Vornado Realty Trust (VNO) Earnings Call Transcript
February 11, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Thanks for joining Vornado Realty Trust's Q4 earnings call. Our Q4 earnings release went out yesterday afternoon, and we also submitted our annual report on Form 10-K to the Securities and Exchange Commission. You can find those documents, along with our supplemental financial information packages, on our website, www.vno.com, in the Investor Relations section. During today's call and in those documents, we'll be talking about certain non-GAAP financial measures. Our earnings release, Form 10-K, and financial supplements contain reconciliations of those measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measures. Please note that what we say today may be considered forward-looking statements, and actual results could differ materially from those statements because of a variety of risks, uncertainties, and other factors. For additional details about these risks and uncertainties, please see our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including our annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2024. Today's call may contain time-sensitive information that is accurate only as of today's date. The company does not undertake a duty to update any forward-looking statements. Joining us on the call today for opening comments from management are Steven Roth, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Michael Franco, President and Chief Financial Officer. Our senior team is also here and available for questions. I'll now hand the call over to Steven Roth.
Thanks, Steve, and good morning to all of you. Over at Vornado, things are going well — truly well — and they keep improving. Our home is New York, and there's broad agreement that the real estate markets here rank above all others in the country, far and away the strongest. As I've noted previously, although New York contains more than 400 million sq ft of office space, our actual competition happens in a smaller segment — roughly 188 million sq ft of superior properties. Within that superior segment, availability sits at 10.7%, compared with 20.1% in the inferior segment. And that 10.7% figure is disappearing at a rapid pace. On Park Avenue, it's already below 7%. On top of that, the expense of constructing a new tower in New York has roughly doubled across the past six to seven years, and when you factor in borrowing costs, fresh supply at 6% is essentially locked up. No significant new building has broken ground in five years, and after ground is broken, it takes five to seven years to deliver. When you put all of this together, what you get is a landlord's market. We anticipate rents climbing sharply. Some might describe it as rents spiking; in truth, rents have already begun their ascent. So everything looks great — extremely great. Why New York? Because it's America's world city. The human and physical capital here cannot be replicated; we possess the biggest, best-educated workforce and the finest transit network for commuting from our enormous suburbs. You might interpret that as a pitch for the PENN DISTRICT, and I suppose it is. We have the greatest concentration of corporate headquarters, the finest dining and museums, plus eight professional sports teams — although the New York Yankees apparently can't manage to defeat the Brooklyn Dodgers. Let me zero in on a few items and several of our recent wins. Remote work was a fright, but just as we forecast, it wouldn't endure; it didn't endure. The majority have abandoned their kitchen tables and returned to the office. Our share price climbed 49% in 2024, following a 35% gain in 2023. During 2024, we signed 3.4 million sq ft in total, with 2.65 million sq ft consisting of New York office space, commanding market-leading $104 starting rents alongside mark-to-markets of 2.5% cash and 10.9% GAAP. For a second consecutive year, we closed the highest number of premium $100-plus deals in New York — 18 transactions spanning 1.36 million sq ft; we also closed three among New York's top 10 largest office deals. At PENN 1, we closed 285,000 sq ft of deals at $98 starting rents, beating our underwriting. We closed 25 retail leases amounting to 187,000 sq ft, with Manhattan's first Primark in the PENN DISTRICT as the standout. We closed the Uniqlo sale at 666 Fifth Avenue, achieving a record $20,000 per sq ft. Last month, upon maturity, we paid off our 3.5%, $450 million unsecured bonds using cash held on balance sheet plus $108 million drawn from our credit line. Every property we own is now 100% LEED certified, and no one else in the country has hit that mark before us. We're basically at the two-yard line on a handful of major deals. By the time this month wraps up, we will finally have closed the master lease with NYU covering 770 Broadway — that's our building of 1.1 million sq ft. That transaction removes $700 million in debt linked to the property from our balance sheet, and it also eliminates 500,000 sq ft of vacancy. By the way, this large, eye-catching property right next to the NYU campus is set to become their science center. I've been shown the plans. It will be a world-class educational facility, and it will elevate NYU into an even stronger elite institution of higher learning. That benefits NYU, and it benefits New York. Shortly, we'll be completing a refinancing of 1535 Broadway, and that will allow us to cash out over $400 million in retail JV preferreds for redemption. We also have several asset sales in progress. When you add it all up, these deals are set to generate an extra $1 billion in fresh cash in the near future. As for PENN 2, a 300,000 sq ft lease is only a matter of weeks away from being executed. The feedback from tenants and brokers on PENN 2 has been extremely favorable, with many saying it's the finest redevelopment they've witnessed, and when you pair it with PENN 1, the amenity offerings are unmatched in both size and quality; additionally, we're reviewing several tenant proposals at PENN 2, including talks on an LOI for a significant headquarters lease. My guess is that by the time this year wraps up, PENN 2 will be about 80% leased. The rents we're getting there are coming in above what we put in our underwriting, which is why the incremental yield on page 16 of our supplement has been bumped up to 10.2%. As for Pier 94, located on Manhattan's West Side, it should be finished by the close of 2025 — and it'll be the first facility ever built in Manhattan specifically for film and television soundstage production. Turning now to those of you following Alexander's, the affiliate in which we hold a 32.4% stake: in Q2 of 2024, we renewed the Bloomberg office lease at 731 Lexington Avenue ahead of schedule, covering 947,000 sq ft, and its expiration has now been extended to 2040. Over in Queens, at Rego Park, the final two tenants still occupying Rego One — Burlington and Marshalls — are being relocated into Rego Two, the shopping center right next door. That leaves Rego Two completely filled while giving us a totally empty space at Rego One to either sell or develop. Naturally, we think this five-acre site, which sits at Queens Boulevard and Junction Boulevard and touches the Long Island Expressway, has a location so favorable that the land itself is worth more than the building, which is 66 years old. In my view, Alexander's stock price falls well short of what its assets are actually worth, and we're going to have to take action on that. As for 350 Park Avenue, that development is proceeding according to plan. The new building's design is completely finished, and it's going to be exceptional — genuinely, genuinely the finest anywhere. Right now we're going through the official approval steps under Midtown East Zoning, and Citadel, which is our biggest tenant, along with Ken Griffin, who is our partner, will soon start relocating from 350 Park into swing space, which lets demolition get underway early next year. To wrap up, I want to say how proud everyone on our Vornado teams feels about what we've achieved so far in the PENN DISTRICT. Consider what's happening at the Farley Building with Meta, plus PENN 1, PENN 2, Moynihan Train Hall, the Long Island Rail Road Concourse, the 33rd Street Plaza, and PENN 11 as well — everyone here couldn't be more excited about the future of this city within a city. The Hotel Pennsylvania site comes up next, and it's already been demolished to ground level, so we're set to move forward. Clearly, our PENN DISTRICT deserves a visit. Should you not have been there yet, ring me up and I'll arrange a tour. Michael, the floor is yours.
Thanks, Steve, and hello everybody. For the full year, comparable FFO came to $2.26 per share. As we had projected earlier, that figure declined versus 2023, driven by reduced NOI stemming from the known move-outs we talked about all year, along with increased net interest expense. Still, on the whole, we outperformed what we had expected at earlier points in the year. The main reason is that leasing at 330 West 34th Street sped up, and there we are recognizing lease termination income tied to signing a 304,000 sq ft lease with WeWork for Amazon. On top of that, net interest expense came in below our initial estimate because short-term rates declined. Incidentally, nearly 80% of the empty space tied to those known move-outs is already accounted for. Comparable FFO for Q4 was $0.61 per share, versus $0.63 per share in Q4 2023. That drop stemmed chiefly from greater net interest expense and reduced NOI from the known move-outs, partly offset by the lease termination income at 330 West 34th Street plus decreased G&A expense. A quarter-over-quarter bridge appears on page three of our earnings release and page six of our financial supplement. Now let's discuss 2025. While we typically don't issue earnings guidance, we can share that, in line with current consensus, we see 2025 coming in slightly below 2024. Part of this stems from the lease termination income at 330 West 34th Street mentioned earlier, which lifted 2024 comparable FFO. As we noted on last quarter's call, the GAAP earnings effect of backfilling vacancies and leasing up PENN 2 won't materialize until near the close of 2026, with the complete favorable effect arriving in 2027, producing substantial earnings growth by 2027. A brief note on occupancy. Our office occupancy at year-end stood at 88.8%, an increase from 87.5% in the prior quarter; once the pending full building master lease at 770 Broadway is included, office occupancy rises 330 basis points to 92.1%. As mentioned before, our first quarter 2025 occupancy will fall because PENN 2 is being placed into service. We expect that decline to be short-lived as PENN 2 occupancy steadies across the coming year and we reach the low 90s. Our New York leasing pipeline stays strong as we head into 2025; we have considerable activity throughout our portfolio, with 750,000 sq ft under negotiation, in addition to the 1 million sq ft master lease being completed with NYU at 770 Broadway. Furthermore, we hold another 1.3 million sq ft at various stages of proposals and negotiation. Shifting to the capital markets, both the financing and investment sales markets have displayed encouraging signals during the last few months. The CMBS market is fully open for large, high-quality assets like ours, provided appropriate metrics and loan structures. AAA and overall spreads for recent financings on The Spiral and 299 Park Avenue have tightened considerably over the past six months, reaching levels in line with pre-COVID. For this year, our expectation is that banks mostly stay uninvolved, but a handful have started examining loans for smaller office properties, which is an encouraging early indicator of a pattern we think will persist. On the downside, short-term rates, having fallen 100 basis points during the prior year, appear set to stay near where they are now for the foreseeable future, which keeps the cost of borrowing elevated. The market for investment sales is also continuing to recover, with a number of high-quality office assets changing hands lately, among them interest from Munich Re in 320 Park Avenue and from Blackstone in 1345 Avenue of the Americas. With that, I'll hand things to the operator for Q&A.
Yeah, thank you. Morning to you. Steve, I appreciate the kind words regarding our leasing efforts. It sounds as though you're on the verge of converting a handful of deals here, though perhaps you or Glen might offer a bit more detail on the schedule for PENN 2, i suppose, specifically, and also the level of competition you're encountering for that space, plus how confident you are that led to the yield increase on PENN 2.
Hello, Steve. This is Glen. How are things with you? Well, PENN 2 is performing better than is typical. All the major tenants in the market include it among their top three choices of what to tour. Manhattan has just 5 buildings offering blocks of 500,000sq ft or larger. Ours is the finest block; thus, as you heard during the remarks, we've got a lease out with a single tenant that will close shortly for 330,000sq ft; we hold an LOI at a highly advanced stage with another sizable headquarters tenant. And beyond that, tenants are competing for space ranging from 60,000 to 200,000sq ft. So PENN 2 has become the focal point of many tenants' searches, and we're fully in year five of our leasing.
All right. Any thoughts on the rental rates, I suppose, that you're seeing out there? I suppose that ties to the cap rate moving higher by 70 basis points there.
Throughout the whole property, we've pushed our rents up, starting at the lowest floor and going all the way to the highest.
I'd like to pick up on what Steve said regarding the $1 billion in fresh cash proceeds you're expecting. At 770 Broadway, you've got $700 million of debt being repaid, plus $400 million released at 1535 Broadway, and beyond that, additional dispositions — so I'm curious how much you expect from those new dispositions.
What amount do you anticipate from new dispositions? Based on the figures you just mentioned, that $700 million will retire debt. From that building, a bit extra is coming in — a couple hundred million dollars more. Refinancing 1535 brings in $400 million, and short-term dispositions will supply whatever is needed to bring the total to a billion dollars.
Will the properties you're targeting be in the retail category, in non-core office, or is there any detail you can offer about what's on the block?
I'm not going to get into specifics on that, John.
Thanks a lot. Nice work on such a strong 2024. Could you connect what Steve mentioned about the spike?
I can't let that go by without saying thank you.
Alright, sure. Steve, could you connect what you said at the start about anticipating a jump in rents with what Michael mentioned regarding growth in 2027? I believe 2025 is clear to all of us. Could you also link 2026 in some way to either of those remarks? Thanks.
Honestly, I really can't say for certain. These sorts of cycles have come around on us maybe four or five times already. My point — and I believed I expressed it quite plainly — is that New York holds plenty of room overall, yet our competition happens within a far narrower slice of the superior stock, and that slice sits a bit under 200 million sq ft. That covers point one. Point two: within that slice, available space stands at 10% right now and is dropping fast, since we're short on inventory. No recession has hit us, every one of our tenants is growing, and growing hard, across New York. Their operations are performing well. The equity market is performing well. So conditions are sound and strong, and appetite for New York space is genuinely outstanding. Given that availability is scarce and contracting, with zero fresh inventory arriving — and that piece matters enormously — nothing new is entering the market, for a whole range of reasons. Building expenses are absurdly elevated. Rates haven't come down; in fact, longer-dated rates haven't budged whatsoever. Consequently, the capacity to bring forward fresh inventory is extremely constrained — I'd call it frozen. Stack all of that up, and you've got a landlord's market; we anticipate significant rent increases in the coming year — should I say it, a spike; and now, regarding what Michael mentioned about 2026, would you like to add something?
Yes. Jeff, here's how I'd put it: when we examine our portfolio, there are several drivers in play, and one of them involves filling up the empties. A meaningful portion of that, we recognize, will come from PENN 2 along with some from PENN 1. As leases roll over, we've now moved past that point into a landlord's market, where mark-to-market is positive, so it takes a while for that to flow through. 2026 will bring an improvement, but we believe very significant improvement arrives in 2027.
Alright, here's another angle for you to consider. At PENN 2, the leases we're signing right now sit in the $100 range — possibly a touch above that. Nothing guarantees this, but look at our neighbors: Manhattan West and Hudson Yards. Market rents at those properties, even though they're newer — in fact, brand new — run substantially and monumentally above $100 per foot. As conditions in this market grow tighter, and as the PENN DISTRICT matures and comes to be seen as the single best spot on the West Side, nothing rules out market rents at PENN 2 climbing from $100 per foot to $125 per foot, and perhaps far beyond that. Appreciation of that kind in income will drive values up monumentally. So, for instance — Tom, help me out here — $25 per foot multiplied by 5 million feet comes to $125 million annually, right? $125 million a year translates into $1.5 billion to $2 billion of value, with no capital expense at all. So our enthusiasm is unbelievable — about the market, about how it's tightening, and about the inventory we hold.
Thanks for that. That's really useful. I've got one more question, and it's about what you said regarding collaborating with a big anchor — obviously I'm not after names or anything like that — but could you simply describe what the appetite looks like for anchor space? Is there one specific sector driving it, like tech or finance? Or is it spread across the board? And I'm not sure whether you might connect that back to the Hotel PENNsylvania location. Thank you.
Hey Jeff, this is Glen speaking. Broadly, though, the main things pushing demand are finance, law, and technology. That's the pattern we're observing, and it holds not only at PENN but throughout the whole portfolio.
All right. I appreciate you fielding this. Steve, I'd like to circle back to what you said regarding the fact that, in your view — or your team's view — the market isn't recognizing Alexander's worth, along with your remarks about taking some kind of action on that. Could you elaborate a bit on what you're getting at? Is there anything we might see coming?
Sure, thank you. When you look at Alexander's holdings and run a sum-of-the-parts evaluation, that figure, no matter how you frame it, is bound to be far, far greater than where the shares trade. It's really a straightforward idea, rooted in NAV. Break down the value of each property individually, and it comes out well above the share price. Now, consider this for a moment. Take Rego One — which, I suppose you could describe as a shopping center that didn't work out — IKEA departed, so it's getting smaller. What we're left with is a building that's 66 years old. Re-tenanting a structure like that carries an enormous capital cost, and clearly the economics don't work. So the straightforward thing we did was take the two tenants still remaining — actually Burlington and Marshalls, a pair of excellent tenants. Marshalls has occupied that space for 30 years, 40 years, quite a long stretch. In any case, we're currently in the midst of — and by the way, the paperwork is signed. We're now in the midst of relocating them into Rego Two, which will bring Rego Two to full occupancy, a fairly new shopping center that we constructed close to 10 years back. That turns Rego Two into a winner. And it clears out Rego One, a magnificent five-acre parcel, which we'll either sell or build on; that generates value. Right now, though, it produces no income. So anyone evaluating Alexander's purely through an income lens will wind up being badly mistaken about where the values actually stand. Still, that parcel sits right in the heart of Queens at the corner of Main, Main, Main, and Main, and in our view it's remarkably valuable; so we'll find out.
Thanks for that. I suppose there's one broader strategic item left. Several years back, you floated a tracking stock, and in the end you set it aside until the New York office market began to bounce back. With recovery now looking pretty substantial, is that idea once again under consideration? Could you walk us through where it fits within the bigger strategic picture?
The simple response is no, though a tracking stock crosses my mind daily. In my view, it remains an extremely, extremely, extremely sound concept. Honestly, I get zero backing for it from any of you, and not even from my own colleagues, yet it stays on my mind every day. Who knows — down the road it might prove to be a helpful instrument. For now, though, the answer is no. That said, I genuinely do like that idea.
Great. Thank you.
Hey. Thanks. I'm just wondering — your remarks about rents, clearly at the PENN DISTRICT they're much higher than what you likely initially underwrote. I remember you discussing $150 million, or at least we estimated roughly $150 million of NOI growth across your three PENN DISTRICT assets, PENN 1, PENN 2, and Farley. Thinking now about how market rents are progressing, has your expectation for NOI growth gone up and, I mean, fully stabilized? Could this thing produce over $300 million of NOI?
The response to that is, clearly, as rents rise, that projection will rise, though only slightly, and my finance people — who are smarter than me — tell me you must factor in capitalized interest. Roll it off. That will roll off. So, I mean, it's a complicated calculation, and my guys can help you with that offline. But essentially, what I'm looking for is PENN 2 leases up and as PENN 1 finishes its fill-up, and then there's some retail space in the Farley Building. As all of that occurs, the income from that cluster of buildings will rise by the better part of $150 million. And that's incrementally going up. That doesn't count, so it'll be more than that. Take it all together. So, I mean, I read your piece that you put out, I think, last week, and I think it is absolutely directionally correct.
Floris, just one quick point on that. As we continue building out this district — and like I mentioned during my prepared comments, the PENN 15 site, which used to be the old Hotel PENNsylvania, is what comes next; it's already been demolished, leveled completely. We're putting up a top-tier office tower there, and while I've noted that the design is locked in, we're approaching it as though the land cost at PENN 15 is already sunk. Treating it, for now, as if the dirt came free lets us get this new tower moving. In any case, when you view this as a whole neighborhood, once that world-class office building rises at PENN 15, it should lift the market value of PENN 1 and PENN 2, directly across the street, by no less than $25 to $50 per foot; so our view is that as we keep working on this district, the value we create is going to be pretty significant — I'd even call it enormous.
Yeah. If you begin putting those components in place. I suppose the next thing I'd ask about concerns acquisitions. I realize finding properties to buy isn't easy. Perhaps you might describe the landscape a bit, plus the kinds of deals you're evaluating and where you expect to find them, or where sourcing is more probable. Also, would you think about directing money to markets beyond Manhattan, say San Francisco or Chicago, which lag further along in the recovery?
That's a perfect one for Michael.
Morning, Floris. When it comes to acquisitions, I'd say your read is right — New York has been tougher, and with the cycle shifting, sellers are feeling a bit more upbeat. Even so, plenty of maturities still need to be worked through, and my sense is that will create opportunities over the coming year or two. So, yes. That said, whatever we target has to be the right asset for our portfolio — meaning it has to meet our quality standards. So I expect there will be some, though it'll be fewer rather than more. On San Francisco, we're constructive. We have faith in that market. I believe we've stayed consistent about that. The signals there look favorable. New leadership. The city is definitely turning a corner; so yes, we're open-minded when it comes to San Francisco. As for Chicago, we're happy with what we've got. I don't see us adding anything there. That market faces far more difficulties, and recovery is going to take some time; so adding there isn't our focus. And I don't expect we'll look past that.
Thank you, Michael.
Excellent. Thanks. I appreciate the detail you provided regarding the leasing pipeline and demand. I'm wondering — perhaps Steve or Glen — might you share some perspective on whether tenants are approaching you sooner to attempt to renew their space, simply because availability is so tight? And you've mentioned the leverage landlords hold on pricing. Given the demand you're witnessing, have you begun to notice any reduction in concessions?
Hello, this is Glen. Regarding demand, we're experiencing it across the board. Numerous expansions, many renewal conversations for deals whose expirations are still years away; and the near-term need for space from tenants who either are new to the market or wish to relocate right away is stronger than anything I've observed in a long stretch of years. When it comes to concessions, I'd say they're neutralized. By and large, they haven't decreased yet, but rents have risen. And that means conditions have improved; and as this market increasingly turns into one favoring landlords, concessions are going to decline.
To build on what Glen mentioned, there are a few dynamics at play here, correct? First, Glen brought up those expansions; we've been reviewing our pipeline over the past few days, and there are several tenants we signed leases with quite recently that have already returned seeking additional space. I believe that reflects a few dynamics that have taken place. One is that tenants showed a degree of caution when leasing space as they emerged from COVID, since they weren't certain how they'd utilize it or how much they'd require, right? And now they're all completely filled up, and they see they need more because of that. Second, as both Steve and Glen noted, business is thriving, right? Law firms are thriving, financial services are thriving, tech is thriving, and so on. So all these businesses are expanding. So when you combine both those dynamics, you have a very strong market layered on top of a very tightening supply situation in the locations where these tenants want to be; so I think that's why Steve made his comment regarding the expectation for rent growth over the next several years.
Thank you, Michael. I appreciate the extra color you provided there. Then, maybe just to follow up on what you said and your prepared remarks regarding the financing markets and capital availability. Clearly, we've witnessed additional transactions hitting the market lately. The CMBS market appears to have opened up more. Regarding the mortgages you folks have maturing this year, be it PENN 11, 888, those assets are extremely well leased. Do you have any sense, or could you perhaps offer some insight into where you'd anticipate the refinancing rate landing compared with the current interest rate? And any further thoughts on the debt capital markets generally would be useful.
Well, look, I believe if you consider where we stand now against where we stood, say, 12 months ago, I'd call it night and day; and we truly unlocked the market on the office side through the Bloomberg Financing. And after that, definitely when it comes to New York City, a floodgate of high-quality office has received financing. So consider the deals that have closed, a lot of them above a billion, and in a few instances, several billion. So I believe that demonstrates simply the appetite from fixed-income investors for top-tier New York City office. I find that quite encouraging; and so clearly, our portfolio is part of that. So when we look ahead regarding the financings scheduled to roll this year, look, we're exiting some low rates in a few instances, especially on a few fixed-rate deals. I expect we'll see rates tick upward there. Conversely, for something like a Union Square, appetite for top-quality retail is quite robust, and that could very well be lower. So on balance, I'd say it's likely somewhat higher, though we're also reducing leverage via some paydowns of the 770, and so on. So from Vornado's standpoint, I think we clearly absorbed some blows over the past couple of years as interest expense rose quite substantially. I believe by and large, we've finished with that entirely. Might it be somewhat higher this year? Perhaps. Might it be somewhat lower? Perhaps. I'd say we're roughly level year over year, and I think broadly the worst is essentially behind us.
Great. That's all I had. I appreciate you taking the time.
Good morning, and thank you for those questions. Steve, I'd say you've accomplished a tremendous amount with the various properties at PENN DISTRICT. You mentioned what amounts to the coming phase, or the following leap, toward stabilized NOI. From the perspective of the actual development work or the individual assets, I'd like to know: what comes next at PENN? In what order would you tackle the remaining parcels or the other redevelopment chances you hold?
Appreciate that question, Vic. That's something we're looking into right now. Our view is that within the PENN DISTRICT, we ought to have a single building or a pair of buildings underway and continuing ahead across the coming 10 years, though nothing is ready to be made public at this point. Clearly, the PENN 15 site just sits there, and in my view it's likely the finest site in Manhattan outside of Park Avenue. So that's plainly the following site; we're weighing every possibility for it. On the front portion of that site, an office building will definitely go up, but we're likewise looking at apartments too.
Understood. Then, just as a follow-up, regarding what you said about the office pipeline — could you provide a bit more detail on how street retail is changing on Fifth and Madison? Any insight into the tenants currently in that market, what's happening with pricing, and how that feeds into your leasing rates? Thanks.
Yes. Hello, Vikram. Regarding the retail pipeline, I would say that, just considering the market overall, it keeps getting stronger. Available space keeps shrinking, and for the top-tier locations, rental prices are, in my view, getting back to near their highest points. So, a major lease was signed by us in Times Square during the previous year. That submarket is seeing movement. To repeat, we hold the two finest blocks, and we are currently in active discussions at quite impressive rent levels, quite near the top for that area. On Fifth Avenue, the situation is similar when it comes to tenants seeking locations. I believe we have witnessed, at least following COVID, the greatest level of retailers exploring for space. Thus, I think things will accelerate. And once more, for the appropriate locations, I believe tenants understand they will need to pay rents that are quite near the top for that area, if not at the very top. The key point, and what is fueling all of this, is the revenue numbers retailers are achieving and the understanding that New York stays the worldwide city in America, possibly the best globally, and they must have sites here. We are near finalizing deals with certain tenants new to the market, along with some that already have a presence here. We keep experiencing solid activity across the PENN DISTRICT, and we are pursuing some leases in that location too; we feel fairly positive about the retail sector as well. We possess excellent properties, and those are typically where retailers concentrate their attention.
Let me share an anecdotal example. We own a significant property on Fifth Avenue. In fact, we hold quite a few there. But at one specific key building on Fifth Avenue, a large retailer approached us, fully aware that the existing tenant's lease would end in three years with no option to renew, and essentially said, "I want to commit to that space right now, and I'll simply wait until the current tenant's lease runs out." That kind of thing only occurs with truly exceptional real estate in markets where supply is tight. So it was somewhat amusing. Another point I'd make is that along Fifth Avenue, occupiers would rather purchase than lease. As a result, the prices buyers are willing to pay exceed what market rent would suggest. The arbitrage opportunity, then, is that selling certain of these properties makes more financial sense than leasing them out. And we are ready to do deals.
Thank you.
Thank you. Steve, you bring up often that you run this company with cash as the priority, and we agree with that approach. The funds available for distribution, or FAD, came in at $1.75 per share for 2024 — the smallest figure in no fewer than a quarter century, and likely even further back. I get that filling a large amount of space requires capital, but could you perhaps give us some insight into how healthy the New York office operation is, given that REITs such as yours are generating less cash than at any prior point, and given this 25-year pattern of FAD steadily declining. Have we reached a turning point? Should we anticipate that number climbing quickly? Will we return to cash flow levels similar to what we saw before COVID?
That's not a simple thing to answer. I know what's happening with this pattern. I know how much money our business requires. I know that we operate in the multi-tenant space. Everyone I work with across this industry is in the multi-tenant arena, where units get re-leased. I know what it costs when those units turn over, and all of that produces the pattern you brought up. So it's obvious — and Glen hinted at this too — that the TI and the incentives given to tenants to re-lease a floor inside a building are extremely sticky, and we're fighting hard to bring them down. The only way they come down is in a market that's very tight. That lies ahead for us rather than behind us. Conversely, when you examine the rents, they've already risen, which helps ease that issue somewhat. My expectation is that the cash — the real cash flow, or AFFO, or whatever label you prefer — has hit its lowest point in this cycle, and from here it will climb in a marketplace that I believe is going to become far tighter. That's my forecast specifically for New York. In my view, New York stands apart from the rest of the country. As wonderful as other cities across the nation may be, I don't think they'll enjoy the same upside from this trend.
All right, that's helpful. For my follow-up, I'd like to focus on the New York office and how in-place rent stacks up against market rent. It appears in-place rent sits at approximately $90 per square foot. Relative to that figure, where would you place market rents for the operating portfolio?
Hey, this is Glen. This is something we bring up frequently. On a quarterly basis, there will be fluctuations — sometimes flat, sometimes up. Our confidence remains that our markets will trend positive. I won't put a number on how large that will be, but we're pleased with our position when it comes to rolling expirations over the coming years, and we're pleased with the rents we're currently setting. As we've said, we've pushed rents higher broadly throughout the entire portfolio. So over the next 2 to 3 years, we feel good about that metric.
I won't hold back, and I'll make a forecast. Let's focus on PENN briefly, since that one's straightforward; we signed, as I recall, a fantastic lease covering 730,000 sq ft at the Farley Building right in the middle and the depths of COVID. When renewal time arrives for that lease, even though it's 11 years away, I think the market at that point will be considerably above the rent currently in place. I've stated before my view that PENN 1 and PENN 2, which we're quite pleased to get $100 or slightly more for today, will see market rents in the near term, three, four, five years out, climb very, very substantially. That's my take.
Thanks.
Incidentally, that's exactly what we're putting our money on.
Morning, Steve. To start, congratulations <<inaudible>> on the better yields at PENN and the favorable response you've gotten from the market. That really is a strong endorsement from the market for you folks. I have two questions. First one.
Alex, thanks, my friend.
No, that's correct. You took the time to guide us through it, and your capacity to reconsider within the campus setting is obvious. So it's nice to observe that rents are shifting in the direction you were expecting. My 2 questions are first regarding Alexander's, and I appreciate your remarks. What would be — I mean, at present, with so many of the original assets having been disposed of, and I'd imagine you could secure a strong price for the apartment tower in Rego Two, why not simply fold Alexander's into Vornado? You'd remove the G&A. Rather than distributing a dividend, that cash flow would build up for Vornado. You'd have 731, which definitely suits your portfolio. Why not simply absorb Alexander's into Vornado? What would stand in the way of that?
Nothing if not persistent; that concept has been raised for 20-odd years, and for 20-odd years I have stated we are not going to do that. And in fact, I likely will keep stating it now. Alexander's, how it's priced, how it would be combined, it's simply not something sitting at the front of my mind today.
Alright. What I'm saying is it requires cash, and for sure, now that you've been winding it down, it looks like an increasingly good fit, though I suppose we should discuss that separately.
No, hold on, Alex. How about I paint you a picture, alright?
Fantasy is something I enjoy.
Alright. I'm attempting to make you happy. Suppose we combined Alexander's with Vornado — honestly, I wouldn't know what price to set, or how to make both parties satisfied. That's extremely hard to pull off, right? On the other hand, imagine we kept Alexander's the way we intend to, which is exactly my point, as a standalone, independent, publicly traded company, and we trimmed it down until nothing remained except the Bloomberg office building. Before long, that building will generate roughly $100 million in net income, and if it were the sole asset held there, carrying very little debt, perhaps none at all — what price would the market put on it? My contention is that it would trade at a level far, far above where the stock changes hands today. Still, that's purely a fantasy.
All right. The next thing I wanted to ask, Michael, is about what you laid out and put together.
Wait, let me stop you there for a second. What I'm getting at, really, is that when you look at it in terms of value, our belief is that we're able to bring Alexander's value up past whatever amount Vornado would be prepared to hand over for it, and that the people holding Alexander's shares will, acting for Alex, that's the goal we're chasing.
All right. Michael, you clearly value the feedback regarding 25, and it does offer some context, though your team has laid out certain asset divestitures, the vacancy situation at 350 Park, and simply the leftover pieces of refinancing. On top of that, there's the capitalized interest — roughly $51 million tied to PENN 2, as I recall — which would disappear once those leases kick in. So when we look ahead at the coming two years, how much FFO net is leaving Vornado compared with the FFO that PENN is bringing in?
Yeah. I'd say this — look, like we've mentioned, there are a few factors. First, on the capitalized interest side, correct? We've discussed how that figure is smaller in the current year than it was a year ago, and PENN 2 will phase out during this year. That, I believe, explains why consensus has moved down as it should, and you can see it there. As for 350, once that drops away, our view is it won't move the needle much compared with the master lease we currently hold. At that stage, the asset will carry no debt. We'll receive capitalized interest on it. So it truly won't make much difference to the figures. So look, over the past year we've discussed the wins we've achieved, refilling 770, 1290, 280, and now bringing PENN up to lease; that will begin showing up somewhat this year, more significantly next year, and very substantially in 2027. So go ahead and project that however you like given what I just said, but I think that's the path you're on.
Okay. Thank you.
Yep.
Hi there, I've got a couple of fast questions for you. The first one concerns same-store NOI for New York office, which finished down 3.3%. When you look ahead over the coming two to three years, do you have any big-picture perspective on how that same-store figure might shape up given this kind of robust backdrop?
Ronald, those figures aren't right in front of me, and I'd rather not hand you something that's basically a rough guess and so forth, so let's take a look at it, and we'll aim to provide a bit more clarity on that front.
Absolutely. Circling back to the — my question on CapEx was similar, though perhaps I'll frame it differently. Considering roughly $250 million of CapEx outlaid during this year, including $72 million allocated toward first-generation space, do you have any views on how 2025 and 2026 might shape up? Will those figures decline? Will they hold steady? Any perspective at all on CapEx as we build out the model would be helpful. Thanks.
I'd say with CapEx, we nudged it somewhat, since it's an annual estimate at best, correct, regarding the timing of those payments, and that timing doesn't always correspond with when the lease is actually finalized. Yet we're aware of the leases currently underway. We hold an expectation regarding what we'll accomplish past that point. Thus I believe that mirrors the fairly robust leasing backdrop, plus a bit of base building capital; so a year ago, I'd say our projection was exactly right. Honestly, in most years we miss, since you're essentially making a rough estimate. So directionally, I'd say we remain in the same range. Honestly, 250 to 275 isn't all that far apart, correct? It simply depends on which space you wind up leasing in a given year and how much capital must be deployed across the portfolio past that. So directionally, I'd call that a fairly solid figure for this year, particularly given certain sizable leases currently being worked on at PENN and elsewhere. And once we move into the following year, we'll observe what remains. Still, I believe that figure will begin to decline as the portfolio refills.
That's useful, thank you very much.
Yes, thank you. Steve, you brought up that because of the cost or basis tied to the Hotel Pennsylvania site, that money is already sunk at this stage. Could you share what the price tag is at present for constructing something and going vertical, and also what level of yield you'd be looking for on that?
How much would you estimate construction runs? My son, who's just starting out in development, puts it at $1,900 per foot, excluding land, for a Class A building. I'm not going to argue with that.
On the yield side?
Alright, when you factor in land, you end up at a figure of $2,000, and I'm not sure, choose a figure, $2,000 to $2,500 per foot, roughly that kind of number. I'm not certain; then you apply a yield to it — what would you develop today given a debt market at 6%? Suppose you've got to achieve 7% or 8%, or roughly that, since equity carries more value than debt. So what does 7% multiplied by $2,500 give you?
175.
That figure, it's after taxes and operating costs have been accounted for, so what that tells us is this—if you were constructing a brand new building right now, the rent you'd have to charge would land somewhere in the high 100s. You're shaking your head. What's behind that head shake?
That's my take as well, and it explains why you describe it as being frozen. The numbers simply don't add up in that.
Just consider that for a moment. One factor behind my strong optimism regarding rental rates at PENN 1, PENN 2, and the remainder of our office holdings, with the primary figure sitting above $100 per square foot, is that constructing something new runs roughly $200 per square foot, possibly slightly under, possibly slightly over. Consequently, existing properties plus superior assets in prime spots are going to grow considerably more valuable. That captures the essential takeaway on those items. That is the takeaway for right now.
All right. That's the piece I was trying to get clarity on, since you brought up how, from where you sit, the expense up to now has already been incurred. So my read is that you're focused only on the additional spending and the impact it might have across the entire area, rather than dwelling on that $2,500 basis and what return it generates.
Right. The reality, though, is that the land belongs to me. I acquired that property quite a while back. There's no debt attached to it. So when we can either leave it vacant or put up a building, we'll decide accordingly. That's the job we're compensated to handle.
All right, that makes sense. Then I have one more quick question. I believe last year you acquired a non-performing B- note tied to a Midtown deal. Could you share anything new on it, or any intentions, or what’s going on with that?
No, sir. Sorry.
It's okay. Thank you.
Yes, thanks.
Thanks, that's helpful. Regarding the PENN project, could you share a bit about whether the sublease space currently on offer at Hudson Yards is proving to be competitive whenever tenants evaluate your development?
Hey Nick, Glen here. So, yeah, the response is affirmative, and when you really consider it, PENN 2 along with PENN 1 are going head-to-head against new inventory. That's a fantastic situation. And like Steve mentioned, the rates we charge aren't close to what they're asking, including the sublet rates. So we're pleased that whenever a tenant is checking out the west side—be it the sublet space available at Hudson Yards, Manhattan West, PENN 1, or PENN 2—we're right there in the thick of it daily. So that works for us. We find ourselves quite competitive with it and quite at ease with it.
All right, thank you. And thank you, Glen. As for my follow-up, let's return to the PENN 2 yield for a moment. Could you refresh our memory? My understanding is that when you give that yield figure, the cost basis being used doesn't factor in tenant improvements or leasing commissions. So, supposing we do include those, I believe I came across a note at some point indicating a TI and leasing commission expense of roughly $140 per foot. I'd just like to confirm whether that figure still holds. And once that's factored in, would the project yield, including those items, be nearer to somewhere in the 7.5%-8% range? Is that roughly accurate?
Yeah. I mean, the response is that they're going to run the numbers. I mean, I think the argument here is that those TI dollars for leasing commissions would have been spent by us regardless, correct? And usually, based on what's taken place, we'd be putting that money out to create rents that weren't economic at this point, considering how good the old building was. So we mentioned the incremental cost. That was money we laid out that otherwise wouldn't have been necessary, right? That's how we arrived at the figure you see in the supplemental. What kind of yield does that produce? So the response is we can take into account the TIs, and so on, to determine that, but that cash would have gone out either way.
All right. So regarding that TI leasing commission on a per-foot basis, should we figure it lands near $140? Would that be the figure?
It's about right, maybe a touch higher depending on the deal.
Okay. Thank you. I appreciate that.
Thanks a lot for taking my question. It seems that roughly 14% of ABR is set to expire at 555 California during the third quarter, with 18% expiring across the full year. Is there anything you can share regarding renewal talks? You sound optimistic about San Francisco overall. Could you provide a bit more clarity, please?
Hello. Hello; this is Glen. We continue to be very bullish on our San Francisco property at 555; it is the finest building in that city, likely in the state, and without question among the top in the nation. So if you look back starting from 2021 onward, we had an enormous amount, hundreds of thousands of sq ft, rolling off between 2021 and 2026. We have leased close to 700,000 sq ft so far over that stretch. Additional expirations are coming in 2025, and then more still in 2026. We are going after those right now. A portion of those tenants will remain. A portion might leave, but we feel terrific about our progress. Our rental rates are unmistakably setting the pace in that market. It is not even close. And our tenant roster remains five-star. So we feel terrific about 555 as we sit here.
Great. Perhaps just a single additional question about that. Regarding the 14% during Q3, does that involve a single tenant, or is it divided among several separate tenants?
In 2025's third quarter, or around then, several tenants have leases ending — roughly 5 or 6 tenants across the year, spread over various quarters. Not one of them is especially large, yet when you total it up, it reaches that figure.
Okay, that's great, thank you. Yeah, thanks — just a quick one as a follow-up. Regarding 770, Steve, I understand that lease isn't fully done yet, but it sounds like it will cross the finish line shortly. Given how unusual this is, are there any special accounting adjustments we should be thinking about? Or is it simply a standard long-term lease with straight-line rent, where we'd need to determine the GAAP rent and make straight-line adjustments? I know you're receiving a significant amount of cash upfront, but I'm just wondering whether there are any nuances here since this deal is somewhat different. I won't discuss that transaction; it's going to be final. In fact, it is finalized, but I expect it will be announced by the end of this month, so whatever we announce will come via press release, and we'll include all the details we need to provide so you can understand it. That said, you already grasp it, so I'd rather not dive into specifics at this point prematurely.
Okay. Thank you.
Yes, sir.
Thanks for letting me ask a follow-up. Steve, you talked about how there hasn't been much new office construction in New York for a number of years, and how difficult it is to make the numbers work at some of these sites. But in your view, how many projects are likely to break ground at roughly the same moment as 350 Park? A handful have been out there at different stages.
None.
So demand just isn't there?
That's not it—demand is abundant. The problem is strictly construction expenses. Where steel pricing is headed right now, I can't say; nobody really can. Those building costs, combined with rates that keep refusing to come down and the scarcity of bold financing, are going to leave this market stuck. That said, 350 Park stands apart as its own unique situation, since a major tenant's lease is already secured and a 60% capital partner is already in place. So 350 Park is going to move forward. What I expect is that virtually no other project will break ground—and, for that matter, PENN 15 could easily be among those, at least near term.
To make new construction pencil out beyond that, what level would rents need to reach?
That's a question I've already addressed. Two hundred dollars per foot is an intriguing threshold.
Understood. That's great, thanks.
I appreciate everyone joining us. Based on what our management team has said, you can probably sense that our enthusiasm for this business is enormous, our enthusiasm for New York is enormous, and our enthusiasm for the PENN DISTRICT is off the charts. So thanks so much to each of you for being here, and we'll talk to you again in three months.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Vornado Realty Trust transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.
Get an API key View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Vornado Realty Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server.
Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search,
and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.