Home / Transcripts / Soluna Holdings, Inc. (SLNH) · November 15, 2022

Soluna Holdings, Inc. (SLNH) Earnings Call Transcript

November 15, 2022

NASDAQ US Information Technology Software earnings

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Michael Toporek executive
#1

Good morning, everyone. My name is Michael Toporek, and I serve as the Chief Executive Officer of Soluna Holdings. I appreciate you being here as we go through the review of our financial results for the third quarter of 2022; as always, we'll start with the standard preamble. Everything I'm about to say is fully subject to the legal disclosures found on the multiple pages that come after this one. What we aim to do is give you a window into some of the strategic thinking and financial analysis that guides how we grow this business. This conversation reflects our commitment to being accountable and transparent with those who hold shares. The economic world we function in is hyper-dynamic. In plain terms, that means circumstances shift fast. Everything we present here rests on our estimates and assumptions, which represent our best guess; we hold the right to update our view whenever new information arrives or the business environment changes. Even with a dynamic environment that's uncertain, planning is necessary, and so are operating and investment decisions. This presentation puts some of that in front of you for your review. Now I'd like to move on to laying out our core operating principles. The first one is alignment of interests, along with transparency and accountability. Brookstone Partners, the private equity firm I'm affiliated with, holds a bit less than 30% of the company's common equity. My sense is that this helps bring the senior decision-making into alignment, both at the board level and at the company level, when it comes to allocating capital, raising capital, and the overall operating principles of the company; it also helps align us economically with what common shareholders want. We are committed to high-velocity execution; by that I mean setting our goals and targets, then marshaling resources to get things done fast. You'll also see that from the beginning of this business, we've put emphasis on return on invested capital, on measuring that return, and on capital discipline in how we run things. We've also laid out for you a long-term strategy and vision that reaches past crypto mining into batchable computing and other high-density computing sectors. Soluna is a company built around solutions; we purchase curtailed energy, the unsold energy that renewable power generators have, and we turn it into clean, low-cost computing power. What the company does is take excess energy from renewable sources and funnel it toward powering batchable computing. Cryptocurrency is one example. Beyond crypto, Soluna's market opportunity is something we refer to as batchable computing. Essentially, that's computing power that can be switched on and off depending on whether resources are economically available from power generation. The digital currency market is the first market we're applying this to. Other sectors we think can gain from this kind of batch computing to deliver low-cost computing resources include pharmaceutical research, for instance, graphics and video processing, and every form of scientific research, whether academic or commercial; on the next set of slides there's an update on our financial results. I wanted to call out a few points about how we performed this quarter. As everyone is aware, the markets have been rather challenging throughout the third quarter. Revenue fell 26.6% for us, yet Bitcoin’s price averaged a 34.7% decline, and the average hashprice index dropped 34.3% as well. The reason we beat the market comes from our hash rate expanding, which let us mine roughly 12.4% more Bitcoin during the quarter. Let’s dig a bit deeper here; on the left panel, there’s a chart showing Bitcoin equivalent mined. You can see our steady climb from 36 to 56 to 143, 224, 267, and then reaching 300 in Q3; that’s a 5.4x rise year-over-year and slightly more than a 12% gain sequentially; we keep refining our miner setup and swapping out some older units for higher performance ones. Our proprietary hash rate has grown too, since we’re extracting the maximum from the machines we already have, and our peak hash rate, including hosted hash rate, exceeds an exahash. Turning to how we did versus the market, on the left side, you’ll see our revenue sequentially dropped 26.6%. While I don’t want to minimize that decline, because it is a large decrease, compared with both the hash price index, which measures revenue and profitability for hash rate delivered, we beat it by 7.7%, and we also beat the Bitcoin price decline by 8%. The clear explanation is that we keep getting the maximum and the best performance from our existing fleet of machines, and that has let us outperform the market. Here I show graphically for your review our revenue trend. It is plainly impacted by the drop in Bitcoin prices. As we said earlier, we have outperformed the Bitcoin price decline. If you look at our Q2 revenue, it rose by nearly 3x year-over-year. We keep building out a substantial company. Looking at Q3 consolidated net income, it was dominated by significant one-time non-cash items. I’ll get into a table of this as we work through the presentation. The biggest element of that was a $28 million write-down on fixed assets, $12 million loss as a consequence of debt extinguishment and revaluation. Also we have recently been carrying some SG&A costs as we prepare to energize Dorothy. Clearly, had Dorothy energized earlier, we wouldn’t suffer some of those negative economic consequences. Let’s look at the detail behind that net income number. Net income came in at -$56 million. Let’s break that down and take it to an adjusted EBITDA contribution number where we’re pulling out key non-cash items and certain items that are typically not included in EBITDA, for example, depreciation, interest, and taxes. We remove net income to EBITDA, which is a non-cash measure; we go from $56 million- $46 million by adjusting for the interest, tax benefit, and depreciation amortization. Let’s work through some of the non-cash items that have been working through our income statement. We recorded $890,000 in stock-based compensation expenses. We did dispose of some fixed assets, though that resulted in a loss relative to book value. A revaluation of certain financial instruments, along with debt extinguishment stemming from our convertible note amendment, took place. That too was a non-cash charge amounting to $12 million. We also recorded a $750,000 impairment on an equity investment related to our Harmattan project. On top of that, there was an impairment on certain ASICs we hold, which again represents a non-cash charge of $28 million. All of that brings us to an adjusted EBITDA contribution of $3.6 million. I'd like to use this moment to let you know that we've been managing our SG&A costs aggressively. We've made some headcount reductions and cut back significantly on activities, such that our normalized run rate SG&A — setting aside extraordinary transactions or events — sits at roughly $1.2 million per month, and we're working to keep bringing that down. In certain months it comes in somewhat lower, in others somewhat higher, but that figure is a solid average to keep in mind when you evaluate us. I believe we will examine our activities even more closely in an effort to drive that down nearer to $1 million per month.

Michael Toporek executive
#2

The significance here is that once Dorothy comes online, more of that surplus cash flow drops straight through to the bottom line. When it came to the operating environment during Q3, two or three things really stood out. To start with, all over North America there was an unexpected shift in energy costs that persisted for us across a couple of months, and relative to certain other companies in the industry, I'd say it stayed modest for us. Then you had the second element, which was hash rate continuing to climb, and the third element was Bitcoin prices staying persistently lower. Even with all of that working against us, our consolidated adjusted cash contribution keeps beating what others in the market are delivering, and on a consolidated basis it carries a 19% cash contribution margin. That said, when you look at site-level adjusted EBITDA, those factors — particularly the power price spike — pushed our unit economics into slightly negative EBITDA territory for the third quarter. Even so, that spike in power prices has come down, and I think the September fuel cost adjustment dropped 37%, so my expectation is a very different picture in Q4. Lower Bitcoin prices and greater difficulty, though, could cancel that out. With us getting ready to bring Dorothy online, I felt it mattered to update our economic model and walk you through it again, so investors can gain a clearer sense of what profit potential the site holds once energized. What you see on this slide centers on our deployment of S19s. Those are the roughly 100-terahash machines. We're showing you Dorothy One A along with Dorothy One B. Both are 25-MW portions of the 50 MW we anticipate switching on. Spring Lane Capital holds a 32% stake in Dorothy One A, while Soluna owns 100% of Dorothy One B. The scenarios we lay out cover 100% hosting, 50/50, and 100% prop mining. Let me zoom in on a few of the assumptions at the bottom, covering network hash rate, what we pay for power, and what we assume for hosting price. Given that we've actually gone out and done this, my belief is the revenue available to us from hosting could exceed that figure. Setting that question aside, the proper approach would be to work through, say, our cash flows. Under this model, Dorothy One A on the 50/50 basis would generate $384,000 each month; that figure then combines with the $565,000 coming from Dorothy One B under the 50/50 model. You add those two together; they represent two distinct components, and once we settle on which revenue model to pursue — which also carries implications for a different capital structure — we'll have a clearer picture of what each of those economic units could contribute monthly, meaning those 25 MW units forming Dorothy One A and Dorothy One B. As we work through our economic model for Dorothy, I believed it was important for you that we show the addition of the Bitmain XPs, the new 140-terahash chips that are far more power efficient and that we've been in discussions about with Bitmain. Once more, this is the identical chart layout, Dorothy One A plus Dorothy One B, spanning everything from 100% hosting through a 50/50 split all the way to 100% prop mining, and what you're seeing is the monthly cash contribution margin to Soluna. It's obvious that the cash contribution margin that results from operating this quicker, more energy-efficient chip comes in substantially higher. What really matters here will be what this chip costs in capital terms compared with the capital cost of the 100 MW chip, and that's a call we'll make at game time, only a few weeks out from energizing. That decision will rest on the pricing Bitmain and other marketplace participants give us on chips, along with possible hosting contracts. Like I said when we discussed net income earlier, we're watching our SG&A costs very closely, and I wanted to walk you through a bridge from our Q3 2021 SG&A over to our Q3 2022 SG&A. Before diving into those details, once more, as we stated in our press release, we've seen a meaningful reduction in headcount. We keep monitoring every SG&A expense for what I'd describe as non-essential items that don't deliver a quicker payback, while also balancing the need for certain expenditures so our business can have a growth path ahead. If you look at Q3 2021 SG&A, roughly $2.3 million sat in there. As we brought on staff for a new facility, extra wages and benefits and stock grants followed, and certain legal expenses arose from Project Dorothy moving forward along with the convertible debt amendment. On top of that, consulting and professional services showed up as a result of those complex transactions, Dorothy included. D&O expense and other insurance expenses shifted; beyond that, office IT, software, and miscellaneous costs moved by $274,000. A portion of that got offset by a $575,000 decrease in operations and management, or O&M, fees that we would have owed under our previous outside management regime. In the section coming up, I'll take a little time with you to go over the results of our facilities. Let's start with Sophie's review; during Q3, we had roughly $1 million in cash contribution margin. Given the current operating environment, the facility kept performing well, going from the July margin of, call it, 30% to 36% in September. Once again, we had those July and August shifts in electricity costs, which show up in our figures of $6.11 and $6.81 for July and August, followed by a return to $4.51, which starts putting us back on track toward more historical norms. Our Sophie facility also started moving back toward its June level of profitability, pushed by a reduction in power cost and a new hosting agreement. The cash contribution margin came back to $202,000, a touch below the June figure yet far lower than what we saw in April and May, when Bitcoin prices stood much higher. As I mentioned on an earlier page, if you glance at a few of these operating metrics briefly, the largest factor that has shifted is the Bitcoin price, which should surprise no one. April's realized Bitcoin price was $41,000, May $31,000, June $24,000. Come September, it reached $20,000. Our Bitcoin equivalent mined did rise thanks to our work optimizing our own hash rate along with that of our hosting customer, yet plainly this was not sufficient to counter the drop in Bitcoin price. If you examine the company's consolidated non-GAAP historical financials for the quarter, you will notice that during the quarter, particularly in September, we started recovering on profitability, getting nearer to the June level. Though with Bitcoin pricing so difficult, it remains considerably under the June level, it has nonetheless rebounded from the July-August level, when we saw that surge in energy power. Energy power has yet to come back to April and May levels, but it is making solid progress; still, the recent Bitcoin pricing clearly puts some pressure on our top line. Turning to a few of the consolidated operating metrics, I would simply direct your attention to the Q3 Bitcoin equivalent mined.

Michael Toporek executive
#3

During the quarter, we mined roughly 300 Bitcoin. That figure is higher than what we saw in Q2, and we're still doing a good job managing our hash rate, plus I'm very happy with how the team is working to get the most out of our assets. Even so, that simply can't offset the movement in Bitcoin's price, which went from $24,000 to $21,000, fluctuated around $22,000, and then dropped to $19,000 right at the close of the September quarter, compared with Q2, when the average Bitcoin price was approximately $32,000 — sorry, I mean relative to Q2, which saw an average Bitcoin price of roughly $32,000; in Q3, the average Bitcoin price came in at approximately $21,000. That represents a significant gap in revenue, and it isn't something we could fully offset just by improving the mix of our equipment, though it does help. I appreciate your joining me today and going over the specifics of our Q3 report. If you have any questions, don't hesitate to contact us directly via our website or reach out to our investor relations team at MZ Group. Thanks once more for your time. After this, you'll find appendices containing more detailed information, in particular a reconciliation of non-GAAP operating results to the closest comparable GAAP figures. Thanks again.

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Soluna Holdings, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsAPI REST API and the hosted MCP server. Quarterly plans from $162 - full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.