Home / Transcripts / Vornado Realty Trust (VNO) · May 6, 2025

Vornado Realty Trust (VNO) Earnings Call Transcript

May 6, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Office REITs earnings 67 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Steve Borenstein executive
#1

Thanks for joining Vornado Realty Trust's Q1 earnings call. We put out our first quarter earnings release yesterday afternoon, and we also submitted our quarterly report on Form 10-Q to the Securities and Exchange Commission. You can find both of those documents, along with our supplemental financial information packages, on our website, www.vno.com, in the Investor Relations section. During today's call and in those documents, we'll be talking about some non-GAAP financial measures. You'll find reconciliations of those measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measures in our earnings release, our Form 10-Q, and our financial supplement. Please keep in mind that anything said on this call might be considered forward-looking statements, and actual results could differ materially from what's stated here because of various risks, uncertainties, and other factors. For more details on those risks and uncertainties, please look at our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2024. This call might contain time-sensitive information that's only accurate as of today's date. The company isn't undertaking any duty to update forward-looking statements. Joining us on the call today from management for opening comments are Steven Roth, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Michael Franco, our President and Chief Financial Officer. Our senior team is here as well and available for questions. I'll now hand the call over to Steven Roth.

Steven Roth executive
#2

Thank you, Steve, and good morning to all of you. Well, the macroeconomic conditions we're dealing with now are definitely not the same as they were when we last talked 3 months ago. A few office CEOs said on their calls that they didn't expect all of this to have much impact on their businesses, but it is going to affect our customers, our clients and our tenants. So naturally, it will have some effect on all of us. I don't have any more information than any of you do. But the way I look at it, the goals behind the tariffs are to bring about symmetry and fairness, and even more importantly, to create a new revenue stream for the federal government, which at, let's say, a 10% tariff is big enough to make a significant dent in bringing our federal budget deficit under control. And regardless of the tactics, lowering the government's burden has to be a positive thing and will also bring down the deficit. I remain agnostic. Whatever happens, my best guess is that this global turmoil will be resolved, settled and finished far sooner than you'd expect. The fundamental dynamics I described in my recent annual shareholders' letter, the ones that make us so excited about the future of our business, are still in place. Our stock performance leads the office class, having risen 49% in 2024 after a 36% gain in 2023. And although year-end is down 12%, our decline is smaller than that of the other CBD office companies. Manhattan remains the strongest real estate market in the country, particularly for office, but for apartments and retail as well. In the 180 million square foot Class A better building market where we compete, demand is still robust. Available space is disappearing fast, and given what a new build costs, meaning replacement cost at, say, $2,500 per square foot, with interest rates at 6% to 7%, no new supply is anywhere on the horizon. All of this is the very definition of a landlord's market. We've watched this unfold in prior cycles, and the story never changes. Supply and demand dynamics will drive rents up, and existing better buildings will gain value quite substantially, all good, very good. Here at Vornado, our teams have stayed very busy building liquidity and getting leases and deals done. In January, we closed the UNIQLO sale at 666 Fifth Avenue at a record-breaking $20,000 per square foot. We applied the $342 million of net proceeds from that sale to partially redeem our retail JV preferred equity on the asset. So $342 million in cash to Vornado. That cash went to paying off at maturity our 3.5% $450 million unsecured bonds. Then, last month, we closed a $450 million financing of 1535 Broadway and applied the $407 million of net proceeds to partially redeem our retail JV preferred equity on the asset. So $407 million in cash to Vornado, which lifted our cash balances. This financing got done in a very choppy market thanks to the skill and relationships of our capital markets team. So we owe them a big thank you. Moving on, on April 22 we got a favorable ruling in the PENN 1 ground lease rent reset arbitration. The panel decided that the yearly ground rent owed for the 25-year stretch starting June 17, 2023 will come to $15 million. Litigation is still pending, and under the panel's decision, should the fee owner win a final judgment, the annual rent for that 25-year term would be $20.2 million, applied retroactively to June 17, 2023. For GAAP purposes, we had been accruing ground rent of $26.2 million per year. So because of what the panel determined, we reversed $17.2 million of rent expense that had been over-accrued in prior periods during the first quarter. Worth noting, starting in the first quarter of 2025, we're now paying $15 million in annual rents, which means our GAAP earnings will rise by $11 million a year. Incidentally, this PENN 1 ground lease, with all extensions, runs through 2098. Then in March, we wrapped up a major 337,000 square foot lease at PENN 2 with Universal Music Group, the world's leading music company, think Taylor Swift and her friends. This important deal brings an exciting tenant into the PENN District and lifts the building to roughly 50% leased. Additional leasing at PENN 2 is on the way. Then yesterday, we at last announced the closing of an important deal with NYU at 770 Broadway, finalizing a master lease covering 1.1 million square feet on an as is triple net basis for a 70-year lease term. Under the lease's terms, a rental agreement under Section 467 of the Internal Revenue Code, NYU made a prepaid rent payment of $935 million and will also pay annual lease payments of $1.3 million over the lease term. NYU holds an option to buy the lease premises in 2055 and at the end of the lease term in 2095. NYU will take on the existing office leases and the related tenant income at the property. We applied a portion of the prepaid rent payment to pay off the $700 million mortgage loan that had previously encumbered the property, and $200 million to boost our cash balances. Even though this transaction is a lease under GAAP, which can be a little wacky, it is treated as a sale. Because of that, we will recognize a GAAP financial statement gain of approximately $800 million in the second quarter. We will keep the Wegmans retail condo, which will generate $4.7 million in income this year. The NYU lease absorbs 500,000 square feet that is currently vacant at the asset. All told, the transaction is accretive by $25 million annually. Had we pro forma leased the vacancy at market rents, factoring in related capital spend, downtime and free rent, it would have been a pro forma push, as you might expect. We are delighted to grow our relationship with NYU and congratulate NYU Board Chair Evan Chesler and President Linda Mills and their teams. We are excited about their ambitions for this project. Like I've mentioned previously, all of this benefits NYU greatly and benefits New York greatly. The press release NYU put out yesterday can be found at www.nyu.edu. In total so far this year, thanks to the activity described above, we brought our debt down by $915 million, grew our cash by $500 million, and our retail JV preferred equity, an asset on our balance sheet, which started the year at $1.828 billion, has now fallen to $1.079 billion. Cash balances stand at $1.4 billion now, and combined with undrawn credit lines of $1.6 billion, that gives us immediate liquidity of $3 billion. These transactions will boost GAAP earnings by roughly $36 million, with $25 million coming from the NYU transaction and $11 million from the PENN 1 ground rent reset results. Tom, that's Tom Cinelli, whom all of you know, in a more complete analysis, including debt repayments and the loss of preferred income, calculates $30 million of accretion I'm happy to defer the talk. Shortly, Michael will go through the quarter and the financials, but first here are some highlights from a very strong first quarter. Comparable FFO of $0.63 rose by $0.08 compared with last year's first quarter and comes in $0.09 above analyst consensus. Our overall GAAP same-store NOI climbed 3.5%. We signed leases for 1,039,000 square feet in total, with 709,000 square feet of that in New York office at $95 starting rents, mark-to-markets of 6.5% cash and 9.5% GAAP, and an average lease term of 14.7 years. Beyond the 337,000 square foot lease with Universal Music at PENN 2, we signed 163,000 square feet at PENN 1. We finished leases totaling 222,000 square feet at our 555 California office tower in San Francisco at $120 starting rents. 555 remains the preferred financial services headquarters in San Francisco. And even in this historically soft market, 555 keeps outperforming. It is proving itself the best building in San Francisco. We are big fans of the new San Francisco Mayor Dan Lurie. Our New York leasing pipeline is a robust 2 million square feet. As I said in my annual shareholders' letter released on April 8, the lease-up of PENN 2 and the lease-up of our retail vacancies alone will generate incremental NOI of $125 million and $50 million, respectively, over the next several years. Tom, here is Tom again, specifies that while NOI for PENN 2 is budgeted to increase by $125 million, FFO is budgeted to increase by $95 million, the difference being capitalized interest. Either way, these are big numbers and with PENN 2 built and ready, this $125 million per year is as close to a short thing as there is. The PENN District, our 3 block long city within a city continues to amaze and receive outstanding reviews. We sit on top of Penn Station adjacent to our good neighbors to the West, Manhattan and Hudson Yards. The 3 of us together represent what I refer to as Manhattan's new booming West side. One analyst of ours refers to the PENN District as one of the biggest mixed-use projects anywhere in the country, and be that as it may, for our company the PENN District is going to be a growth engine for many years ahead. As I wrote in my annual letter, we took market rents in the PENN District from $50 up to $100. Our neighbors on the West side are getting rents above $150, and I predict that in due time we will achieve the same in the PENN District. You can all do the math on what an incremental $50 across 4.3 million square feet will mean for our earnings and values. 350 Park Avenue, with Citadel as our anchor tenant and Ken Griffin as our 60% partner, has started the development process to build a grand 1.8 million square foot headquarters tower on the finest site on Park Avenue. The new building is going to stand out as truly best-in-class. And we have several other assets on the market for sale. We recently filed our very comprehensive sustainability report, which you can find on the sustainability page of our website. Vornado was first in the nation to achieve 100% LEED certification across our whole portfolio of in-service buildings. The many awards we have earned can also be found on the sustainability page of our website. Kudos to Lauren Moss and her team. Finally, one other observation I would make is that most of our secured loans reflect current market rates, while others are still living off their low-rate loans. As I have said before, there is really no protection against loans that mature into a rising rate market. Now to Michael.

Steven Roth executive
#3

On comparable FFO, we posted $0.63. That's $0.08 higher than what we saw in Q1 of last year, and it beats the annual consensus by $0.09. GAAP same-store NOI across the portfolio was up 3.5%. In total, we released 1,039,000 square feet. Of that figure, 709,000 square feet was New York office, with starting rents at $95, mark-to-market of 6.5% cash and 9.5% GAAP, plus an average lease term of 14.7 years. On top of the 337,000 square foot Universal Music deal at PENN 2, we leased another 153,000 square feet at PENN 1. Over at 555 California, our Road Officer Tower in San Francisco, we wrapped up leases amounting to 222,000 square feet, with starting rents of $120. For financial services headquarters in that city, 555 is still the top choice, and despite how soft this market has been historically, the building continues to beat expectations — it's turning out to be San Francisco's finest property. San Francisco's new mayor, Dan Lurie, has our strong support, and a pipeline that keeps growing now sits at a healthy 2 million square feet. During my April 8 annual shareholder letter, I mentioned that filling PENN 2 with tenants, along with leasing our retail vacancies, by itself will produce additional NOI of $125 million and $50 million, in that order, across the coming years. Tom — that's Tom once more — points out that although PENN 2's NOI is budgeted to rise by $125 million, FFO is budgeted to rise by $95 million, with capital interest accounting for the gap. Incidentally, those figures are substantial, and since PENN 2 is finished and ready, this $125 million annually is about as near to a 4 — is about as near to a short thing as anything gets. The Penn District — that's a three-block stretch, a three-block lawn city inside a city — keeps drawing praise and getting fantastic feedback. We're positioned above Penn Station, right next to our wonderful neighbors at West Manhattan, for a hundred yards. Together, the three of us form what I describe as Manhattan's new booming west side. An analyst on our team has called the Penn District among the biggest mixed-use developments anywhere in the nation. Regardless, for many years ahead it will serve as a growth engine for this company. In my annual letter I noted that we pushed market rents in the Penn District up from $50 to $100. To our west, neighboring properties are pulling in rents above $150 per square foot, and my expectation is that we'll match that figure once the bankruptcy runs its course. Everyone here is capable of calculating what adding another $50 across 12.3 million square feet means for both our profits and our property values. At 350 Park Avenue — where Citadel serves as the anchor tenant and Ken Griffin is our partner going forward — work has started on the development process for a magnificent 1.8 million square foot headquarters tower, situated on Park Avenue's finest parcel. This new structure is going to distinguish itself as genuinely best-in-class, and beyond that, we currently have a number of additional assets listed for sale in the market. We just submitted an extensive sustainability report, and you can locate it on the sustainability section of our site. Yet ours was the first in the country to earn 100% certification throughout the whole portfolio of its service business. All the honors we've received are also available on the sustainability information on our website — credit goes to Lauren Moss and her group. And finally, one more thing I'd note: most of our secured loans carry today's market rates, whereas others remain on their cheaper rate loans. As I've mentioned previously, there's truly no shelter from loans that come due into a market where rates are climbing. Now over to Michael.

Michael Franco executive
#4

Thank you, Steve, and hello everyone on this call. Comparable FFO for Q1 landed at $0.63 per share, compared with $0.55 per share during the equivalent quarter last year, which works out to an $0.08 improvement. The main factors behind this rise were a favorable ground rent reset ruling at PENN 1, plus greater signage NOI and increased NOI tied to rent commitments — although those gains were partially counterbalanced by anticipated tenant departures and lower interest and investment income. You can review a bridge comparing this quarter to the prior one on Page 2 of the earnings release, as well as on Page 5 of the financial supplement. On our last earnings call, we shared that comparable FFO for 2025 would likely finish a bit under the $2.26 per share comparable FFO recorded in 2024. Since the ground rent for PENN 1 ended up below our earlier projection, our current expectation is that comparable FFO for 2025 will be roughly unchanged from the prior year. Looking beyond that, we anticipate that leasing momentum at PENN 1 and PENN 2 will reach its complete beneficial effect during 2027, producing notable earnings expansion by that year. Turning to occupancy: office occupancy in New York declined during the quarter to 84.4%, down from 88.8% the quarter before, which matched our expectations and, as previously mentioned, stems largely from PENN 2 entering full service. With the master lease for the entire building at 770 Broadway now finalized, office occupancy currently stands at 87.4%, and over roughly the coming year we anticipate a gradual climb into the low-90s. Momentum in New York's office leasing market remained robust throughout the first quarter, which recorded the highest quarterly volume since the fourth quarter of 2019. In the top-tier Class A segment, available space keeps contracting, and given that only 500,000 square feet of new construction is expected to be delivered across the next several years, alongside 13 million square feet of office-to-residential conversions either underway or announced, we anticipate continued tightening in the market, laying the groundwork for significant growth in rental rates. Sure, we're keeping in mind that with the market as volatile as it is right now, businesses might start being more careful when making decisions. Even so, our view is that for the majority of tenants, this won't change their final choice to sign for space, and when it comes to the market and the pipeline of deals throughout our portfolio, we continue to feel quite positive. Good illustrations of this are the big commitments made recently — NYU at 770 Broadway, Deloitte at Hudson Yards, and Amazon at 522 Fifth Avenue. In the first quarter, our leasing volume again came out on top in the market; we closed 31 deals amounting to 709,000 square feet, with an average starting rent of $95 per square foot and positive mark-to-market of 6.5%. The biggest new lease signed in the market during the quarter stood out as the highlight of our activity. At our new PENN 2, Universal Music Group has taken 337,000 square feet, with the building's base—floors four through seven—serving as the anchor. This transaction has us thrilled, and we can't wait to see Universal build a world class office and studio production headquarters in Penn District. What this deal demonstrates is just how strong the new, modern, top-tier workspace in the project really is, and it proves that our robust work-life amenity offerings across the Penn District campus continue to draw people in. Turning to PENN 1, leasing there remains healthy — during this quarter, 163,000 square feet was signed. That included Cisco renewing for 61,000 square feet, UnitedHealthcare relocating into 36,000 square feet, and Dish Network taking a new lease for 27,000 square feet. Our pipeline of deals at PENN 1 and PENN 2 looks really solid, with all sorts of new transactions already in lease documentation, which points to deepening intensity. If you set aside the master lease we just wrapped up with NYU at 770 Broadway, our New York pipeline has 2 million square feet of leases under negotiation at different proposal stages. Over in San Francisco, on California Street at number 555, we completed two major headquarters transactions — one a renewal, the other an expansion — involving Dodge & Cox and Goldman Sachs, and each produced positive cash mark-to-markets. Ever since we signed leases for 657,000 square feet at 555 back in 2022, that property has been outperforming the market by a wide margin. This tower stands as the city's premier office building, occupied by world-class tenants, and it has been leased with remarkable success in what has ranked among the nation's hardest-hit markets since the pandemic arrived. Even so, conditions are finally beginning to improve. The incoming mayor has made an excellent beginning. We believe he will fulfill his role in restoring the city's health and vibrancy. Finally, on to the capital markets. In the first quarter, CMBS was wide open for big, high-quality assets like ours, and spreads kept tightening. After the President unveiled his new tariff policy on April 2, the financing markets turned quite volatile — spreads widened and new issuances got pushed back. Even with that turbulence, we managed to finish our 1535 Broadway financing. We think the market will calm down soon, and that high-quality issuers and assets will keep having access to it; we're working hard on refinancing or extending our upcoming maturities, with plenty already underway. With that, I'll hand things to the operator for Q&A.

Steve Sakwa analyst
#5

Thank you, and good morning to everyone. Michael, I wanted to see whether you might provide some detail on that 2 million square feet — I believe it involves lease discussions at PENN 1, PENN 2, plus the remainder of the portfolio. I suppose I was hoping to revisit what Steve mentioned during the prior quarter regarding PENN 2 sitting at 80% leased, and simply get a clearer picture of how much activity is underway, especially at PENN 2.

Michael Franco executive
#6

Morning, Steve. Why don't you kick things off, and then I'll jump in.

Glen Weiss executive
#7

Hey Steve, Glen Weiss here. Of that 2 million pipeline, roughly 50% comes from PENN 1 and PENN 2 right out of the gate, and there's a ton of exciting stuff happening at PENN 2. Universal is done, as you know, and there's still more in store, while PENN 1 keeps filling up with new tenants, and even with all of that underway, we're still pushing rents higher week after week. So PENN is genuinely in its fifth year. It accounts for a large share of the pipeline, though not the entire pipeline. Across the portfolio, performance is really strong at the moment, so we feel extremely good about where things stand throughout the whole portfolio.

Steve Sakwa analyst
#8

And I suppose, how confident are you that PENN 2 will reach that 80% mark by the time this year ends?

Michael Franco executive
#9

Well, Steve, here's my take — sitting here right now, our feeling on it remains positive, correct? If it lands by December 31, in Q1, or whenever, as Steve mentioned during his opening comments, that building is going to get leased, correct? By and large, we will reach the figures we set forth. That's a big jump upward. And if it comes one quarter sooner or one quarter later, from where we stand, that won't move the needle in any real way. So we will arrive there. As for the rents, the ones we will secure, just like we shared three months ago, they are larger. Glen launched the pre build initiative at PENN 2. The rents we are getting there are phenomenal. We might expand that effort somewhat. Therefore I wouldn't fixate on whether it lands precisely at year end. Still, yes, as we sit here right now, our confidence stands exactly where it did during last winter.

Glen Weiss executive
#10

We're reducing our spot position in this case. When you consider it, Steve, quality blocks available on the market are shrinking, and there's nothing being shown that compares to what we accomplished at PENN 2. Therefore, we believe that even if we exercise greater patience, rental rates will continue to climb; tenant quality will continue to improve; and as a result, our confidence keeps growing as we move forward on the whole.

Steve Sakwa analyst
#11

All right. And perhaps as a quick follow-up — I believe Steve said something, though I'm not sure I heard every part of it, regarding 350 Park. What I simply can't recall is where you've landed on whether to move ahead completely or not proceed at all with that project. So could you walk us through the kinds of milestones, and perhaps the achievements, that you either need or would like to observe in the market before you finally reach that call?

Steven Roth executive
#12

Steve, good morning. What we've put out regarding the specifics you've raised is quite thorough, so please revisit the 10-K along with the press release. In my view, that's the finest approach to take.

Dylan Burzinski analyst
#13

Hello everyone, I appreciate you fielding my question, and congratulations on getting the NYU deal done. Steve, I believe you said that once every transaction has closed — so we're looking at quarter end — the balance sheet holds roughly $1.4 billion in cash. Could you perhaps walk us through what some of that money could be set aside for?

Michael Franco executive
#14

Of course. Good morning, Dylan. Before anything else, I'd like to praise that report you put out. In my view, nobody captured 770 as well as you did. So well done to you and your colleagues. It was, all things considered, very insightful. As for the cash, we're…

Steven Roth executive
#15

What that means is that he likes a report. Go ahead.

Michael Franco executive
#16

When it comes to cash, we're clearly happy with the progress we've made; we've accomplished a fair amount. Those are our big, sizable deals. When you consider it, we've managed to reduce leverage on the balance sheet significantly while still holding onto that considerable cash position, correct? So we're sitting in a really strong place. What do we intend to do, right? In a climate such as this, where there's plainly a bit more volatility, keeping more cash on hand, we hope and anticipate that will create some chance to move some of that cash into investments, and we're exploring. Simultaneously, we have certain debt with higher costs that we could either reduce or eliminate. So I believe you'll witness a mix of a) keeping it in cash, as has been our pattern, to ensure we maintain a suitable cushion for anything. Two, address some of that debt, and then three, ideally put it to work in new opportunities that come our way.

Steven Roth executive
#17

To go a bit further on that, we're putting money aside to retire an unsecured bond maturing in one year and a fraction. We're building up cash since we'll have a strong development pipeline at 350 Park in the Penn District, and possibly an additional site we control. Having that cash is beneficial, and we intend to deploy it toward expanding the company.

Dylan Burzinski analyst
#18

That's useful, and I appreciate what you had to say about the report we put out last night. I suppose, maybe just one more follow-up — clearly you folks have succeeded at monetizing part of the press and at selling off certain assets inside the sure retail joint venture. I suppose I think during the prior quarter you folks hinted at having further dispositions or wanting to go out and carry out further dispositions. I suppose could you perhaps discuss just how much appetite some of these luxury retailers have and their wish to keep owning the real estate rather than leasing the real estate.

Steven Roth executive
#19

So I believe I mentioned this in my letter. I made known in a quite understated manner that certain buildings situated outside of New York are possibly available for sale at the proper price; that remains the case; these are a few very large assets; so we shall see how that goes. In Manhattan, we hold a few non-core buildings that are currently on the market for sale and I think, as I stated in my letter, no towns are sacred. Then the other matter is we have demonstrated a readiness to sell certain of these important retail assets whenever we find a buyer prepared to pay a suitable price. That is still so. What's interesting is it isn't only the retailers that are purchasing these assets. For instance, Amazon is stepping in and purchasing significant assets in Midtown Manhattan for, I guess, their HQ3 or whatever it may be. So there are plenty of examples of certain larger companies, which are changing their strategy from leasing over to buying and that's a positive thing. We know that is occurring aggressively in New York. I don't know whether that holds true across the rest of the country, but for New York and for the New York real estate market that is a very positive thing.

Dylan Burzinski analyst
#20

Great. I appreciate the color, and congratulations to the team, thanks.

John Kim analyst
#21

Could I just ask a follow-up regarding real estate valuations? On the assets you're potentially looking to sell, whether in New York or elsewhere, we've seen high street retail sort of return to 2019 levels; and including 555 Cal, will we return to 2019 valuations or go above them?

Steven Roth executive
#22

Sure.

Michael Franco executive
#23

I'd like to piggyback on Steve's remarks, John. When you consider everything we've accomplished up until now—I'm not sure any of those assets were ever officially listed for sale, correct? Our approach has been to seek out the appropriate counterparty in a deliberate, opportunistic manner. That remains largely true today. Conditions in the capital markets keep getting better when it comes to selling. Yet you have to determine which buyer or investor fits best. And I believe this cycle has demonstrated once more that top-tier properties fetch top-tier pricing, correct? Quality always prevails. It might fall out of favor temporarily, but with patience—if you endure the tough period—it will bounce back, correct? That was obviously true with street retail. I believe the same applies when you examine certain financings and the values they suggest for New York office, and definitely for the marquee properties in San Francisco. So by and large, quality always prevails.

Steven Roth executive
#24

Sure — one word sums it up. What I really meant by that is we won't unload excellent properties at bargain-basement values caused by COVID or anything like that. So our reference point is 2019, before COVID, and these properties have bounced back, they're still bouncing back, and as time goes on they'll fetch higher and higher prices.

John Kim analyst
#25

That’s helpful detail. Thank you. Regarding the leasing pipeline, which rose quite a bit versus the prior quarter, could you break down how much comes from your in-service portfolio, or from leases that might lift occupancy during the coming 2 years, compared with maybe 350 Park or an early renewal that would not affect SSL?

Glen Weiss executive
#26

Without question, a very substantial share of that pipeline will raise occupancy; so much of it is absorption, many new transactions, many expansions—there is considerable expansion across our New York properties at present. Therefore, a great deal of our meaningful activity will take up empty space during the next 9, 12 months, without a doubt.

Steven Roth executive
#27

Occupancy just got mentioned for the first time during this call. So could someone address occupancy? The figure we gave out for occupancy is unusually low, and let's see whether we can bring an accurate picture of the occupancy we anticipate into this discussion.

Michael Franco executive
#28

John, building on what Steve said, my sense is we'd signaled over the prior two quarters that occupancy would decline, and we placed PENN 2 into service, which we completed entirely during this quarter, correct? Thus, we reported 84.4%. We discussed the pro forma figure once you include 7.70%, which brings it to 87.4%; and afterward, in my remarks, I noted our expectation of 90% plus within roughly the next 12 months; and clearly, much of that is fueled by PENN 2. I think when we look more widely across New York, if we lease up PENN 1 and PENN 2, or at the point we fully lease PENN 1 and PENN 2, and suppose that, that, that occurs within the coming 24 months, plus a few items here and there, we'll land at roughly 94% occupancy; so I can't give you a precise date for when that will occur. Yet if you simply consider, if we execute on PENN 1, PENN 2, a small amount of space, 1290, 280, we'll reach that 94% mark, and we're very fond of that position, correct? So from our perspective regarding generating growth, we hold our finest assets, which currently contain some vacancies. The market offers fewer alternatives. We've recently invested a substantial amount of capital into these assets. Glen mentioned how rents are climbing, not merely across the market, but particularly at these assets. And so all of that will convert into growth; and I think, as we've noted on the past few calls, that truly takes hold in 2027. So we're pleased with where we stand and, from an occupancy perspective, we historically operated the business at approximately 95%, 96%. And I think once we're a couple years out; what we anticipate is that we'll return to that level.

Glen Weiss executive
#29

What you should focus on above all else is that when occupancy goes up, earnings go up too, and the increase is substantial. That's a really noteworthy point.

John Kim analyst
#30

Yes, good stuff. Thank you.

Glen Weiss executive
#31

Yes.

Floris van Dijkum analyst
#32

Hi there, good morning, everyone, and thanks for fielding my question. I'd like to return to what you mentioned regarding the Penn District — one of the nation's most valuable mixed use projects.

Steven Roth executive
#33

Who made that claim?

Floris van Dijkum analyst
#34

I'm not sure. That point came up from someone. With any luck, it got your attention. One thing that's obviously quite striking is the $300 million of NOI once PENN 1 and PENN 2 reach stabilization. But could you address something we picked up on this quarter, and my guess is it will also apply across the coming couple of quarters — namely the GAAP figure. There's approximately a $20 million GAAP gap between GAAP NOI and cash NOI, presumably reflecting free rents at these — at PENN 2, as it comes online before you actually collect the real cash. How long will that persist? And eventually, when do you expect things to inflect, in your view, so that cash NOI turns out to be stronger than your GAAP NOI going forward?

Glen Weiss executive
#35

Yes, Floris, I'd say that's an excellent question. My sense is we should likely handle that one offline. The bulk of it will occur in the later years, as Michael pointed out. We begin to see 2027 earnings really take off. So those are probably the years you'll witness, though that's a matter we should probably discuss offline with more detail.

Floris van Dijkum analyst
#36

Thank you. Moving to my next point — honestly, I believe there are times you harm your own cause through just how open you are, especially regarding occupancy figures. Has it ever crossed your mind to disclose what occupancy looks like for your core, in-line, or in-service properties? It's clear you're currently holding a handful of assets empty, notably within the retail portfolio, and those weigh heavily on the occupancy number you report.

Steven Roth executive
#37

That idea has come up, Floris, but what you've just said pushes us to consider it more seriously, since yes — certain properties have been taken offline and will stay that way while awaiting redevelopment or, in one or two instances, a workout. So your point is valid.

Floris van Dijkum analyst
#38

Appreciate it, everyone. I've got nothing further.

Steven Roth executive
#39

Much appreciated.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#40

Morning, good to see everyone down there. Steve, one thing I wanted to ask about — when you look at that Deloitte transaction, 800,000 square feet anchoring a brand-new development is really something. How do the numbers on that project stack up against what you'd require at PENN 15? I'm just trying to get a sense of whether we're getting nearer to a point where a project of $2 million or more can actually pencil, or whether the market still only supports what you'd call million two type developments.

Steven Roth executive
#41

Morning, Alex. Before we get into any of that, you wrote a piece on Alexander's that came out, I believe, yesterday.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#42

Right, that was yesterday.

Steven Roth executive
#43

Honestly, as far as I can tell, you're the sole analyst I'm aware of who follows this. That said, let me step in and point out two corrections. First, we will not — and I want to stress that word, not — apply our cash toward paying off the 731 retail loan. That's simply not happening.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#44

All right, we'll make a note of that. That's something we'll keep in mind.

Steven Roth executive
#45

Then the other point is this — Alexander's is not being folded into Vornado, all right? So after we secure the Oscar, we move past that stage. Look, when we presented the Deloitte transaction, every developer in the city was doing the same thing. In our view, we hold the finest empty parcel on Manhattan's west side. I've often remarked that I consider it the number two piece of land in the city, with the top spot going to our Park Avenue site; therefore, the agreement reached was extremely favorable for the tenant. The pricing came in very tight. We're not about to reject a deal that fails to deliver the financial outcomes our shareholders deserve. So we're making progress, and we're at the early stages of a landlord bull market, and we believe values and prices will rise as transactions occur. We expect the supply of new construction to be quite limited. So we think we're sitting in a rather strong position. We're patient — just consider what occurred with the Alexander's transaction, which happened quite a while back, yet even so, we allowed that deal to slip away until we completed the Bloomberg deal, which proved to be remarkable. So we're making progress, and we're quite pleased with where we stand.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#46

All right.

Steven Roth executive
#47

One thing worth noting is that a significant portion of this stems from how strong we are financially. Given where we stand money-wise, we're able to wait things out somewhat; the PENN 15 lot therefore carries zero debt. Zero debt sits on the PENN 1 building. Zero debt sits on the PENN 2 building. Zero debt sits on the Farley Meta building; that's a rather favorable position for us. And it isn't — essentially, the way we've built our business is that we operate like a secured lender. Those properties carry no debt, and that's an excellent position to occupy.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#48

Okay. Let me follow up on that. You put out a Chairman's letter, which is something you do every time. In it, you mentioned how appealing apartment projects are, partly due to their smaller scale. But when you consider certain laws that Albany has enacted, the numbers get harder for tax incentive deals as projects get larger. So when you evaluate our apartment opportunities, are you looking at as-of-right locations? Or smaller-sized projects? Or what's your view on how apartments fit in as you broaden your thinking on development and monetizing your various sites? Are these current sites, new sites, what are your thoughts?

Steven Roth executive
#49

You know, when you've got the kind of city down at PENN that we've got, you must weigh both office — we're mainly an office company. We enjoy the dynamics of the office business; we enjoy them as they're getting better now. But you can't ignore the fact that, looking back across the past decades, apartments have generated more value than office. The office market is volatile across more periods of time, the apartment markets are very — are less volatile. Even so, the political dimension of the apartment business is far more complicated than the office business. So there's a bit of this, a bit of that, and we will be constructing some apartments in the Penn District. It won't be an entirely apartment development project.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#50

Thanks, Steve.

Steven Roth executive
#51

Thanks, Alex. And keep in mind, that cash isn't something we're settling in full.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#52

I plan to pass that message along to my colleague Connor.

Jana Galan analyst
#53

Thanks, and good morning. Congratulations on a solid beginning to the year. One notable recent development in New York City appears to involve a sort of owner-occupier activity, in both the office and retail segments. I was simply wondering whether you might be able to offer some perspective on what you're observing, especially regarding certain of the dispositions you might be considering pursuing.

Steven Roth executive
#54

Much of that, I believe, we've already addressed. Mike, I'll take another crack at it.

Michael Franco executive
#55

Appreciate that, Jana. So here's how I see it: on the owner-occupier side, in retail, we've discussed how that trend reemerged during the past 12 months, and that's where the activity showed up first. You had Prada, you had Caring, you had UNIQLO, and interest in that space hasn't faded. I'd call that a function of — and all of those were on Fifth Avenue, though a few situations also popped up down in — take what Ralph Lauren just did in Soho, a meaningful figure for that store, and Dyson down in Soho. What these retailers are essentially telling you is that in those great forever locations — Fifth Avenue, SoHo, Madison Avenue, Times Square, the sort of core districts of Manhattan — they intend to stay permanently, correct? The sales volumes they generate in Manhattan are multiples of what they achieve anywhere else in the U.S., and often anywhere else globally, so they want to be there permanently. And instead of haggling with the Vornados of the world every 10 or 15 years, they'd simply rather own the property, right? And they're willing to pay a meaningful figure to control it forever, so that's a positive. We've picked up some additional income from that, and if the right numbers come along on certain situations, we'll do a deal. But that remains an area where retailers stay active; on the office side too, you've seen some owner-user activity; and again, let's return to what's driving that, right? I believe Steve drew the distinction that we truly haven't witnessed that in other places. Perhaps it's happened, but I don't think it's happened at this volume; and my view is it's fundamentally about talent wanting to be in New York, right? And that's really propelling every asset class. So Alex, to your question, how do you get the math to work? On these larger sites, the math does work. Setting aside your remark about the 99, the math works. Why does it work? Because rents keep climbing; we have an enormous housing shortage in New York City. It won't be solved within the next decade. So anyone building apartments will likely do just fine, all right, the backed off. So talent wants to be here. Employers have no trouble getting their people into the office. This is where all the young people want to come. And so they're essentially holding their ground. And in many of these companies' cases, they borrow more cheaply than real estate counties that are cheaper than any companies for that matter, and they're putting that capital to use, right? So with Amazon, where they've ramped up significantly here lately, they want to be here. Their intention is to expand in this market, and they'll leverage their balance sheet in a forceful way because, once more, they see themselves as a permanent presence here, plus the volume of money they plan to put into their properties beyond what a typical landlord would contribute is substantial. So their goal is to hold it indefinitely. Consequently, when you consider NYU, the university didn't acquire the property from us, yet it made a commitment to rent it over a lengthy period, which allows them to spread out the funds they'll invest into that property. As a result, they possess control over that property for the long haul. So will this be a weekly occurrence? Most likely not. Still, I doubt this will be the final instance of such deals, since for corporations with considerable capital that can be spent in a cost-efficient manner, it's an effective answer.

Jana Galan analyst
#56

Thanks.

Seth Bergey analyst
#57

Hello, and I appreciate you taking my question. So, from what I'm hearing, demand seems to have gotten better. The pipeline for leasing has increased — what kinds of shifts in behavior are you noticing among tenants? For instance, is there any easing on concessions or more activity in early renewals, on top of the rent increases you're observing?

Glen Weiss executive
#58

Hey, this is Glen. For sure, rent growth is happening. That's the primary topic. Rents are rising, and tenants understand that rents are rising. Second, we're beginning to observe a decrease in free rent packages. Regarding TIs, they've abruptly, let's say, stayed at essentially the same levels. So I'd say rents are getting better and free rents are beginning to decline. When it comes to early renewals, we're absolutely seeing folks approach us sooner these days since they worry about where the market will head, increasingly toward a landlord's market; so we have certain bigger deals in this pipeline when it comes to early renewals, no doubt; but I'll tell you, the single key point I'd share is expansion. The expansions in New York — there are expansions happening throughout the entire market in each submarket and certainly within our portfolio; so significant growth in New York, and not only financials, you're now seeing tech expand, law firms expand, consulting firms expand, media, entertainment, such as the Universal deal; so I mean that's essentially the gist of what you're asking.

Seth Bergey analyst
#59

Yes, thank you — that helps. For my follow-up, I'd like to return to what you said regarding how capital-intensive office buildings are compared with apartments. It seems like there are pluses and minuses for both asset classes, but does that shift the way you approach portfolio investment over a longer horizon?

Michael Franco executive
#60

Well, I believe the direction it points you in is toward owning top-tier properties — the very best ones, correct? The reason is that those properties are the ones seeing demand, the ones where you have the most room to raise rents, and the ones where you'll begin to reduce some concessions. That's happening right now, and our view is that it will keep happening. So capital isn't something you can sidestep, correct? Even if TIs decline somewhat, each time you roll those spaces over — every 10, 15 years of a tealeaves — there will be significant capital needs involved. That means rents must climb for this to work as a suitable investment, and that points you toward the better-quality properties. So I think what we've aimed to accomplish over the past several years is to reconfigure our portfolio: disposing of assets we saw as poorly positioned for what's ahead, and holding a portfolio we believe is well set up for that. Are we fully there? No, but we're quite near, and we're pleased with the progress. And that, I think, is where you need to be putting money — we've modernized our assets. We're in the right locations. My view is your portfolio must lean in that direction to win, given what the capital requirements demand.

Steven Roth executive
#61

There are a few points I want to make. We anticipate that rents will go up. As the market gets tighter, we anticipate that free rent will begin to appear. Cash TIs, in our view, won't be coming in, since tenants are actually spending far more than that to build out their space; so base rents and free rent will improve — rent and free rent, that is — while cash TIs, we don't think, will get better; that's one item. As for how apartments and office are mixed, in our major development activities we are an office company, and office is what we will develop. In the Penn District, we will also be adding, I'd say, a not insignificant number of apartments. Buying existing apartment buildings is not something I think we'll do; some we have examined, but fundamentally, I believe we would be a developer of apartments, yet a reluctant buyer of apartments.

Seth Bergey analyst
#62

Great. Thank you.

Steven Roth executive
#63

Thank you.

Anthony Paolone analyst
#64

Alright, thank you. So, I suppose this is just a follow-up on a few of those inquiries regarding Penn District and apartments compared to office. I mean, what's your take on which project Vornado takes on next in the Penn District — is it apartments, since that's smaller, as opposed to PENN 15? Or how are we supposed to think about that? And similarly, what are your views on the federal government becoming involved in the planning for Penn Station and how that could affect you?

Steven Roth executive
#65

We aren't tipping our hand about what we're up to by revealing today what the blend of a public will be. We'll do that once we truly begin doing something — that's an actual project — and we'll inform the market. We've already stated that our focus is on completing a modest apartment project at Eighth Avenue and 34th Street on a plot of land, we — the smallest piece of demand that we possess there. So that's underway. Beyond that, we'll declare development starts when they begin. As for the matter of the federal government becoming involved in PENN, we believe that's wonderful. I'm going to hand that to Barry, since he enjoys discussing it. Please go ahead, Barry.

Barry Langer executive
#66

Hello, everyone. As all of you know, across the past few years we have devoted considerable effort to a number of public private partnerships aimed at improving Penn Station — be it the Moynihan Train Hall, the Walnut River, or the 33 Street consoles for a couple of new entrants, as we collaborate with the government building on Seventh Avenue. Anyone who wishes to keep putting money into Penn Station and to carry on the strong work we have already done, so that we can keep making the Penn Station we back even better.

Steven Roth executive
#67

Which is why, incidentally, when did you most recently take a stroll around the Penn District?

Anthony Paolone analyst
#68

This past weekend.

Steven Roth executive
#69

Oh, that's great. So I believe you'd share the view that the Penn District — that old notion of PENN being some kind of nice term — well, PENN as a messy, messy area is behind us. So if you're working down there these days, look at what we've accomplished along Seventh Avenue, look at what we've accomplished with those buildings, all the money we invested in the sidewalks, and Moynihan Train Hall is magnificent. That train hall is magnificent. The Long Island Railroad Congress as well; so the Penn District appears quite different now compared to how it looked 5 years back, and we take considerable pride in that. Anyone who'd like to step in and assist us in completing the work beneath ground level. Essentially, we hold everything above ground. So — however the government entities and the railroads control what's below ground, and anyone willing to assist us in repairing that, we support.

Anthony Paolone analyst
#70

All right, thanks. Just one more quick question — I might have missed it, and it could be in the queue. What's the par value left on the preps in the Fifth Avenue JV at this point, and what's the yield?

Steven Roth executive
#71

Roughly $1.050 billion, in round numbers. And the yield there is 5.5%?

Michael Franco executive
#72

Tony, it likely comes out to roughly 5%. It's around 5%, so Steve <<inaudible>>

Anthony Paolone analyst
#73

Okay. Thank you.

Steven Roth executive
#74

Yes.

Caitlin Burrows analyst
#75

Hi, good morning. Perhaps to start, I sense this has come up in a few forms already. Still, during your prepared remarks right at the outset, you noted that you didn't expect macroeconomic uncertainty to have an effect on leasing, so I was hoping you might expand on that—what exactly underpins that confidence? And if you can share anything more granular regarding patterns across 1Q, April, and now into May.

Glen Weiss executive
#76

As of yet, leasing has shown no effect. Naturally, though, we remain watchful. Deals are still getting signed, and we would be foolish not to keep it in mind and monitor it. Even so, up to this point, leasing has not been affected at all.

Michael Franco executive
#77

Caitlin, here's what I'd add to what Glen mentioned: when you consider the Amazon news, the Deloitte news, and the NYU news, all of those came out within the past couple of weeks. So naturally, companies and tenants know exactly what's happening, they're making choices, and they're still planning ahead. That doesn't mean every single deal will move forward, but I'd say there's a tendency toward things being somewhat volatile right now. And as Steve mentioned at the start, this will get resolved soon; when it comes to retailers, anyone sourcing goods from abroad is clearly seeing a bigger effect on their operations, correct? They're definitely going to hold off until they understand precisely what that — what it actually amounts to. So we've felt a small amount of impact from certain of those companies; I think Glen described it accurately. Up to now, not a lot, though you do need to keep it in mind.

Caitlin Burrows analyst
#78

Understood. All right. Then you all mentioned that some of this NOI and earnings is going to arrive across the coming 2 years, and your visibility is strong, though there will also be certain refi headwinds. So I was curious, when it comes to perhaps even what's left in 2025 and the maturities in early 2026, is there any kind of guidepost? Or what's your thinking on how large those refi headwinds might be? For instance, would you figure spreads stay like the ones currently in place, or do those rise too? Any thoughts there.

Michael Franco executive
#79

Yeah. I mean, listen, we — everything that's coming due is getting intense attention from the team. Around 45 days back, our feelings on the pricing were terrific. Clearly, that has widened somewhat since then. Even so, the market is absolutely available and execution is possible. As a result, we have several items underway that we're hoping to finish across the course of the coming — this quarter; so our confidence in getting all of it executed is fairly strong. I believe regarding — right now I'm going through the list in terms of pricing and amounts I think broadly, and I think as a reflection of the market, every one of these can be refinanced at par; now whether we decide to pursue that or not depending on pricing, that choice will be made once we get nearer. But the market backs the proceeds level because, once more, that high leverage at the outset; and I think it has to be handled asset by asset. Sometimes, we'll roll those over quite near to where they stand now. In other instances, for example, like an Independence Plaza, we're moving off a 4.25% fixed rate loan. Given that treasuries themselves sit at 4% today, that won't persist. So we'll see some coupon expansion there. In other instances, I think it will roll over quite near to flat. So — but all of that is sort of included in the guidance that we sort of discussed regarding where we thought we'd land this year and where really the following 2 years would be; so listen, we'll need to see where the markets stand at the moment we actually price the assets by the markets open, we expect to take these on across the coming 2 quarters. And overall, I think interest will rise somewhat but not by much.

Caitlin Burrows analyst
#80

Thanks.

Ronald Kamdem analyst
#81

Hi, just a couple of fast questions. First off, that occupancy path was genuinely useful. I'm just curious whether we might push that a bit further — should we anticipate that same-store NOI and similar metrics will likewise be picking up speed all the way into 2027, or do other factors come into play? Thanks.

Michael Franco executive
#82

Yeah. As far as 2027 goes, definitely, this year, we'll find out. I think, once again, it's roughly flat, like we discussed. So my sense is you won't see that happen this year; but my sense is that once — as the properties get leased up, that same path will be what we follow, yes.

Ronald Kamdem analyst
#83

Excellent. My next question concerns how you deploy capital. Could you remind us of the current order of priorities among development, redevelopment, share repurchases, and similar uses? Also, is there any news regarding the Hotel Penn site and a possible sale? Thank you.

Michael Franco executive
#84

Our approach is that we evaluate every opportunity and determine the best place to put that capital to work. And clearly, we would rather not use up realized dollar. Yet development takes a long time, correct? So certain items we are discussing now might move ahead; however, that money really won't be out the door for a number of years while you build that up. Regarding buying back stock, it isn't top of mind at present, we continue to view it as attractively valued, though it was — clearly, when we launched the program it was in the teens, which made it more striking. So that is — I would say right now, the priority is putting money into our current operations, be it fresh development or reducing some debt; and after that, as I mentioned, we are reviewing certain outside opportunities, and it's simply tough to estimate the likelihood that any of them will proceed at this point.

Ronald Kamdem analyst
#85

Thanks.

Nick Yulico analyst
#86

Hello, and thank you. Let's return to the NYU deal. From what I understand, you mentioned it adds $25 million each year; paying down the mortgage appears to generate a $35 million gain; could you explain what balances that out? And regarding NOI, how should we consider whether cash and GAAP accounting will differ moving forward?

Steven Roth executive
#87

That sounds like a Tom.

Thomas Sanelli executive
#88

Sure. I believe that figure is 35, and that includes the swap sitting at the corporate level. So that swap is being moved. If you take the swap out, interest expense tied to that asset comes to $47 million. Current NOI sits at roughly $49.50. That puts current NOI at essentially flat. Looking ahead, once you add the payment coming from NYU, the Wegmans deal, and interest on the 200-plus we're keeping, you land at approximately $29 million — which is the $25 million, $26 million Steve mentioned in the prepared remarks.

Nick Yulico analyst
#89

Okay. Thanks; that's very helpful. Just second question is on, I think you gave the lease number for PENN 2 at around 50%. Is it possible to get the lease number for PENN 1? I know it's 88% occupied. Is the lease number higher than that?

Glen Weiss executive
#90

It's the same number.

Nick Yulico analyst
#91

Great. Thank you.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#92

Hey, thank you for taking the follow-up. Steve, I realize you're probably not going to give the intimate details of the ground rent litigation; but from a big picture perspective, the arbitration panel agreed to $15 million, but now there's litigation pursuing $20 million. From a big picture perspective, can you help us understand how this works? I would have thought the arbitration panel was the final determinant.

Steven Roth executive
#93

Alex, it is. The arbitration — the litigation pending, that litigation will extend through appeals for who knows how much longer. By the way, we think we have a very good position there, but be that as it may. The arbitration panel addressed the question of which party—landlord or tenant—prevails in that proceeding. In the base case, where we come out ahead in the litigation, the $15 million figure stays in place across the 25 years. Should we lose the litigation, that $15 million turns into $20 million. So our position is quite favorable. Either way the litigation resolves, the values are already locked in. That's really all there is to it, Alex.

Alexander Goldfarb analyst
#94

Okay. That’s helpful. Thank you.

Steven Roth executive
#95

Yes.

Steven Roth executive
#96

Appreciate you all. This morning's discussion has been quite strong. Q1 turned out to be quite busy and quite productive, with plenty of positive developments. We can't wait to connect with you on the upcoming call, which is going to be — when is that again?

Steve Borenstein executive
#97

The fifth of August.

Steven Roth executive
#98

Our upcoming call falls on August 5, and we're looking forward to it. Hope your summer's been good up to now.

Operator operator
#99

Everyone, that brings today's call to a close. We appreciate your joining us. You're welcome to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Vornado Realty Trust transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Vornado Realty Trust earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.