also see us plainly reaffirming what we expect for NII across the coming years. So...

Anke Reingen analyst
#59

So why wouldn't there be room to improve NII? Is that because you're seeing more headwinds, or is it just...

Carsten Schmitt executive
#60

Yes. It's mainly because — no, it's the models; we'll keep them as they are. We don't expect to change them. This is purely to address the current situation we are seeing in the market, which we've seen developing over the course of the year with the competition and also anticipating that, as mentioned, as a consequence of the competition will also go up. So this is why we're keeping it steady at this point in time. As mentioned before, we're running into the end of this year with an expectation for record NII and for the next years, expect inclines as we've also shown with the replication portfolio. So we approach it from that perspective, a little counterbalance and then let's take it quarter-by-quarter when we see how the increased rate expectation also materializes.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#61

Now, regarding minorities and minority shareholders — I mean, first off, our equity story is genuinely strong. When you look at our targets and at our business model, none of that is changing. And it won't change just because we're part of the UniCredit Group. That's the key message, first point. Second, if you look at the numbers, they're very strong as well. From where we sit, when you look at Phase 1, they can only get stronger, and they will then also balance out should any necessary restructuring costs arise. And don't forget — and I have no reason to doubt this — that we're aligned with our controlling shareholder, soon to be, on our goal of maximizing value rather than destroying it, which means whatever target you see here is a minimum we intend to hit, and probably exceed. And then it isn't just the controlling shareholder who benefits — minority shareholders do too. And then there's our company law, the German Acting Gazette, which spells out very clearly how you must act as a Management Board, and as a Supervisory Board as well, particularly for as long as no domination agreement is in place.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#62

And it's quite evident that you must act exclusively and in the interest of every stakeholder and every shareholder. There's also that small instrument known as the dependency report, where you're required to give a very clear description if certain decisions are made because you belong to a larger group. And as a Board of Managing Director, you additionally carry the obligation to request disadvantaged compensation if a decision might exist that benefits only the controlling shareholder rather than the minority shareholders. So some protective elements are in there. But above all, I'd say we are aligned on our objective and our target of maximizing value for all stakeholders. And even in a Phase 1, which isn't yet defined in any way timing-wise, minority shareholders would benefit either by becoming part of a larger group, should they accept that, or they would receive a cash appraisal. And if they chose to remain within the group, they would likewise benefit <<inaudible>> from potential synergy potential that would then be created. So from my perspective, there is a win-win, always assuming we are aligned on our objective of...

Operator operator
#63

And our next question is from Jochen Schmitt at Metzler.

Jochen Schmitt analyst
#64

I have a single question. Regarding what you said about the efficiency potential in Phase 1 on Slide 8 of your presentation, should we expect an update from you on your medium-term targets in February next year? Or is it a bit too soon to answer that question?

Bettina Orlopp executive
#65

That would be a goal, though I’m not sure we’ll already be ready to do that.

Operator operator
#66

That brings us to the final question for today, and that question has been withdrawn. All right. Many thanks to everyone. That wraps up our Q&A session, and I'll now hand things back to our CEO, Dr. Bettina Orlopp.

Bettina Orlopp executive
#67

Thanks so much for every one of your questions and for taking an interest, and I hope the remainder of your week goes really well and, after that, that you have a lovely weekend — and see you, we'll talk again before long.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Commerzbank AG transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Commerzbank AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.