Home / Transcripts / HCI Group, Inc. (HCI) · February 25, 2026

HCI Group, Inc. (HCI) Earnings Call Transcript

February 25, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Insurance earnings 30 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Nat Otis executive
#1

Thanks, and good afternoon everyone. I'd like to welcome you to the Q4 2025 earnings call for HCI Group. If you'd like to view today's webcast, it can be found in the Investor Information section on our company site, www.hcigroup.com. Before getting started, I want to remind everyone listening that this presentation and our answers to your questions might include forward-looking statements under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Terms like anticipate, estimate, expect, intend, plan, and project, along with other comparable words and expressions, are meant to indicate forward-looking statements. Such statements aren't promises of future results or conditions; instead, they carry various risks and uncertainties. Certain of those risks and uncertainties are described in the company's SEC filings. If any of these risks or uncertainties turn into actual events, those developments might have materially adverse effects on the company's business, financial conditions, and results of operations. HCI Group disclaims any obligation to update forward-looking statements. With that said, I'll hand the call over to Mark Harmsworth, our Chief Financial Officer.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#2

Thanks, Nat. Good afternoon, everyone, and I appreciate you making time to be on our call. As we shared in the earnings release, pre-tax income came to $144 million in the fourth quarter and $429 million for the full year. Diluted earnings per share stood at $7.25 for the quarter and $22.72 for the year. Gross premiums earned during the fourth quarter rose 12% versus the same quarter a year ago and climbed 14% for the full year. The gross loss ratio for the fourth quarter was 15.6%. Although that figure contains a modest amount of favorable development from prior periods, adding that back gives a normalized loss ratio of 17.5% for the fourth quarter and just 20% for the full year. Now for the past three years, claims and litigation frequency have kept declining, which has produced a loss ratio that has been lower in each successive year, showing the positive effects of the legislative reform as well as our disciplined underwriting. The combined ratio came in under 45% in the fourth quarter. There is some noise created by the Citizens' assumptions we completed in the fourth quarter. We booked some favorable loss development, as I mentioned, along with a few other items. Adjusting for all of that, the normalized combined ratio was below 60% for the fourth quarter. Let's shift to the balance sheet for a moment. Earnings growth, together with prudent capital management, has produced a fantastic balance sheet. Shareholder equity finished the year above $1 billion and has more than tripled in only two years. Book value per share now exceeds $80; that figure excludes any unrealized gains on real estate or on our investment in Exio. Including those, pro forma book value would be roughly $140 per share. Cash flow remains strong. Across the past two years, we've generated more than three-quarters of a billion dollars in cash from operations, and consolidated cash at year-end exceeded $1.2 billion. On holding company liquidity, we hold $175 million of liquidity at the HCI level. That does not include the 75 million shares we own of Exio, which now trade publicly; beyond the strong liquidity position at the holding company level, the consolidated surplus in the underwriters has never been stronger. We now have well over half a billion dollars of surplus in the underwriters. The gross leverage ratio is just 2.5, which leaves plenty of room for additional growth without needing new capital. Our strong balance sheet should keep providing comfort to our policyholders. Our shareholders should take comfort in how efficiently we use capital. Our after-tax return on equity over the past three years, a stretch that included three hurricanes, is above 35%. In summary, this has been another fantastic quarter and year for the company. Revenue is growing. Loss ratio and expense ratio are both coming down. Cash flows are at a record, debt is minimal, and returns on capital are superior. With that said, over to Karin.

Karin Coleman executive
#3

Thanks, Mark. In addition to the solid fourth-quarter financial results we reported, I want to note that HCI completed Exio's IPO during that same quarter. At present, HCI owns 82% of Exio's outstanding shares — a position valued at close to $1.2 billion in that company. Exio's platform is an enormous asset for us, and it places HCI far ahead of the curve as automation and AI integration transform the insurance sector. In the fourth quarter, we took on 47,000 policies from Citizens, amounting to over $175 million in in-force premiums. For the entire year, we assumed 60,000 policies from Citizens. By using the October assumption, we gained a strategic chance to fund growth for 2026 in advance, because we now enter the year already ahead of 2025 on in-force premiums; regarding reinsurance, we made the prudent choice not to lock in multiyear rates during recent treaty years or via cat bonds, expecting the reinsurance market to soften. Early indications are that this was the correct decision. At our June 1 renewal, we continue working with our reinsurance partners to obtain more favorable terms. Adding new business before the year starts, and employing expense levers to push more to the bottom line, provides us with greater flexibility and prepares us for future growth. Just a quick note that HCI has traditionally done well by capitalizing on periods when the market is unsettled and dislocated. Following record results in 2025, stiffer competition and a significantly reduced count of policies at Citizens could create pressure for other players in the industry that face tighter limits on expanding their operations. Under these conditions, we see ample opportunity for strategic acquisitions, though we need to stay patient while pricing rationalizes. We're likewise continuing to evaluate new markets for entry, places where our experience, expertise, and leading-edge technology distinguish us from rivals. To give you an example, we're keeping a close watch on what California is doing to overhaul its insurance sector, because we notice parallels between that market and the one where we've run a successful operation for a long stretch of time. Just to recap, HCI Group has made its way through extended periods of market instability, the country's greatest tendency toward state-level litigation, regulatory difficulties tied to Citizens' depopulations, and rivals offering rates below market, along with Florida's weather conditions that carry high risk. While we await developments, we're using the chance to put resources into our own company. We're wrapping up the details and anticipate unveiling a fresh buyback of $80 million in the next few days; we see this as M&A done in-house, since nowhere else can we acquire a business priced at our kind of discount while delivering return on equity that reliably tops 30%. With that said, I'll hand things over to Paresh for a few closing remarks.

Paresh Patel executive
#4

Thanks, Karin. You've seen the figures — as is clear, 2025 proved to be yet another phenomenal year for HCI. Those results didn't happen by chance; they stem from deliberate planning and disciplined execution. More importantly, they're sustainable going forward, and we believe we can build on them. As Karin noted, the assumptions we made late last year positioned us to keep growing in 2026, and there are also several other opportunities that could let us speed that growth up. The future looks bright. Growth can come organically. Growth can come through acquiring books. Growth can come by entering new markets. We've done all of this consistently across a long stretch of time. In the meantime, we're investing in ourselves via the share buyback program Karin talked about. Why are we doing this? We see it as a great chance to put money into a company with a superior ROE at a significant discount. On a personal note, I'm doing the same thing myself by exercising — as recorded yesterday, I exercised a number of stock options, because I want to raise my ownership stake in this great company. In closing, this was another impressive year for HCI, and I've said before that the best is yet to come, and I'll say it again: the best is yet to come for HCI. With that, we'll open it up for questions.

Mark Hughes analyst
#5

Yeah, thanks. Good afternoon. So how do you expect pricing to play out over the coming year? Obviously, these results are pretty strong. What does that mean for your rate filings?

Paresh Patel executive
#6

Yeah, Mark, this is Paresh. Yes, look, it's a highly competitive environment. The results speak for themselves. I think we'd already said in earlier quarters that, you know, rate increases are a thing of the past, right? Now it's just about holding rates and/or some easing of rates. What I'd tell you is that all of that has been completely predictable for almost a year at this point. All that will play itself out, as we already anticipated. What we're looking at is how to go up in much bigger increments than this, right? All of that stuff is really noise, and I say that in the context of, I think if you look back over the last three years, it's been years since we actually changed rates upwards, right? We've been doing everything we've been doing at a very steady rate; we hope to do that in 2026 and beyond. To put it simply, I think we sell a great product at a fair price.

Mark Hughes analyst
#7

All right. So when you mention a bit of easing, how do you figure that plays out over the book? I'm not sure whether you can offer any figures or ranges on that.

Paresh Patel executive
#8

As I recall, we said before that Homeowners Choice, beginning in January, had already cut rates by 3.5%, correct? Mark, go ahead.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#9

Mark, that's only on the Homeowners Choice book, and, I mean, I don't think.

Paresh Patel executive
#10

Down in Florida.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#11

As for Florida, I really don't see that having much of an effect on average revenue per policy, or on any metrics of that kind at the consolidated level, you know.

Mark Hughes analyst
#12

Is there any chance you'd need to give back any portion of that to policyholders—some kind of excess profit refund, that sort of thing?

Paresh Patel executive
#13

No, because I think... Look, we're in a fascinating situation right now. Three years back, the worry was: Is anyone going to make it in Florida at all? We kept telling people, "Relax, we've got this handled." Now, three years on, everyone acts as though sunshine is permanent and hurricanes are a thing of the past, correct? I think both of those extremes are somewhat overblown. Every discussion about growth, rates, all of it, can flip in an instant, you know, thanks to a single hurricane. It's occurred before, and in all likelihood it will occur again. That's something we understand; it's the reason our approach has always been disciplined and will stay that way.

Mark Hughes analyst
#14

Mark, if we look at net premiums earned — the $226 million for this quarter — would that be a reasonable baseline for 2026, or does that figure include anything unusual or one-time?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#15

There are a couple of ways to approach that, Mark. Karin talked about the assumptions we made in Q4. Those were set mid-quarter, on October 21st, I believe. So in Q4 you don't get a full quarter of premium. Of the roughly $45 million per quarter, I'd say about $35 million landed in Q4. That's one way to look at it. Gross premiums earned in Q1 ought to come in above Q4, since you get the full 90 days on those assumptions. Another way to look at it is that your starting point really is gross premiums in force, which are up roughly 11%-12% from the end of last year. If you go back and compare with the prior year, Q1 will be above Q1 of last year, and so forth. Those are the two ways to think about it, if that's helpful.

Mark Hughes analyst
#16

It does. Do you have any comments about the weather we saw in the quarter? When you mention a gross loss ratio in the high teens, is that also the case if the top line holds steady, or, from a pricing perspective, yeah, wind could blow, but is there anything about that gross loss ratio that could rise or fall over the next few quarters?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#17

Well, it was a loss ratio — the normalized loss ratio for Q4, as I believe I mentioned, came in at 17.5%. Weather was pretty uneventful that quarter. I wouldn't frame this as a weather story. As I noted earlier, our loss ratio has been declining steadily across the past three years. Certain quarters bring weather events; others do not. Taking the ten accident quarters since the legislative reforms essentially took full effect and viewing them collectively, our average loss ratio excluding catastrophes comes to roughly 20%. We regard ourselves as operating within a range of 20% to 25%, though we have sat at the bottom of that band for some time now — in fact, five of those last ten accident quarters came in below 20%. So, what's behind the better loss ratio this Q4 compared with the same quarter a year ago? Weather isn't really the driver. Whether you use X weather or with weather, the answer comes out the same. Sure, some quarters bring somewhat more weather and others less, but in that regard Q4 wasn't an unusual quarter. It had slightly less weather — this isn't a weather story.

Mark Hughes analyst
#18

All right. If I can squeeze in one more, Paresh, you brought up the possibility of buying books, you know, getting a bit more of a step function in your growth, maybe having to hold off until pricing comes into line. I mean, with the — is it simply too steep to pay right now, given the profitability in the state, or could there be deals available even today?

Paresh Patel executive
#19

Hey, Mark, before I address that, I was just going to add a bit to what Mark said a moment ago regarding the loss ratio and all the rest. What I think Mark is getting at now is that my earlier remark about our numbers that we're posting now looking very sustainable, right? Over a long stretch of time. The book we hold has been tuned so finely that it begins to feel highly predictable, highly consistent, and so on, since we've maintained a very steady portfolio. It isn't only about the figures we report; it gives us confidence regarding the quarters ahead, right? That matters a lot too, because, you know, we've been through plenty of periods when each quarter was uncertain — we have that working in our favor. As for growth and acquisitions or whatever, I think opportunities do exist out there. Naturally, there's a negotiated transaction between the buyer and the seller. At bottom, I think the main thing sitting in a bid-ask spread right now is that sellers view 2025 as an average year, while buyers likely want to average 2025 across the last four years and arrive at a different number; that will get resolved over the next few months, as you know — is 2025 repeatable? That will determine what prices would be for any purchases, et cetera, that might happen. Does that help?

Mark Hughes analyst
#20

It does. Thank you.

Paresh Patel executive
#21

Mm-hmm.

Matt Carletti analyst
#22

Hey, thanks. Good afternoon. Paresh, I’d like to follow up. Hey, how are things? I want to build on both of Mark’s questions. If I could begin with the pricing question and get a better understanding—you know, the answer you gave and some of the remarks in the opening about reinsurance pricing and what we’re hearing in the market regarding the potential size of savings. Would it be reasonable to think of it as margins being unlikely to face downward pressure when you combine those, and that it’s not out of the question that they could actually get better?

Paresh Patel executive
#23

Yeah, I believe that's the conclusion we'd reach—agreed. It's clear that reinsurance pricing is easing too. As you work through all of this, how much pressure on margins will actually materialize, well, I don't think it's as severe as many people worry.

Matt Carletti analyst
#24

Sure, that’s clear. Let me ask one more thing about M&A. As we consider possible acquisitions you might evaluate, should we be focusing on Florida homeowners, or should we take a wider view—perhaps either A, opportunities beyond Florida, or B, areas beyond homeowners?

Paresh Patel executive
#25

Yeah, Matt, I'm actually going to toss a curveball your way with that question, all right?

Matt Carletti analyst
#26

All right.

Paresh Patel executive
#27

During Mark's prepared remarks, he mentioned that once you take into account what we hold in Exio as well as our real estate, things that tend to get overlooked now and then, book value-

Matt Carletti analyst
#28

Uh-huh.

Paresh Patel executive
#29

— it's $140. Insurance operations account for $80, correct? Through non-insurance activities, we've built up $60 in book value, so to speak. Right?

Matt Carletti analyst
#30

Yeah. Yeah, very fair.

Paresh Patel executive
#31

And-

Matt Carletti analyst
#32

Yeah.

Paresh Patel executive
#33

Yeah. As far as M&A goes, I want to make things clear to everyone about our thinking here, and I do need to give everybody the forward-looking statements note — these are my aspirations. What we've done through the years is that we always examine wherever we stand and ask, how do we become three times bigger, or three times the size, right? Ultimately, what this comes down to is how do we triple the share price from here? Because obviously, earnings call, we're trying to do right by our shareholders, the people who trust us with their investments. We are sitting here looking at it and saying, "How do we triple our share price from here?" Because that is.

Matt Carletti analyst
#34

Mm-hmm.

Paresh Patel executive
#35

Doing that is exactly why management gets paid. That doesn't mean we've pushed rates up 3%, or that we wrote a single new policy or anything like that. Right now you have to be considering larger upward moves, and that's precisely what we're doing, and that's where opportunity shows up for us, since we have a strong foundation to begin from. Mark mentioned $1 billion in shareholder equity, no debt, correct? Karen is talking about how smoothly the operations are running. You know, trying to make that better bit by bit almost feels like, you know, sort of swinging for a single at a moment when you ought to be aiming for home runs, and that's what we're attempting to do. Regarding our goals for M&A and other avenues of expansion, I can certainly address that.

Matt Carletti analyst
#36

Got it. That's very helpful. I appreciate the color. Thank you.

Paresh Patel executive
#37

Uh-huh.

Michael Phillips analyst
#38

Thanks. Good evening. My first question is — sorry if I missed this. I don't believe I did, but could you share the gross written premium figures for this quarter and last year, 4Q, excluding Citizens?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#39

Excluding Citizens? Yeah, this is Mark, hold on a second. You want gross premiums earned without Citizens?

Michael Phillips analyst
#40

If you've got that in writing, I'd rather have it that way—not earned.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#41

I don't believe I have it here with me.

Michael Phillips analyst
#42

All right, we can take a follow-up.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#43

Actually, hold on just a moment. Gross written premiums for Q4 came in at $333 million. I don't have the Citizens figure in front of me. My apologies.

Paresh Patel executive
#44

We'll get back to you on it, yeah?

Michael Phillips analyst
#45

Yeah. No problem. Thanks. I'll circle back. Thanks. Paresh, I want to verify I got what you said right. In a question earlier on, you mentioned buyers and sellers and that sort of gap — I believe your words were that sellers view 2025 as an average year. If that's what you said, it confuses me, since there were no cats. Is that what you're picking up from sellers, or did I mishear?

Paresh Patel executive
#46

No. Look, I think you've heard enough earnings calls over the past, just this week, from enough insurers, that everyone enjoyed a really strong 2025. For whatever reason, everyone's had a great 2025. I'd say whatever the reason, we know the reasons, but you catch my drift. The real question is: can 2025 be repeated over the next five years, or is it a peak earnings year, after which things will decline a little? Unless you've got a plan for how you grow from here to a bigger number, you wind up, you know, in some of these discussions. All that said, I'm not... You know, that's just life. That's how it goes. That's how it went, in 2014 too. Everyone assumed 2014, which in that decade proved to be a peak year, could be repeated annually from then on, right? The point there is, and you've just landed on the key item, right, that 2025 is repeatable, assuming no further hurricanes. We find that tough to build into our numbers, right? So, you know, that's the gap between buyers and sellers.

Michael Phillips analyst
#47

All right, yeah, thanks. Perhaps a fast question on figures for Mark regarding the expense ratio figures. I'm looking at net expense ratios. In the quarter, we're down quite sharply. I suppose I'd like a bit of clarification on that. I realize there's some quarter-to-quarter choppiness, definitely in the G&A expense. Any thoughts on how to think about the overall net expense ratio going forward?

Mark Harmsworth executive
#48

Yeah. You're comparing Q3- Q4, correct?

Michael Phillips analyst
#49

Well, not just Q3, but, you know.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#50

Yeah.

Michael Phillips analyst
#51

1 Q, 2 Q, 3 Q.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#52

Yeah. I mean, in Q4 the expense ratio came in lower than during a few earlier quarters, and that really just ties to how the accounting works for bonuses in Q4; a sizable share of the bonuses we paid out was in restricted shares, and those get expensed across a three or four-year period instead of in the current year. So Q4's expense ratio was lower, and if you look at what that ratio was, gross or net, in the second and third quarter, that's probably a better estimate of what you'd see going forward.

Michael Phillips analyst
#53

All right. Yeah, Mark, I was actually checking the net figure, but thanks — that's helpful. Okay, great. That was everything from me. Thanks a lot. Congratulations.

Mark Harmsworth executive
#54

Thanks.

Mark Hughes analyst
#55

Yeah, thanks. What's your sense of the timing on that $80 million buyback?

Paresh Patel executive
#56

Probably — obviously it depends on assorted minor regulatory requirements and so on — but it could start as soon as next week, or the week after that.

Mark Hughes analyst
#57

All right—for approval, or would you figure that you could get it done fairly fast?

Paresh Patel executive
#58

Yeah. Mark, okay, let's dig into the specifics of a few of these items. Given all of this and our effort to also be shareholder-friendly, we wanted everyone to be aware of it beforehand, you know, rather than having just a press release appear in the middle of the week or whatever. We want to be sure we cover it on the earnings call, and in reality, we must initiate it during an open window. For us, the open window will likely begin probably mid-next week. It's approximately in that sort of timeframe that we actually have to initiate it. That's what, you know, holds all of these things up, since we have to make sure we do it at the right time while, you know, ensuring all of our shareholders are amply informed, yeah, before it begins.

Mark Hughes analyst
#59

Yeah.

Paresh Patel executive
#60

That's why it's next week.

Mark Hughes analyst
#61

Okay. Thank you very much.

Paresh Patel executive
#62

Mm-hmm.

Paresh Patel executive
#63

The whole management team and I want to express our gratitude to shareholders, employees, and agents, and above all to our policyholders, for the support you keep giving us as we begin the coming stage of expansion. Thank you. We will make sure you stay updated going forward.

Operator operator
#64

That brings us to the end of today's call. You're welcome to hang up now. Thanks again for joining us.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete HCI Group, Inc. transcript - plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments and full-text search - through the EarningsAPI REST API or hosted MCP server.

Get an API key View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to HCI Group, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.