Home / Transcripts / HCI Group, Inc. (HCI) · November 6, 2025

HCI Group, Inc. (HCI) Earnings Call Transcript

November 6, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Insurance earnings 24 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Matt Aldrich executive
#1

Thanks, and welcome everyone on this afternoon. Glad to have you join HCI Group's earnings call for the third quarter of 2025. If you'd like to follow today's webcast, it's available in the investor information area on our company site, www.HCIgroup.com. Before we get started, I want to remind everyone listening that this presentation, along with our answers to your questions, might include forward-looking statements issued under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Terms like anticipate, estimate, expect, intend, plan, and project, along with other comparable words and expressions, are meant to indicate forward-looking statements. Such statements don't promise future results and conditions — instead, they carry various risks and uncertainties. A number of these risks and uncertainties appear in the company's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. If any risk or uncertainty turns into an actual event, those developments might materially and adversely affect the company's business, financial conditions, and results of operations. HCI Group undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements. With all that said, I'll now hand things over to Karin Coleman, our Chief Operating Officer.

Karin Coleman executive
#2

Thanks, Matt. Hello, everyone, and I appreciate you being with us this afternoon; we're happy to share results for yet another quarter of solid performance, which mirrors our ongoing commitment to careful execution, growth that is profitable, and creating value for those who hold our stock. For Q3, the notable items are earnings reported at $4.90 per share and a net combined ratio of 64%. We have total shareholders' equity of $821 million, while book value per share has risen over 50% since the start of the year, reaching $63 per share, along with a 22% loss ratio, since Florida's weather has stayed favorable as we continue through what remains of the 2025 hurricane season; beyond those financial results, the quarter brought a number of other significant events. A campus of three buildings in Tampa that is owned by our real estate division, Greenleaf Capital, saw its tenant take occupancy, and now the whole campus has been fully leased; that gives us room to consider financing alternatives for the asset so we can maximize shareholder returns. In the quarter, Greenleaf also expanded its holdings by purchasing a new complex located in Pinellas County, Florida. We keep seeking out chances to produce durable, long-term value for our shareholders. And in September, Exio brought on a fifth carrier for its platform, marking its first carrier that is not controlled by HCI. Alongside those noteworthy wins, we have kept making solid headway on a number of other efforts during the opening months of Q4. During October, we took on more than 47,000 policies from Citizens without issue, which amounts to roughly $175 million in in-force premium; given how well October went, we have no intention of taking part in the December assumption from Citizens. Not long ago we signed a new credit facility with Fifth Third Bank, and it will substantially boost the credit HCI has available. Mark will share further specifics about that. And earlier this week, Exio finished its initial public offering successfully. We're enthusiastic about what lies ahead for Exio, and we expect HCI to stay a major shareholder in Exio for the foreseeable future. Mark and Paresh will offer more information in what they have to say. Going forward, we stay dedicated to producing robust earnings, compounding book value per share, and creating appealing returns for our shareholders. I'll now hand things to Mark so he can give more detail on our financials.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#3

Thanks, Karin. For Q3, pre-tax income came in at slightly above $90 million, and like Karin said, diluted EPS was $4.90. On a year-to-date basis, pre-tax income sits at $285 million. That's versus $167 million across the first nine months of the prior year — a gain exceeding 70%. Let's spend a moment on the loss ratio. In looking at Q3 of last year, keep in mind that Hurricane Helene struck during that quarter. Had we made an adjustment for it, last year's Q3 loss ratio would have come in around 25%; this year's Q3 loss ratio fell to 22%, which mirrors reduced claim frequency versus the prior quarter. The combined ratio for this quarter came in at 64%, which mirrors both the reduced loss ratio and reduced operating expenses measured against premiums. This quarter's combined ratio runs slightly below the 70% figure we've brought up on several occasions, since the loss ratio this quarter landed a bit under what we'd anticipated. Let's turn to the balance sheet for a moment, which keeps getting better. Cash and investments have risen roughly $334 million since the year began. Long-term debt now stands at merely $32 million. Shareholder equity, at well above $800 million, has nearly doubled from where it stood when the year started. Debt to cap has fallen to 8%, and book value per share has climbed over 50% since the start of the year, now above $63. Our robust balance sheet ought to keep giving our policyholders peace of mind, and our shareholders ought to feel reassured by how efficiently we deploy capital, given that our after-tax return on equity remains above 30%. That robust balance sheet has likewise let us secure improved conditions with our credit partner, Fifth Third Bank. As Karin noted, we just renegotiated our credit facility, and through that process we doubled its size, taking it from $75 million up to $150 million, while also freeing up all the real estate collateral that had backed it. To wrap up, this was one more solid quarter within an exceptionally solid year for the company. Every one of our operating ratios is trending better. The balance sheet keeps growing stronger; we're producing outstanding returns, and with the recent Citizens assumptions, we're positioned for further profitable growth. With that, I'll pass things to Paresh.

Matt Aldrich executive
#4

Appreciate that, Mark. Karin and Mark covered what happened during the quarter just ended, yet everybody on this call understands the headline event came earlier in the year — indeed, earlier in the current week. Over the past 2 years, we've been putting together an intricate series of moves aimed at starting to release the genuine worth of Exio, the insurance platform we built in-house and grew on our own. Throughout that process, HCI investors showed both endurance and backing. With Exio's IPO taking place earlier this week, that sequence's final stage is now behind us. Our attention has already shifted to what comes afterward, though it's worth pausing briefly to look back and, even more crucially, to put real numbers behind how much financial gain the Exio IPO delivers. HCI shareholders. Mark, could you walk everyone through the specifics?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#5

Okay. In the IPO that Paresh brought up a moment ago, Exio put out 8 million newly issued shares priced at $21 apiece, producing net proceeds of roughly $155 million. Beyond those 8 million shares, another 1.2 million shares could be sold through an overallotment, and I'm leaving that out of every figure I just gave. HCI sold none of its Exio stake in this offering. Our holding stood at 75 million shares prior to the IPO, and it stands at 75 million shares afterward. Given where our ownership sits, Exio will keep being consolidated into HCI's financial statements, exactly as we've always handled it, though a few effects will show up. One, in the earnings per share calculation, net income attributable to non-controlling interest will rise a bit, which means diluted earnings per share will come down a bit. Suppose the IPO had taken place at the beginning of Q3 — then diluted earnings per share would have taken a hit of under $0.15. Two, once we record the IPO in Q4, HCI's consolidated book value and book value per share will climb considerably, thanks to the net proceeds from the offering. Book value should rise by roughly $125 million, while book value per share should rise by roughly $10. We anticipate HCI's book value exceeding $1 billion by the close of this year, with book value per share nearing $80. Careful capital management and profitable growth have made this a tremendous achievement. Even so, that book value won't reflect any unrealized gains tied to the Exio shares we hold. Our Exio position amounts to 75 million shares, and their trading price is visible whenever you look, yet on our books they'll sit at under $3 a share, since they're effectively carried at cost. Pull out a calculator and run the numbers, and that gap turns out to be larger than HCI's whole book value. This marks an exciting transaction for shareholders of both companies, and we anticipate Exio's continued innovation, growth, and success. With that, I'll turn things back over to Karin.

Karin Coleman executive
#6

Thanks, Mark. So, as we bring this to a close, we feel really good about the way our businesses keep performing. HCI's insurance and reinsurance units keep expanding and turning in strong results. Our real estate holdings carry considerable embedded value, and at the same time they're producing meaningful returns, while our investment portfolio remains a key source of solid, steady income. Finally, it was great to see Exio complete a successful IPO earlier this week, since that transaction unlocked part of the intrinsic value of that company. But as Mark noted, we didn't sell even one share in the IPO, because we think this is only the start of a successful journey for that company. In short, we're very happy with HCI's results and with Exio's successful IPO as well. With that, I'll hand the call over for questions. Operator.

Amir Trebelsi analyst
#7

Hello, and thank you for allowing me to ask. I'm Amir, filling in for Mike. My question concerns Citizens. Could you provide us with an update regarding the 75,000 policies that you applied to remove from Citizens across each of the three subsidiaries? To put it differently, out of those 25,000, what number do you anticipate writing? And then, regarding Homeowners Choice, what average policy size do you expect for those takeouts? Thank you.

Karin Coleman executive
#8

In that October takeout, I believe we had 47,000 policies altogether.

Paresh Patel executive
#9

We applied for 75. We got 4.

Karin Coleman executive
#10

Okay, so we put in for 75, yet what we ultimately received was the 47,000 that's referenced in the script.

Paresh Patel executive
#11

That's how many. I think Homeowners Choice got about.

Karin Coleman executive
#12

It's 19.

Paresh Patel executive
#13

19,000.

Karin Coleman executive
#14

19,000.

Paresh Patel executive
#15

19,200 — my mistake. Homeowners Choice came in at roughly 19,500. Terra was at approximately just above 19,000. TypTap reached slightly more than 8,000.

Amir Trebelsi analyst
#16

That sounds excellent. One final item from me. Could you provide any insight into how you anticipate deploying cash held on the balance sheet across the next several years, whether for Homeowners Choice, a more aggressive push into additional states, or possible M&A activity? Thanks.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#17

This is Mark. I don't believe we're in a position to be overly precise, though in my prepared remarks I did discuss our solid capital standing. The underwriters also hold a very healthy surplus. Without going into too much detail, our growth this year came in around 15%. Plenty of expansion opportunities lie ahead of us in the year to come, and grow we will. The capital needed for that is in place. 2026 will be a strong year.

Amir Trebelsi analyst
#18

Thanks.

Mark Hughes analyst
#19

Right, thanks. Good afternoon. Mark, what's the amount of cash sitting at the holding company?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#20

At the close of September, I believe total liquidity for the holding company came to roughly $285 million.

Mark Hughes analyst
#21

Alright. So what's the reason for skipping the December takeouts? October went really well for you. Why not aim for additional ones the following month?

Paresh Patel executive
#22

That's a fair question. The truth is, in my view, Citizens is contracting at this point. As far as I'm concerned, Citizens no longer holds the top spot among insurance carriers in the state. Its position has fallen considerably. Once December arrives, I won't claim there will be an insufficient number of policies available, but my sense is we have far more; our attention has already shifted toward opportunities outside Citizens, and continuing to say you're returning to a source that has essentially run dry felt like something of a diversion. Had you been after Citizens policies, honestly, the right moment would have been 2 years back, and that's exactly what we did.

Mark Hughes analyst
#23

Yeah, yeah. The expense ratio came in pretty strong for the quarter. G&A and other operating expenses both declined. Was there anything one-time in this period, or is it simply leverage?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#24

No. I mean.

Mark Hughes analyst
#25

A fresh administration?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#26

Yes. I appreciate you asking that, Marcus. Mark, what I'd say is there is absolutely nothing out of the ordinary during Q3. What we're seeing is simply a carryover of the themes we've discussed previously—namely operational leverage and how much technology matters. We've managed to expand while barely bringing on additional staff, and that produces relatively flat operating expenses even as revenue continues climbing. Revenue rises 13%. Operating expenses barely move. That's precisely the operational leverage we've referenced for some time. There is nothing at all unusual in Q3.

Mark Hughes analyst
#27

Yeah. As we consider how to model the Exio impact along with the minority interest, basically, we're taking into account the 8 million shares from Exio's earnings; those get removed as minority interest. Looking ahead, when determining what basis to use for calculating minority earnings, we need to consider the ratio between Exio and HCI earnings. Do you have any rules of thumb or suggestions for us as we think that through?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#28

Yeah. I mean, Mark, it's fairly simple, once again. It's fairly simple. Take, for instance — and on the call I offered some sense regarding the 15 cents, slightly under that. That's the impact had the IPO taken place on July 1. Had it been fully reflected in Q3, the effect isn't very large. Consider that even in the press release, there's an earnings per share calculation, and in that small section we subtract minority interests for several companies, Exio included; that figure would be a little — that figure would be — it wouldn't be double what it is; it would be slightly under that. You simply perform the calculation the way you ordinarily would. That negative $2 million shown in the press release. If you'd like a rule of thumb, just say multiply it by 2; and that's how you calculate EPS. It's fairly simple.

Mark Hughes analyst
#29

All right. I'm guessing the queue document will have this itemized, but can you share the net income figure for Exio compared with Homeowners Choice?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#30

That information will show up within the segmented report contained in the queue, which comes out tomorrow.

Mark Hughes analyst
#31

Yeah. All right. That sounds great. Is there anything you can share regarding the Exio pipeline? Perhaps just an update on how that business is doing. I completely understand if there is nothing you can say or are permitted to say right now, but is there any information about the pipeline of business growth prospects for Exio that you are in a position to provide?

Paresh Patel executive
#32

Yeah. Mark, this is Paresh. My thinking is that moving forward, we will attempt to make this call focused on HCI and essentially on how HCI views its ownership stake in Exio, rather than on pipelines and talking about Exio matters, since Exio is now a public company, Exio will soon be hosting its own quarterly earnings calls, and so forth, and that is where all of those items will be addressed. That said, here is a very straightforward point. There remains an outsized level of interest from people wanting to join the Exio platform. As I understand it, they have already made an announcement that a second customer has been secured, though that happened after Q3 had ended. The pipeline has to begin somewhere, and from that point it expands, and it appears to be expanding in a very healthy manner.

Mark Hughes analyst
#33

That's great. I appreciate it, and I get where you'd rather take this from here.

Paresh Patel executive
#34

Thanks.

Mark Hughes analyst
#35

Mark, I’ll squeeze in just one more question here. Mark, on the loss ratio — 25% this quarter versus 22% last year excluding Helene — how much of that came from weather or mix? Could you expand a bit on what drove that improvement?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#36

No. What I’d say is the weather stayed quite consistent. Conditions were relatively favorable. When you compare Q3 of last year with Q3 of this year, it really came down to frequency. Claim frequency declined. It was, as I recall, 3.7% annualized, 3.7% during the third quarter a year ago, and 3.4% in the third quarter this year. That is what pushed the loss ratio down. There’s genuinely nothing else at play, just. Lower claim frequency; and weather wasn’t — I mean, weather is always present, but weather didn’t play a role either direction when comparing one quarter with the next.

Mark Hughes analyst
#37

Yes, got it. That's great. Thanks a lot.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#38

Thanks.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#39

Mark here. Right, so the figure Karin provided — that's essentially the annualized premium, or premium in force, whatever term you prefer. Regarding what portion of it remains unearned, that corresponds to the cash we'll receive and what gets written in Q4. Roughly $150 million.

Mark Hughes analyst
#40

60%.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#41

Yes, that's right. At this point, roughly 60% of that figure. After that, naturally, regarding the way it will be recognized, it will simply be recognized uniformly across the following period. When it comes to modeling earned premium, the $175 million is the thing — the $175 million is what counts, not what portion of it is earned versus unearned in Q4. The $175 million is what you have to model. All right. You mentioned 60%? Yes. That's roughly it. That's fairly typical. Understood. Yes. 60% of the $175 million. That's what's unearned. Great. Thank you so much.

Karin Coleman executive
#42

The whole management team and I want to express our gratitude to our shareholders, our employees, our agents, and above all, the people we insure, for standing by us as we begin the next stage of expanding our business. Thank you.

Operator operator
#43

Thanks. That brings today's call to a close. You're welcome to hang up now, and we appreciate your joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HCI Group, Inc. transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to HCI Group, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.