Home / Transcripts / HCI Group, Inc. (HCI) · May 6, 2026

HCI Group, Inc. (HCI) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 6, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Insurance earnings 24 min

What were the key takeaways from HCI Group, Inc.'s May 6, 2026 earnings call?

HCI Group, Inc. reported a strong first quarter for fiscal year 2026, with a 15% increase in pretax income to $115 million and diluted EPS of $5.45. Total revenue grew by over 12%, driven by significant gains in investment and other income. The company maintained a stable loss ratio of 20% and a combined ratio of 57%. Management highlighted a robust balance sheet with stockholder equity doubling to over $1 billion. Guidance was not explicitly updated, but management expressed confidence in maintaining current performance levels.

What topics did HCI Group, Inc. cover?

What were HCI Group, Inc.'s May 6, 2026 results?

HCI Group's strong financial performance and strategic initiatives position it well for continued growth. The robust balance sheet and active share repurchase program are positive indicators. Investors should watch for developments in reinsurance placements and potential new ventures akin to Exzeo. Risks include market conditions in Florida and timing of strategic acquisitions.

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Nathaniel Otis executive
#1

Thanks, and good afternoon, everyone. I'd like to welcome all of you to HCI Group's First Quarter 2026 Earnings Call. If you want to follow today's webcast, it's available in the Investor Information section on our corporate site, www.hcigroup.com. . Before getting started, I want to use this moment to remind those listening that the presentation today, along with any answers we give to questions, might include forward-looking statements under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Terms like anticipate, estimate, expect, intend, plan and project, plus other comparable words and expressions, are meant to indicate forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements aren't guarantees of results and conditions in the future; instead, they're subject to a range of risks and uncertainties. Certain of those risks and uncertainties are spelled out in the company's filings with the Securities and Exchange mission. If any risk or uncertainty turns into an actual event, those developments could materially and adversely affect the company's business, financial conditions and results of operations. HCI Group disclaims all the obligations to update any forward-looking statements; with that said, I'll hand the call over to Mark Harmsworth, Chief Financial Officer.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#2

Appreciate that, Matt. Hello, everyone, and thanks for making room in your day to be with us on this call. We delivered yet another outstanding quarter. Compared with the identical period a year ago, pretax income rose 15%, landing at $115 million, while diluted earnings per share came in at $5.45. It marked our strongest first quarter on record, as we keep expanding the top line, the bottom line and return on equity. Gross premiums earned were up a little more than 8%, which captures the complete effect of the assumptions we finished in 2025. Total revenue climbed just over 12%, driven by substantial gains in investment income and other income. That other income improvement comes from revenue produced by Exzeo and Griston, a non-HCI business. Our loss ratio for this quarter stood at 20%, roughly matching the first quarter of last year and mirroring ongoing low claims and litigation frequency; the combined ratio is something we've been discussing for quite some time. Given where the business stands, our target for the combined ratio is <<inaudible>> with a margin of plus or minus 5%. Across all of 2025, the combined ratio came in around 57%, and once again it was 57% this quarter, which speaks to the caliber of our underwriting and the efficiency of our operations. Now let's spend a moment on the balance sheet. Thanks to rising earnings and disciplined capital management, the balance sheet keeps getting stronger. Stockholder equity has doubled in only the past year, now exceeding $1 billion. We hold just under $2 billion in cash and fixed-term securities. Book value per share has reached almost $85, and our debt-to-cap ratio sits at only 6%; beyond that solid consolidated balance sheet, the underwriters are in better shape than they've ever been. As I noted before, gross premiums are up roughly 8%, yet total surplus has increased 22% over the last year, reaching well above $0.5 billion. The gross leverage ratio now stands below 2.5, which leaves ample capacity for further growth without requiring surplus — for new capital, pardon me — and provides extra protection should a storm hit. We also carry substantial surplus in Claddaugh, giving us a great deal of flexibility for our upcoming reinsurance program. As you're aware, we announced a buyback plan in March, authorizing us to purchase as much as $80 million of stock, and we've been actively repurchasing shares under it. By the close of March, we had drawn $17.5 million of that authorization, repurchasing roughly 110,000 shares. Since the first quarter ended, we've kept repurchasing shares. And by the end of April, we had reached a cumulative 239,000 shares bought, having used approximately $37.5 million out of the $80 million. Regarding holding company liquidity, we have just under $200 million available at the HCI level; that figure excludes the 75 million shares we hold in Exzeo, which are now publicly traded. When it comes to Exzeo, even though our book value per share sits at just under $85, which is quite strong, I want to point out that no unrealized gains from our Exzeo stake are reflected in that figure. Were the fair value of Exzeo plus the real estate portfolio factored in, pro forma book value per share would come to just about $145; what that tells us is we trade at merely around 10% above book value, all while producing record earnings and a 35% after-tax return on equity. To close out on the quarter, it's been yet another outstanding one for the company. HCI had a record year in 2025, and this year's first quarter was even stronger. Revenue is climbing, margins are widening. We're producing record cash flows, carry very little debt, and are delivering excellent returns on capital. With that said, I'll pass things over to Karin.

Karin Coleman executive
#3

Thanks, Mark. We couldn't be happier with how 2026 has begun. Across the last 5 quarters, we averaged over $5.60 per share, and when we entered the second quarter, we had $1.3 billion of premiums in force distributed among 4 carriers. One thing worth highlighting: more than half of the Citizens takeouts we completed in 2025 came from Tailrow, our second reciprocal exchange. Tailrow now sits in a strong position moving forward, with in-force premiums exceeding $120 million. Each of our 4 carriers is now profitable from inception, and the most recent 2 got there within a span of 12 to 15 months from inception. My reason for mentioning this is to highlight our company philosophy. In making strategic decisions, we act with purpose and precision. Execution matters enormously in our business; put differently, getting an insurance carrier off the ground isn't all that hard. Building one that turns a profit, and doing so in a fairly brief period, is far harder and demands experience, skill, and a bit of finesse. Along those lines, I'd like to share that during the first quarter we licensed a new reinsurance company called Fortex Reinsurance, domiciled in the Cayman Islands as a Class B insurer, which becomes our second reinsurance company and provides us with even greater flexibility to selectively retain risk and lower the cost of third-party reinsurance. As you may remember, our other reinsurer, Claddaugh, is domiciled in Bermuda and has proven very advantageous in our reinsurance placements. On the subject of reinsurance, HCI is in the final stage of the June 1 reinsurance placements. We won't disclose any specific details until everything is finalized, given that current market conditions keep improving. As Mark mentioned, on March 3 we announced the $80 million share repurchase authorization and went into the market right away on the 4th. We're open about our belief that HCI shares represent great value at today's price. Consistently high return on equity, strong earnings generation, a track record of value creation, and our technology platform Exzeo all give us compelling reasons for that confidence. Beyond earnings generation and value creation, HCI also offers longer-term optionality. Historically, we've capitalized on market dislocation, moving quickly to deploy capital when opportunities arise. An inflection point for our industry will come. Until then, we'll keep serving our policyholders well, deliver strong operating results, return value to shareholders, and seek additional ways to drive long-term growth in a measurable way. With that, let me hand things over to Paresh Patel for some final thoughts.

Paresh Patel executive
#4

Thank you, Karin. Mark and Karin have just taken a few minutes to discuss the company's current position. Allow me to recap. Our premiums continue to rise. Reinsurance is heading in a favorable direction. Our investment portfolio is producing returns, our loss ratio remains steady, we're delivering record earnings, and our balance sheet is solid and growing stronger. This enables us to accomplish 2 things simultaneously: repurchasing a slice of the company each month while also reinforcing the balance sheet. So why do we do this? Because our goal is to put money into a business at an excellent valuation, and it's a business whose every detail we understand. To put it plainly, we're investing in ourselves. At the present pace, we're repurchasing roughly 2% of the company each quarter. That means each shareholder listening today will effectively hold 2% more of the company when every quarter ends compared to what they held when it began. And we're accomplishing this using just a portion of our earnings. With what remains of the earnings, we're making our balance sheet even stronger. This is preparation for a brighter future, since sooner or later, an inflection point or an opportunity will present itself. And when that happens, we'll possess a highly robust balance sheet that lets us act swiftly and with tremendous ease. But what do we do in the meantime, until that opportunity or inflection point arrives? Mark described the value creation that Exzeo delivers for HCI shareholders. We took Exzeo from roughly an idea — from merely an idea — to a $1.5 billion valuation today. And what we're doing now is we're developing the next thing; we're examining 2 or 3 things that could potentially become the next Exzeo-like asset. We possess the resources needed to cultivate these ventures to their fullest potential. Results aren't always guaranteed; yet based on our track record, I'm extremely enthusiastic about what's possible; so that's the work we're doing, that's what we're awaiting with the inflection point. And simultaneously, we're purchasing valuable HCI shares. To sum up, each day we arrive at work understanding our mission if circumstances remain unchanged. We likewise understand our mission and our plan of action should conditions shift; and lastly, we're sowing seeds for the future over the long term; with that, I'll open the floor for questions.

Matt Carletti analyst
#5

I suppose this could go to either Paresh or Karin, and maybe we begin with something quite straightforward, which is simply this: could you bring us up to date on your view of the primary market in Florida — not reinsurance, but the primary market as it pertains to HCI and each of its carriers.

Karin Coleman executive
#6

Certainly; where HCI is concerned, our premiums have held steady relative to earlier quarters, and we expect that steadiness to continue moving forward.

Matt Carletti analyst
#7

All right, that's helpful. Then, Karin, you brought up launching a fresh reinsurer, and it sounds like a captive type of thing sitting next to a new Claddaugh. I suppose, setting aside where it's domiciled, why — could you shed a bit more light on the reasoning for setting up a new reinsurer rather than simply getting more out of Claddaugh?

Karin Coleman executive
#8

Absolutely; we currently hold 4 carriers, and in our view that optionality genuinely provides us an edge across varying market conditions. Consequently, we believe there's a chance for us to pursue something comparable in the reinsurance arena too, and perhaps gain some extra flexibility among those reinsurance carriers.

Matt Carletti analyst
#9

All right, that's great. And if I may, one final question, Paresh — toward the conclusion of your remarks, you mentioned possibly 2 or 3 opportunities similar to Exzeo. Could you share a bit more detail? Specifically, I'm wondering whether these are tied to insurance. Or clearly, HCI does more than insurance alone — you have real estate, you have a hand in several areas. At a sort of 30,000 foot level, how should we be thinking about this?

Paresh Patel executive
#10

Yes. Matt, we're keeping these discussions a bit vague on purpose, since ideas emerge and then fade, but what we're examining does relate to insurance — though I don't mean something like homeowners insurance in Florida. It's other insurance lines and/or additional parts of the insurance value chain as well. So the net we're casting is fairly wide, because growth isn't solely about repeating what we already do; it's also about being capable of doing new things. So we're considering it in terms of what will be required, what will hold value roughly a decade from now. Yes.

Mark Hughes analyst
#11

When you were stating the combined ratio goal, somebody sneezed right at that moment — what was that target again?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#12

Right, it's 60%, give or take 5%, and in Q1 we came in at 57%, essentially matching what we saw for the whole of 2025.

Mark Hughes analyst
#13

So Karin, regarding HCI premiums, you described them as stable, if I recall correctly. Does that cover every company in the group — TypTap, Homeowners Choice, and the rest? Or are you only talking about homeowners...

Karin Coleman executive
#14

The entire enterprise, yes.

Mark Hughes analyst
#15

All right. So considering the amount of capital available, can you still find chances right now for book rolls or M&A, or has this industry simply become so profitable that nobody's willing to do a deal while they're earning solid returns?

Paresh Patel executive
#16

Mark, the way I'd put it ties back to what Karin said regarding the inflection point — at some stage an inflection point will arrive for those sorts of transactions, and hurricane season is nearly upon us. Would you really want to grow by buying something as that approaches? That's presuming it were a Florida-type situation. Still, those are the sorts of factors that come into play here as well. An opportunity will come, a moment will come, correct? Yet you've got to pick your timing properly. Let me put it another way instead. Doing M&A the day after the storm is what we'd prefer, rather than doing M&A the day before the storm. One of those two creates far more headaches than the other, that's for sure.

Mark Hughes analyst
#17

Yes. How are you approaching the reinsurance renewals? It sounds like you might be keeping more risk, given the capital in Claddaugh and the Foretex. Would that be accurate?

Paresh Patel executive
#18

Yes, I believe the details of all of this will become clear once the reinsurance is placed, yes.

Karin Coleman executive
#19

Right. It's clear the reinsurance market keeps easing, so at this point I'm not sure we'd want to guess where it ultimately lands. But once things are settled — once our June 1 program is finalized — we'll put out a press release, probably within a few weeks.

Mark Hughes analyst
#20

All right. Yet I believe your comment was that it keeps getting softer, which comes across as you describing what's happening over the last few weeks.

Karin Coleman executive
#21

Right, and that's the reason we find ourselves roughly where we are at this point.

Mark Hughes analyst
#22

Yes. I realize Exzeo will hold a separate call of its own, but Mark, as they carry out their plans, what effect does that have on the P&L — specifically, the geography of the P&L — if their business is expanding? Which line items will see the biggest impact here?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#23

Well, other income — a significant portion of their revenue, on a consolidated basis, is going to come through that other income line. That's the reason I sort of called that out for this quarter, and naturally, earnings — still 80%, 85% of that ends up flowing through to earnings per share; but when it comes to revenue as they grow, other income is the line that will really — that's the one you'll watch rise. And it, I believe, tripled quarter-over-quarter, and that's the reason I sort of flagged that in my prepared remarks.

Mark Hughes analyst
#24

Alright; so I suppose this serves as our baseline, and as they carry out the plan, presumably it ought to climb from there, right. That works for me, I think. Thanks a lot.

Michael Phillips analyst
#25

Mark, I just want to confirm my understanding regarding the target combined ratio you mentioned. That 57% for this quarter — as you put it — was roughly what you achieved in 2025? So when you say target, first of all, you mean accident year ex-cat, is that right?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#26

Yes.

Michael Phillips analyst
#27

Alright. And when you mention target, are you considering that over a cycle, or over a longer horizon? Do you mean, hey, that's the goal for this year, maybe stretching into the next 18 months? But what sort of time frame are you referring to when you say that?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#28

Yes. What I mean is it's where we stand at present. I don't anticipate it shifting much. The factor that could nudge it somewhat is weather, clearly, correct? But for us at this moment, I believe that's a fairly solid target for the upcoming — definitely for this year.

Michael Phillips analyst
#29

All right. All right. That is exactly the point I was getting at with my question. So there's no worry about possible pressure on that, considering the current rate conditions — plenty of positive developments are occurring in Florida, yet rates are easing, so you don't anticipate any strain on that stemming from where rates stand?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#30

Well, Karin addressed that, I believe. When you examine what we charge on average for each policy at the close of Q1 and set that against 12 months earlier, it's essentially unchanged. And just as Karin indicated, looking across the entire book, we don't anticipate much movement there. So yes, I'd say — and clearly, that factor has been factored in whenever we discuss a projected combined ratio. What shifts things most is the loss ratio.

Michael Phillips analyst
#31

Yeah, cool; and then perhaps just one more, just shifting topics. You've — one of your fresh efforts was the E&S company <<inaudible>> company. Could you discuss that and sort of where you expect it to head in the near term? I believe that only began fairly recently last quarter, so I just want you to tell us where that stands.

Paresh Patel executive
#32

It keeps moving forward, right? One of the items we mentioned using that for is perhaps California or similar things. And California is a wonderful spot. have things keep developing over there. I think we just saw a few headlines the other day where policyholders are taking legal action against their prior areas for the losses in the California wildfires. All of these items sort of push you to make sure you do your homework and diligence before you step into that. So we're doing all those things, yes. .

Michael Phillips analyst
#33

So does that fall under the two or three items you mentioned you were working on? Or is it more of a final one?

Paresh Patel executive
#34

I wouldn't say it's among the three items we're discussing in that $1 million category, so to speak. This is one more thing we're doing, much like Karin's new reinsurer <<inaudible>>. It's simply another initiative we've got going, separate from the $1 billion asset creation efforts we're referring to.

Paresh Patel executive
#35

Appreciate it. The whole leadership group and I want to express our gratitude to those who hold our stock, the people who work for us, our agents, and above all, the customers we insure, for standing with us as we move into the coming stage of expansion. Thanks, and we'll be in touch before long.

Operator operator
#36

Much appreciated. That brings us to the end of today's session. You're welcome to hang up at this point. Thanks again for joining us. Enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HCI Group, Inc. transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to HCI Group, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.